Mini 1194: Reverse Mafia [Game Over]

[Parama]

deathnote
999
spongebob

two of them are meme-ish in quality, one is just because I felt like spoiling a major plot point in a game and also looking evil

[Packbat]

Fair enough.

[MrTrow]

noticed the hammer, this no longer matters but:

That's possible if he was scum - I don't think it's as probable as town making the error honestly, but it isn't in any way ludicrous.

Thanks, guess i'm not completely insane then.

Not accurate. In the unvote-Pack post, #188, he quotes

me

saying that, but still lists Packbat over Bub Bidderskins:

True, noted and corrected a few pages ago.

- only calls SC out for 'anyone who ignores me or parama is scum' ,parama is no better (understatement) in that respect.
- Split the town in 2 groups on this matter and calls for a decision based on the entire group. 'someone who looks scummy agrees with you -> you must be scum'

Could you elaborate on these?

1. Although SC`s post to which that was a response, Parama`s ignoring or refuting my awesomeness is a scumtell was a lot worse than that one post by SC, yet he only calls SC out on it -> possible connection
2. his ' this turns into 'list of generally considered townier players who don`t dispute the slip' vs 'list of considered scummier or less skilled players who do'.'
suggests the opinions people have on players other than the one in my case/myself is relevant to the case (via PoE it may be but that`s pretty much it)

Parama:

Skipping most of this because:

One could argue he performed the towntell instead but no he did not.

Why do you say he didn't? Start at the gg gambit and you seem him go "I knew Pack was scum the whole time" #287/#292. That looks hella like a townslip to me.

That is indeed what it looks like, however in the post i linked to he admitted the thought it wasn`t true has at least crossed his mind.
If he knew (or in any way expected) the 'we win'-claim to be false, how does it still have any meaning he acted like he believed it.

-----------
As for the pictures: LOL

especially the first one:
The most awesome scum ever.

(That time he was right)

In fact it came from one of the episodes i was watching while writing the case.

[Parama]

BTW, read the endgame of Mini 973. I stole two pictures from there <_<
It's also the best endgame ever.

[MrTrow]

That was indeed pure awesome (although 1 pic is now missing).

[AntB]

spongebob bewbs face is always awesome, no matter the situation.

[Parama]

Fun fact: I know Pie from SH and we got to see an even more elaborate I WIN --> I LOSE reaction in mafiahero.

[Parama]

but yeah anyways I'm town and Toasty is town sup

[ToastyToast]

but yeah anyways I'm town and Toasty is town sup

<3

On our way to a win!

[kiwieagle]

So your not scum?


....


ok then now what.


Im I gonna have to reread?






ok then.


maybe malp and bobsnox.
wouldnt know about the 3rd tho

[bobsnox]

would you guys revive me if I promise to shoot kiwi? <_<

[ToastyToast]

would you guys revive me if I promise to shoot kiwi? <_<

lolno

[Packbat]

Wow - I'm

allergic

to kiwi and I'm not as enthusiastic as bobsnox to shoot kiwieagle.

[bobsnox]

I mean, I like killing scum, what can I say?

[ChannelDelibird]

End of Day 1 Vote Count

ToastyToast - 2 (Parama, Packbat)

Not voting - 1 (crypto)

ToastyToast has been revived.

It is now

Night 2

. Night deadline is 72 hours from this post, although the thread may stay locked for a little longer than that as I may have some work commitments on Saturday afternoon. Any night talk or actions however MUST finish by the 72-hour deadline. Killing roles are now potentially operational.

[ChannelDelibird]

Morning of Day 2

Four went to sleep and four awake.

However, an impenetrable aura surrounds

StrangerCoug

today. He is ineligible to be voted for today.

Parama, Packbat, crypto, and ToastyToast are alive.

With 4 alive, it will take 3 votes to revive a player from Limbo.

Day deadline is 3 weeks from this post.

[malpascp]

No NK? That sounds weird...

Also I didn't get if the SC's ineligibility is due to some PR or what. I guess I will re-read carefully the Rules.

[Parama]

THIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIS
WAS A TRIIIIIIIIIIIIIUMPH

Malp you know as well a I do what a no NK means. Unless scum are playing silly games with us (and there is no good reason for them to not kill) it means we have four living town players. Or an afk crypto-scum, but crypto's town so.

By my math, a town-vive today wins us the game.
5 living town players, 7 players in limbo - even if there's only two scum, that'll be 5 of 10 town players alive, which is half the total pro-town players. And if there's 3 scum, then it's 5 players of out 9, which is over half. Woopity wop let's win this game today.

[Parama]

EBWOP:
Forgot to mention, but this was a huge success.

[Packbat]

EBWOP:
Forgot to mention, but this was a huge success.

I'll make a note here, and try not to overstate your satisfaction.

I

did

want to mention, just for completeness sake, that

if

there were one scum in town they could still win after a no-kill as long as they revived scum today ... but I don't think that's the case. On which theme, as Toasty said yesterday:

So basically this is turning into Parama-TT-crypto-Bub-Pom-AntB vs. kiwi-malpascp-MrTrow-bobsnox, with SC and Packbat as swing votes
Tell me: which side is townier?

In my opinion, we should revive one of {Bub Bidderskins, Pomegranate, AntB} today. My own preferences fall in roughly that exact order, but I'm flexible - anyone have particular praises or objections to members on that list?

[StrangerCoug]

However, an impenetrable aura surrounds

StrangerCoug

today. He is ineligible to be voted for today.

Damn it.

5 living town players, 7 players in limbo - even if there's only two scum, that'll be 5 of 10 town players alive, which is half the total pro-town players. And if there's 3 scum, then it's 5 players of out 9, which is over half. Woopity wop let's win this game today.

This is the good news, though.

The people against the ToastyToast revival now look even worse. Again, they're not all scum, but we're best off not touching this group if we want to secure a win today.

I still support Bub Bidderskins, but Pomegranate's actions toward the end of yesterday make her a good revival target in my eyes.

[Packbat]

However, an impenetrable aura surrounds

StrangerCoug

today. He is ineligible to be voted for today.

Damn it.

You were the logical choice, as the scummiest potential revive candidate.

[kiwieagle]

Mmk

Bit of a suprise.

I was against toast = I know I wont get revived, but I know im town so I dont think trow is scum.

So if we revive one of {bud , antb, pom }

I would prefer... bud.


Not pom.

[Parama]

I had to swing votes away from Bub yesterday and I'm sure as hell going to make sure he doesn't get revived today either.
No offense Bub but my conspiracy theory is still a possibility so

vote: Pome

[kiwieagle]

Meh I was close enough with my scum reads ^^