My Little Pony Mafia - GENOCIDAL FRIENDSHIP PONIES

[hohum]

The way you claimed was just wrong.

Please disclose all information.
A zebra isn't a pony. ^_^
Look at the flips. Your claim isn't consistent.
Miller-Zecora fits, but... No, I don't think you're one.

I'd wait until she claims what fluttershy saw on N1 before rushing to judgement. You know exactly what I'm referring to too. I'd unvote if I were you. I don't want LC hammered until she answers this question.

[Charlie]

Have an UNVOTE: LobsterCatapult while you answer some questions.

[Charlie]

Ah, ninja'd.

[LobsterCatapult]

primate targetted you n1.

which...makes me think that primate is town. you looked like town d1, and with jahudo targetting you, I'm leaning town on primate, probability also favors that he is most likely town, not a scum power-role.

i didnt claim because fluttershy didnt claim d1...and ive never been miller anything before, much less miller watcher. @_@

but my play has been shit lately, and the possibility of a investigation, im not terribly surprised my wagon formed, but i AM surprised how quickly it formed.

and i know the way i claimed was retarded. also, i had no idea that zecora wasnt a pony. i figured she was just a zebra pony.

[hohum]

primate targetted you n1.

which...makes me think that primate is town. you looked like town d1, and with jahudo targetting you, I'm leaning town on primate, probability also favors that he is most likely town, not a scum power-role.

i didnt claim because fluttershy didnt claim d1...and ive never been miller anything before, much less miller watcher. @_@

but my play has been shit lately, and the possibility of a investigation, im not terribly surprised my wagon formed, but i AM surprised how quickly it formed.

and i know the way i claimed was retarded. also, i had no idea that zecora wasnt a pony. i figured she was just a zebra pony.

I like this post.

ATTENTION EVERYPONY! LC IS NOT SCUM. DO.. NOT... LYNCH...

PLZ TO BE CLIMBING BACK ONTO THE JAHUDO WAGON KTHNX BAI

[Twilight Sparkle]

Day 3, Votecount #7

LobsterCatapult:

Pinkie Pie,

Charlie

, Primate, inHimshallibe (L-2)

Jahudo:

hohum,

Primate

, LobsterCatapult (L-3)

Inhimshallibe:

Jahudo, Feysal (L-3)

Pinkie Pie:

Charlie

Not voting:

GlaDOS,

inHimshallibe.

Charlie

Day 3 deadline

Deadline is in (expired on 2011-08-07 22:25:00), so that's the 8th of August at 3:25am Irish time. (Or 10:25 East Coast of America)

With 9 alive it's 5 to lynch

[hohum]

If I can't get a jahudo lynch today I'll take a pinkie pie lynch.

[Charlie]

Ugh, LobsterCatapult...go ISO Jahudo, that's the proper way to claim. Also, you might find a picture of a light blue equine with a mulit-coloured mane placing her hoof to her face. I'm not sure.

Let's try this: VOTE: Pinkie Pie

[Jahudo]

The secret stuff is getting so elaborate and involving that I'm just going to trust it. Two scums apparently couldn't fabricate it all and mislead any townies caught up in it from what I can gather. And it doesn't matter that he said pony instead of zebra. No LC lynch.

I still don't like a Pinkie Pie lynch.
Who has a decent theory on how Pinkie and Mina's interactions could be scum-scum?
Who has a case that goes beyond things Katsuki has been known to do as town (lurk, not explain reads)

If I felt there was some good evidence I would say now is the perfect time to lynch an anti-town lurker that also looks like scum. But he just looks like an unhelpful lurker. And if he's town we don't have as much good information as we can have if we do pick between myself and inHim today. That seems like a more prudent option today.

[Primate]

Not uncommon scum role claiming miller?

HMMMMMMM

[Primate]

@Hohum: Do you think miller means there's a cop in the setup?

[Primate]

Does beg the question though that if I was seen n1 targeting a perceived pro-towner by scum why wasn't I shot N2 for being beneficial/protective.

[Primate]

I'm not saying I am a beneficial/protective non-vanilla role, just that that would be the perception. Obviously scum LC wouldn't know for sure from watcher results.

[Primate]

Glados can you please come and tell me whether I'm being obtuse by staying voting LC, I can't tell anymore.

[LobsterCatapult]

well, im not one for lots of set-up speculation, but we probably have a cop or some other investigative role if im miller, and mina flipped godfather.

and no. i dont know if you are town, but obviously from hohum's reaction she suspected you targetted her. and if she isn't flipping out voting for you then...im going to side with town on this one, despite the fact that your vote for me on my wagon is the one i like the least, your last few posts make me think youre town trying to really think things through.

i'll need to think things through.

[inHimshallibe]

Being a one shot is not broken mechanics. This wagon is cool tho

@inHim: Not that I'm complaining but don't you still prefer my lynch? You went from not voting to a LC vote without trying to get my wagon top again first. There's still Pinkie Pie who would vote me and Primate who would switch if you stopped the LC compromise so I can't imagine you are thinking I'm a lost cause at the moment.

Oh that's right, you said I was unlikely to be a buddy with LC. I would actually make a better Pinkie Pie buddy. So you are just going to abandon your higher confidence opinions in order to what? I can almost see the bus pulling out of the station.

TBH, I'd rather not say why I don't want to vote you at the moment.

[inHimshallibe]

Also, I said LC looked more absolutely scummy than you, so etc...

[inHimshallibe]

BTW

unvote
vote: Pinkie Pie

[inHimshallibe]

I would also suggest those voting Jahudo to cease.

[hohum]

@Hohum: Do you think miller means there's a cop in the setup?

Well to say for certain there's a living cop in this setup would require a fair amount of mod outguessing. Dangerous waters. But I'd put the chances of having a living cop in this setup at better than 50/50

Does beg the question though that if I was seen n1 targeting a perceived pro-towner by scum why wasn't I shot N2 for being beneficial/protective.

Because nobody besides "just the three of us" knew you were targeted me until just now. We managed to stay under the radar.

Unvote, Vote Pinie Pie

Go go gadget lynch!

[hohum]

EBWOP:

Unvote, Vote Pinkie Pie

[Primate]

It's entirely possible that he's a scum watcher (his results are obviously legit). That's not a new or original role.

[hohum]

One more trailing though. Mina's flip "God

father

mother goes a long way towards supporting the notion of a living cop as well.

It's entirely possible that he's a scum watcher (his results are obviously legit). That's not a new or original role.

Good point. I hadn't considered this. I'd still rather see Jahudo or Pinkie flip though.

[Primate]

That's a legitimate point, but I've seen games without cops have GFs (for various reasons, some flavourful, some kill-proof, some whatever). I ran a miller no cop game once, but I don't think I've seen it outside of that (though I'm sure it has happened).

[inHimshallibe]

Primate, Pinkie Pie voting plz.