I don't find Gilda particularly likely. Gilda wanted Rainbow Dash all to
herself
, and continually tried to separate the main characters so that she was always alone with Rainbow Dash. Having Gilda make a Neighborhood that purposefully excluded herself, then, does not seem consistent with the flavor at all.
"Aperture Science: We do what we must because we can."
I love guessing games! My guess is that a Discord neighbourizer would be the grrrrrreat and powerful Trixie! (as GLaDOS previously mentioned)
Anyhoo, I still think those bunch of interactions up there are Town.
I'd like to remind every
pony
body that hardcore lurkers early game were Pinkie Pie and LobsterCatapult's slot, Fluttershy. And I advocate a lynch the lurkers policy before getting to LyLo.
Except for the whole fact that Trixie turns out to be a fraud, and never encouraged friendship in any of its forms. I especially doubt she would have a role that encourages friendship between two ponies that does not include herself.
I'm going to kindly but firmly request that those voting for Jahudo unvote in your next post.
If anything, my conversation with inHimshallibe and Charlie just now have pretty much solidified my thinking that Jahudo is Town.
"Aperture Science: We do what we must because we can."
Now, now, My Little GLaDOS, let's not be overthinking about the logic here. Too much thinking and the next thing you would be wondering is how Earth Ponies built Ponyville with hooves. Point is, this is setup speculation which although is nice; doesn't really serve a purpose in terms of hunting Discord.
GLaDOS wrote:
I'm going to kindly but firmly request that those voting for Jahudo unvote in your next post.
If anything, my conversation with inHimshallibe and Charlie just now have pretty much solidified my thinking that Jahudo is Town.
And which pony exactly should be lynched Today? Oh, and would you help me lynch Pinkie Pie?
GLaDOS, Post 838 wrote:Everybody who is voting for Jahudo (or has indicated that they will vote for Jahudo) should really think about both of these points. Because they certainly caused me to go from near-total conviction to seriously thinking he is Town. I'm thinking this is a mislynch, and so I would rather be lynching somebody else.
(Unfortunately, I'm annoyed that I'm not quite sure who that somebody else is, but I am pretty much down to the pool of inHimshallibe, LobsterCatapult, and possibly Pinkie Pie).
"Aperture Science: We do what we must because we can."
inHimshallibe wrote:Now we have half of a Neighbor pair dead, that being CES, whose vote of Mina could actually have been interpreted as a soft counter claim, now that I think about it andit'sallcomingtogetherforme.
Why is it suspicious that half of the neighbor pair died? If you think I'm lying about the neighbor power being a 1-shot, then give a reason why I'd lie about that? Why would I lie about any part of my role?
I can understand wondering if scum thought CES was a power role but how does that tie to me?
inHim wrote:Jahudo didn't immediately believe or disbelieve Mina's claim, just said it would be hard to test.
There wasn't anything that stood out from the claim to say it looked fake or not, so once I realized it couldn't be tested properly I decided to ignore it and just stick with my scum read.
inHim wrote:Then I said I'd Lynch Mina before No Lynching, and CES plops down a vote, so Jahudo decides to jump in for cred ahead of my eventual hammer.
You said that, but I jumped in because I already thought you were scum so why should I trust your word? Even if I'm wrong about you, I didn't prefer a LC lynch and it looked like Charlie would have jumped on the wagon, and CES might have liked that wagon just as well. Add a Mina vote and its becomes the largest wagon.
Lol, I just realized the effort took by inHimshallibe in finding that list in 849. You could have just asked, you know. From what I can tell there are 3 players who are content/theme/flavour experts: Jahudo, myself (self-proclaimed as I've seen all the episodes + spent a good deal of time with the fanfic/fanart/games/memes/etc.) and the replaced Equinox.
Actually, this is a valid tell that makes me think you're Town, since Discord would get Night-talk and thus more likely to be well informed of the theme. Unless you're faking it... Dammit WIFOM.
-------------
I'm totally going against my read here and placing inHimshallibe at L-1 with this: UNVOTE: Pinkie Pie VOTE: inHimshallibe
Whoever Pinkie Pie wants to hammer, he'd better justify it.
I'm not interested in spicing things up. I'm interested in lynching scum. I'm not so confident in inHimshallibe being scum that I would leave him (or put him) at L-1.
"Aperture Science: We do what we must because we can."
to catch up, i picked pinkie pie at the time because i think they are both scummy....so why not take out my top 1 and 2 scum picks in 1 day if i could, since the jahudo wagon seems/ed to be going through.
@inhim, why hang me if jahudo is lynched and flips town?
at your 838 glados, your first point to her quote out of context i agree could indeed be both ways, not just the buddying/distancing sense. her 483 is so waffly on jahudo, i think the entire intent of the post was to not give away either way whether it was buddying/distancing, or a subvert attempt to get her lynched. her "REALLY mixed vibes" part and the "recent posts are townish" parts, coupled with the "naaahh" part you pointed out, gives the whole post a "starting out null....now town.....could be scum....nah prolly town/null" with it ending on a slight negative, it could be interpretted as either scum distancing from itself, or scum trying to egg on a mislynch.
I'm undecided looking at it:
my gut, along with jahudo's play, makes me feel like this its more of a buddying/distancing ploy,
your 2nd point, again seems to be taken either way. set up wise, would it be fair to town for scum to have the "stronger" neighborizor? and also why would that necessarily benefit scum to have the stronger neighborizor?
also...at charlie. what in the hell? pinkiepie's last content post said that she saw inhim, along with others as town. why would putting inhim at L-1 make any sort of effect on Pinkie Pie's decision? you putting inhim at L-1, for the sheer reason of "mixing things up" or for giving pinkie pie more pressure to make a decision is....dumb.
charlie's vote makes me think that maaaaaaaybe i'm just more annoyed with pinkie pie's actual playstyle, and this is coloring my thinking. we have a little under a week till deadline. ill mull this over. consider my "hot potato" answer on hold due to this.
ÔÇ£IÔÇÖll do what I can to help yÔÇÖall. But, the gameÔÇÖs out there, and itÔÇÖs play or get played. That simpleÔÇØ ÔÇô Omar
~LC
Why is Feysal a suspect for you glados? What do you think of Mina's attempts to get Espy lynched?
LobsterCatapult wrote:there is to me, no other way to see jahudo's post except as fishing.
If you are still holding onto this viewpoint can you explain it more than just saying the general scumtell?
I clearly was asking if the information had already been given, and even if I was trying to uncover a neighborizer power how is that not called counter-claiming?
Hypothetically if you were a power role in a game and heard there might be another person with your role, how would you react? Just ignore it, I don't think so. I think its natural to be curious that there might be a counter-claim situation and what that might lead to.
Charlie, whyyyyyy? If it's for the sake of seeing something out of Pinkie Pie, vote Pinkie Pie. Your read is correct, your vote is not. Now get it on someone you actually think is scum.
Given GLaDOS's unvote and behavior, he's town. Given THAT
unvote
Current thoughts would be: LC -> Feysal -> Pinkie Pie
LC, you asked why you if Jahudo is Town. I didn't see you as a partner of Jahudo, but I saw you as having the highest absolute value of scumminess. A combination of lurking, weak reads, stalling, and voting record. And the death of CES.
I don't have enough time today at work to pore over this again right now. I'll try in the afternoon, but right now I have to mod and that's it.
I still don't see how my role did not live up to the expectations that I know from my role PM and shared yesterday before we tested it. I guess I'm not going to get that information but the people that know more about the setup better have good reasons for setup speculating this much.
My top three suspects are inHim, Lobster, Charlie in that order. Pinkie and Feysal look town despite what people are saying.
