Mini 1202 Smalltown Mafia (Game Over!)

[Beck]

I dont get that at all from his vote. He attacks Bob's flawed reasonings and poor use of NK analysis.

Bob asked for me to provide reasons why Juls could have been killed, I provided like 7 or 8

He dismisses them all based on occums razor or whaterver, and sticks with his own. He isn't playing with an open mind at all, he realizes he is caught and is trying to get me lynched instead (or was). When that fails he joins his counter wagon.

[bobsnox]

do you know what ockham's razor is beck? <_<

[Beck]

No I don't

[Zachrulez]

4th vote count of day 2:

bobsnox - 3 (Hiplop, Beck, pappums rat)
pappums rat - 3 (charter, bobsnox, VP Baltar)

Not voting (Phoebus)

With 7 alive it's 4 to lynch.

Day 2 will end no later than Thursday August 11th at 11am CST.

[Beck]

So Phoebus was supposed to be available starting today...

I eagerly await his/her arrival. Somebody needs to bring life to this game.

[Beck]

Not like it will matter much but I will be at the park of Hershey tomorrow all day

[charter]

I'd be down for a Phoebus quicklynch on this page. I'm tired of his excuses. Post or replace. And we can lynch your replacement.

On the other hand, anyone who hammers Pappums will garner infinite town points. What a good deal!

[Beck]

Same for anyone who hammers bob

Did pap's even claim yet?

[charter]

Except Pappums is

actually

going to flip scum. Why are you so against a Pappums lynch? How can you possibly think he's town?

I guess he can claim if he has some useful info, but no claim will stop his lynch.

[Beck]

maybe I just don't understand his wagon, it seems like a counter wagon to the bob wagon. let me re-read him this weekend.

[charter]

I'm voting him because he is scum. Balter is voting him because he is scum. Bobs is voting him because he doesn't want to be lynched. You can't argue against that.

On the other hand, the Bobs wagon has Hiplop the clueless, Pappums the scumbag, and yourself the soon to switch to Pappums.

[Beck]

Well when you put it that way...

[charter]

i know right

[Beck]

I still want to re-read

If Phoebus hasn't posted before I get back from my trip, I'm turbo lynching him

[pappums rat]

My case on bobsnox is pretty much the definition of :goodposting: and brings forth real, legitimate points against bobscum, and the way VP and charter are pushing my lynch is absolute horseshit.

It's more about the shape of things. People were slobbering all over him immediately. that puts me off a bit.

That is usually what happens when obvscum comes out of the gate with a horrible "case" based soley on the NK of someone.

If anyone looks at how Pappums was playing before anyone was suspicious of him and how he's playing since the last few days of day one, you will notice a dramatic difference.

I don't often go out on a limb like this, but I can count the number of scumbags I've been more sure about on one hand. I'm less sure of people I get guilty investigations on.

Well duh, obviously there is going to be a difference because WHEN THERE IS PRESSURE ON YOU YOU DEFEND YOURSELF. I am still pushing my scumread and trying to get scum lynched, but now I have to deal with the shit-reasoning behind people voting me as well.

How about you contribute to the game now, mmkay?

In what way am I not contributing to the game? I have given my reads and have made a case on bobsnox. I'm not going to blather nonstop about nothing. When things need to be said I say them.

I find it troubling that both charter and VP Baltar, who are both quality players, have no problem with bobsnox's terrible reasoning and play. Not to mention he replaced FUCKING BUDJA.

You have given no reads other than your weak suspicion of Bobs. There are plenty of other players to comment on without blathering nonstop about nothing. Ask Phoebus some questions, lord knows he needs some reasons to start posting.

Bullshit, read the fucking thread, I gave my thoughts on everyone, and they have remained unchanged until recently. I'm not going to ask Phoebus questions because I dont feel like I need to. If you want to give him reasons to start posting, then YOU ask him questions, I am going to play the game the way I play it.

Weren't you one of the people questioning bob out of the box?

Yeah, cause I was trying to figure out his alignment and reasons. That's different from "LOL BOBS HAMMERED> VOTE: BOBSCUM"

whos doing that

You're the worst offender. Pappums' vote post also has a distinct tang of 'I don't care what your actual reasons were'.

ROFLMAO. And what exactly gave it that?

Except Pappums is

actually

going to flip scum. Why are you so against a Pappums lynch? How can you possibly think he's town?

I guess he can claim if he has some useful info, but no claim will stop his lynch.

This is just a terrible post, desperately begging for Beck to change his mind with excellent reasoning as "how can you possibly think he's town?" LMAO.

I think the scum pool is down to:
bobsnox
charter
VP Baltar

In that order. They completely shrugged off bobsnox's FUCKING GODAWFUL shit-attempt at a case on Beck COMPLETELY BASED ON THE NK and then jumped onto an OMGUSwagon saying I was "opportunistic" and that I was "going for a soft target" when I made a solid case on bobsnox.

p. edit: Beck, what the fuck, seriously... fucking THAT made you decide to speedlynch me? ROFLMAO.

[Beck]

Not lynch you, lynch Phoebus. Duh

[pappums rat]

oic... nvm then.

[charter]

After that post, you should speedlynch him, Beck. That's the protown thing to do. I mean, his scum list is the people that are voting him. IT'S NOT ROCKET SCIENCE...

[pappums rat]

FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF

ONE OF THE PEOPLE ON MY SCUMLIST ONLY VOTED ME AS OMGUS I VOTED HIM FIRST AND THE OTHER TWO ARE USING BULLSHIT REASONING FOR PUSHING MY LYNCH. DURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Self-detonate with: charter

I'll see you in hell scumbag.

Lynch bobsnox tomorrow kthxbai

[charter]

Lol
Nice try

[charter]

Self protect: charter

MUWAHAHAHAHAHAH

[Beck]

[pappums rat]

Lol
Nice try

^ Scumslip.

charterscum thought I was gambiting to see what his reaction would be, and so wrote "nice try" because he wasnt going to be so easily duped into going "aw shucks. go scum!" But, in effect, this post would have had basically the same scumfinding value if we were not dead.

[Beck]

So is it a gambit or real?

I hate gambits

[charter]

lol

It's impossible to replace the top three surefire scum reads I've ever had, but Pappums, you are now at the fourth most sure I have ever been about someone being scum. Congratulations.