Jason wrote:Urgh, Pine timed out again for 3rd time, not 2nd, sorry. However with so many needing replacements I am very hesitant to force replace him
MOD – It is of my opinion that you need to replace him. This isn’t the only game he’s picked up prods and failed to post in multiple times (to his faction’s detriment in at least one game).
--
Silver wrote:Stop trying to twist the same "reasoning" to further "implicate" my other head. It's somewhat scummy to not post in a game while posting elsewhere to a degree. It's incredibly scummy to respond to prods, make posts promising to catchup while doing no such thing and all the while still posting in other games
It’s not twisting your reasoning. You are trying to split hairs on what ‘level’ of inactivity in this game while being active elsewhere is scummy.
For the record this isn’t the only game Pine is “active flaking” from. So this game isn’t the sort of isolated incident that would indicate it is a Scum-tell unless he is scum in every game where it is happening.
--
Pappums wrote:Relative newcomer, yes, but he has at the very least finished a large theme game here. IDK WTF Vifam's level of play has been here.
I never said Zinger did a "good job" of scumhunting, I said "he did some pretty decent scumhunting". By this I meant he was actively scumhunting and contributing to the game, not that he was "raping da scumz".
Butting heads with you and ignoring you does not mean he wasnt scumhunting in that game.
You are splitting hairs as to what consititues a ‘Newbie’ in a way that makes me very suspicious of your defense of Vifam / Junpei.
Please provide me with post numbers that showed Zinger doing “decent scum-hunting” in Superhero Mafia. I don’t recall anything but some OMGUS accusations Day 1 and a string of mostly bad / unacceptable Vig shots.
Pappums wrote:Could everyone please tell me in what order they rank the following possibilities:
Sure, I’ll rank them if you can tell me what good this little exercise is to scum-hunting. You don’t even bother to ask for a weighting of those options.
And please justify why, under minimal pressure, you think Scum would ACTIVELY claim Third Party as Zinger did. I’d really like to hear the logic that places 2 as a viable option.
--
Zel1nk wrote:- He soft-claimed vanilla on the last page. And it was a genuine softclaim, not an I'm-scum-gambiting-so-maybe-people-will-think-I'm-town softclaim
Um, no.
He’s using the “I’ll go concessionary and hope people say “Scum never do that” to get me off the lynch” route. That I've seen used by scum before. Could he be doing it as Town? Certainly possible. Thus it’s Null and doesn’t absolve him of the rest of his play.
--
Zinger wrote:@Everyone voting me: will you pledge to eat your hat when I flip town? Kthxbai.
Why should they? Your play has been scumtastic. The only reason I’ve not driven your wagon to completion is you’ve ‘retracted’ your gambit and claimed a Town PowerRole.
--
Junpei wrote:So Jailkeeper is more important than tracker or cop?
This is a scummy mis-rep at
1139
. Nowhere in the quote of Zinger’s post does he come even close to saying Jailkeepers are more important thank information roles.
--
"I am a leaf on the wind ... watch how I soar!"
Pretty much Geriatric game restricted at this point ... unless there are players I REALLY want to play with.
100% chance vs 75%, seriously; theres no way hes town
