Mini 1211: Murder in Sicily [Over]

[Whiskers]

Here, how about this: I saw this in an other game, so ,

Nolynch in mylo?
There's your question.

[Scumhunter]

Hi Maruchan. Welcome to the game

I've got a question for you: What do you think of the Whiskers wagon/Whiskers' alignment?

Also, any other reads or input you have would certainly be welcomed as well.

[Scumhunter]

Oh and thanks to Bud for getting us replacements. Much appreciated.

[Scumhunter]

Edit: Bub /fail

[Maruchan]

@scumhunter, my last game when I replaced in and gave a strem of thought narrative on what I thought through the part of the game I wasn't here for I immediately got scumdar'd by half the game for it. I didn't want that to happen again so I figured if I just answered any questions asked of me it would be a better way to ease myself into an already rujnning game

To answer your question at first I didn't see why anyone was making suxh a big deal of the whole situation. To me it seemed like the whole thing was just blowing out of proportion faster than seemed possible. When the one person (can't remember names right this second and don't have the processpr speed to go back and ch eck quickly, on my cell at state fair) who was all "I think it could be seen as town" with no explanation after being asked page after page kept defending him I thought the two of them could be scumteam or he had some role where his life was dependant on the life of whiskers. Either way I was wary of the two. Then when he finally told us his reasoning it made sense and I began to go back to thinking the whole thing was just blown out of proportion.

As to why thoughts on whislers alignment I'm leaning more towards town. The person that accused him of scum for flip lfopping his votes on an "opportunistic hammer"? No. She switched her vote back to her main suspect after ir being on her secondary suspect. She wanted musicninja lynched and only voted bob when she felt no possible chance for a nusicninja lynch. When musicninja becomes a viable option again, shed rather lynch her number one suspect than her number 2.


I hope any of this makes sense and isn't too misspelt. I'm on my cell at statefair.


As to your auestion whiskers, if its mylo with 1 scum I would nl. If it is mylo with mulyiple scum I would lynch. When I get home I will elaborate on this, but for now t at answers your question

[Maruchan]

M'kay. if it is mylo with 1 scum, I would nl, because it gives you more information. Who dies in the night A: lessens your chance of misslynch, B: gives you information to use to find out who might be scum if you can correctly interpret the night kill, C: raises the chance of hitting scum (now a 33% instead of 25% from town PoV, and a 50% rather than a 30% from individual PoV)

if it is mylo with multiple scum, I would lynch because I hate being at lylo day after day after day. Plus night kills have a double-edged sword, now the scum can talk at night about who they want to kill, the least scummy looking scum can say "Hey this is why I think the night kill happened" and then push for a vote on their partner, then the next day when there is 1 scum left he is harder to find. did that helpful townie yesterday bus his partner, or is he really a helpful townie? Much more confusing and brain-wrecking. I'd rather through a lynch and say fuck the consequences.

[Maruchan]

Robo's rules make no mention to the post-game

Robo: Can we link the QT so as to show the scum's night-discussion?

[Maruchan]

wow /facedesk

SORRY GUYS I CLICKED ON THE WRONG TAB> those were meant to be posted in my game I just endgamed... -.-


http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=17911

wow fml.

[Scumhunter]

lol maruchan XD

[Maruchan]

I'm a failure at life, just ignore me and I will go away now.

[Friend]

If you guys want to meta me, this is how I play. I am heavily under the belief that conciseness is pro-town.

Anyways, it doesn't even matter that I talk about bob today; Music is the one that should be getting lynched. Bob can wait for tomorrow.

[monk]

If you guys want to meta me, this is how I play. I am heavily under the belief that conciseness is pro-town.

Anyways, it doesn't even matter that I talk about bob today; Music is the one that should be getting lynched. Bob can wait for tomorrow.

No, bad friend. While Conciseness is pro-town, saying "I've got these suspects, but I'm not going to tell you about them." is sooooooooooo not town. So much so that:
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Friend

[Friend]

I've told you about my top suspect, the one who needs to be lynched today.

As for the others, they can wait.

[Maruchan]

just a few quick questions for my own interests, I want to see the replies. they may be odd but just go with it please.

Substrike, can you explain in a DETAILED (longer than 1 sentence, sentences longer than 5 words) post for me why exactly you are voting Packbat, if you are honestly hopeful for a lynch on her or are just voting her without hoping for a lynch, if the second option, why don't you want her lynched if you're voting her? (if that made sense)

Panacea, are you the same alignment as me?

