Any Band U-Pick (Town Wins)

[Magua]

Hooray for reading the thread.

Nikanor is town.

CMAR is scum.

Diddin is more scum.

Gorilla and Regfan are both town.

Trumpet of Doom is null.

Groundsel is town, but this is based off of one meta piece of information rather than playstyle.

DemonHybrid is scummy, but, goddamn, I really felt DemonHybrid was scummy in 00s Mafia as well, so I'm very indecisive on this one.

Explanation for any of these reads is not available upon request.

VOTE: diddin

[Faraday]

Vote Count 3.05

Gaoth(0):
Demonhybrid(0):
Regfan(0):
Diddin(3): Regfan, Nikanor, Magua
CryMeARiver(0):
Tarsonisocelot(4): Trumpet of Doom, diddin, Seraphim, CryMeARiver
Bowser(0):
Magua(0):
Seraphim(0):
Nikanor(0):
Trumpet Of Doom(0):
Groundsel(0):
Cogito Ergo Sum(0):
Gorilla(4): Cogito Ergo Sum, Bowser, Magua, Gaoth

Not Voting:

Tarsonisocelot, Groundsel, DemonHybrid, Gorilla

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch and 7 to no lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2011-08-07 15:30:00)

CES and Bowser are V/lA
Magua is a n00b, but happy birthday!

[Magua]

Magua is a n00b, but happy birthday!

im

12

13 years old and what is this

[Slaxx]

FUUUU both

And fuckin lol@ MAgua

[diddin]

You have two votes on you, diddin. Why do you want to claim so badly?

Deadline is running down, so I would like to claim early enough to not be deadline lynched.

Regfan still hasn't said why I'm scum so yeah.

[Nikanor]

What, you think REGFAN is scum?
Lol.

[Seraphim]

Unvote
Vote: diddin

[diddin]

Never said Regfan is scum, he just never explained the vote on me that he said he would explain.

[Nikanor]

Never said Regfan is scum, he just never explained the vote on me that he said he would explain.

Oh hey you responded exactly how I expected you to respond. With, "His vote is invalid because he didn't explain it."
More diddin votes please.

[Magua]

Let's just skip the "actually voting diddin" part and get to the "diddin claims" part so we can get to the "lololololol lynch diddin" part.

[diddin]

Well I can't defend myself from an attack that hasn't been posted, valid or not. He promised an explanation, and hasn't given one yet.

[Nikanor]

I don't expect you to defend yourself, diddin. I expect you to die.

[Trumpet of Doom]

Not getting on the diddin wagon yet - I think I've specified what wagons I'd prefer, and there's still time till deadline - but I'm okay with it (IIRC, my biggest obstacle to thinking he's scum was that I thought epm was more likely to be, and that's no longer the case), and if needed I will join it.

[DemonHybrid]

CMaR is far from scum. There is no scum motivation of pointing out a non-existent scum tell. But he's definitely not smart in the ways of scumhunting.

I might be okay with the diddin lynch, but he wasn't involved with the gorilla wagon at all, so that worries me. Thoughts?

[Magua]

CMaR is far from scum. There is no scum motivation of pointing out a non-existent scum tell.

The scum motivation to point out a non-existent scumtell seems self evident to me.

I might be okay with the diddin lynch, but he wasn't involved with the gorilla wagon at all, so that worries me. Thoughts?

Do you think those involved in the gorilla wagon are more likely to be scum?

If so, why are you not voting any of them?

[DemonHybrid]

I asked for a votecount of the gorilla wagon right before people started taking off their votes; I haven't had time to tally them together.

[DemonHybrid]

And yeah, I think the late gorilla voters are suspect depending on who they are. Let me do that now.

Also, explain why pointing out a non-existent scumtell has scum motivation. Don't scum want to hang back and not take a risk like that?

[DemonHybrid]

gorilla wagon:

Regfan, Nikanor, DH

(votecount)

CES, Bowser, nintendo, Gaoth

Nikanor switches to Gaoth, and the wagon falls apart.

Hm.

[DemonHybrid]

Unvote, Vote: Gaoth

[Magua]

Also, explain why pointing out a non-existent scumtell has scum motivation. Don't scum want to hang back and not take a risk like that?

Scum need to get town lynched. Though town are sometimes perfectly willing and able to lynch themselves, usually scum need to be able to build a case on a town. Enter in the non-existent scumtell.

Not to mention the whole "the moment you say 'scum want to hang back and not take a risk', you incentivize scum to take a risk" bit.

Nikanor switches to Gaoth, and the wagon falls apart.

Wouldn't the wagon falling apart quickly be more of an evidence that *gorilla* was scum than Gaoth was scum?

Or are you saying that Nikanor is that much of a bad-ass?

[Regfan]

Only got a few minutes so I'll bullet point this:

- Magua explain your town-meta-read on Groundsel please. Also your read on Seraphim and Bowser would be nice.

- Diddin, the reasoning behind my vote on you is your complete filler posts, your position on the EPM and Poweroox lynches and your complete lack of scum hunting. There's no signs of even an attempt at doing so from you. You've already soft-pr claimed at this point so you may as well fully claim in your next post please.

[Magua]

- Magua explain your town-meta-read on Groundsel please.

No. But holy fuck, has he really not posted for two weeks? What the hell?

@Mods:

I assume that you've PM'ed Twistedspoon to make sure he's still in the game, y/n?

Also your read on Seraphim and Bowser would be nice.

Very null. I sat down and read the whole thing through in one reading, and what I wrote is what I had when I was done. Neither Seraphim nor Bowser/CSL made much of a dent on me.

So I checked back. Seraphim seems town enough; I'm not going to sheep his vote or anything, but he at least seems like he's trying. Null-to-town.

CSL/Bowser has -- now, keep in mind, I know I'm town -- only voted town, with the very last exception of his vote on gorilla, who I'm only sure is town. That's just an incredibly bad track record, even for someone voting by random chance.

So, I'll toss him in the scum bucket because why not?

[Slaxx]

Yes he is.

[Nikanor]

CSL/Bowser has -- now, keep in mind, I know I'm town -- only voted town, with the very last exception of his vote on gorilla, who I'm only sure is town. That's just an incredibly bad track record, even for someone voting by random chance.

CSL/Bowser

[Magua]

CHESSKID