Whiskers, if we lynched you, would you still think its bob and music?

[Whiskers]

Who the hell is packbat?

And probably, yeah. They're both on my wagon now, right? I'm not entirely certain abou teither one of them, and I'd suspect Not both of them. While it's entirely possible, I think it's unlikely (just seems to be the way it plays out) that you'd have two shit scum players in a game. Maybe the bad play of one would prompt the other to step up and not suck ass, I don't know.

[Maruchan]

/facedesk. I meant Panacea.

past game. I got all of the people I was POINTING the questions at names correct!
(note to self: maybe not good idea to play with players you have played other games with, names may get mixed up)

[Maruchan]

Also Whiskers, did my summary of what I thought your votes meant sound about accurate, or am I way off?

[monk]

I've told you about my top suspect, the one who needs to be lynched today.

As for the others, they can wait.

But I'm asking about the one that's more likely to be lynched today

[Friend]

Well I think he's probscum.

But Music is pretty much confscum in my mind so those are better odds.

[Panacea]

MARUCHAN!!!!

Long time no see! And lol, a billion apologies for that. Poor Maruchan was my scumbuddy, who put a townie at L-1 as I was signing off, and got to wait with bated breath for nine hours until I got off work last night and noticed my vote was needed to win the game. ^^* I hope you're town; we're good on the same team.

Robo's rules make no mention to the post-game

Robo: Can we link the QT so as to show the scum's night-discussion?

I read this and was like,"Wait, did I click the wrong game?"

If you guys want to meta me, this is how I play. I am heavily under the belief that conciseness is pro-town.

For what it's worth, this is true; I remember reading his stance on this like a year ago.

Substrike, can you explain in a DETAILED (longer than 1 sentence, sentences longer than 5 words) post for me why exactly you are voting

Packbat

Second time I thought I'd clicked the wrong game. Stop that!

Panacea, are you the same alignment as me?

Are you town? I already notice a difference in your posting style, so I'll offer a hesitant "I think so." What do you think of my vote on your slot?

Going to run a quickish meta on Friend at the moment.

Iam: It has been three days since your last post. Thoughts?

[Maruchan]

MARUCHAN!!!!

Long time no see! And lol, a billion apologies for that. Poor Maruchan was my scumbuddy, who put a townie at L-1 as I was signing off, and got to wait with bated breath for nine hours until I got off work last night and noticed my vote was needed to win the game. ^^* I hope you're town; we're good on the same team.

lol no biggy. I was just hoping you didn't hate me for accidentally mentioning your name and bringing you down with me when you ended up disappearing for 9 hours right as I voted.

Panacea, are you the same alignment as me?

Are you town? I already notice a difference in your posting style, so I'll offer a hesitant "I think so." What do you think of my vote on your slot?

A: I think I may have confused you with my little joke I placed at the end of yesterday. I am not LTP. LTP is still MIA in terms of the game, waiting for a replacement. I am a player who (I believe) never confirmed? (if I remember correctly)
B: Any change in my posting style is purely due to experience and not based on my alignment in any way shape or form, thanks though for giving me the implied compliment of "you're no longer posting as scummy-like"! Greatly appreciated! Don't take this as me saying I am not town btw, I am town, I just want don't want to be presumed town under false pretenses. Thats like my whole ribbing I gave Stuntman about how "that is what scum do. not town". Playing under false pretenses is a form of lying by exclusion, and lying is a mafia tactic, therefore I would prefer to not use it, even if it does benefit me.
C: Good you answered my question perfectly! If you had said yes or no, I would have taken that as a slightly-scumtell, as only scum would know for sure which alignment I was.

Oh also, I want to see what this does. VOTE: bob. -waits patiently-

[Whiskers]

Well Maru, I want to take the credit and say, "Yeah, yeah, I was totally doing that!"

But I'm going to be honest and say, "No: I was fucking afraid."
It's Day 1. My personal main goal is to not get lynched.
I'm not going to hammer willy nilly or anything, but if we're about to lynch a scumspect of mine and I feel threatened for some reason, I will save myself over somepony who is not confirmed (to me) town.

[PREEDIT]
Heh, I was like, "DUH! If she's town she won't know, you're only damning her to hang when she gives you a yes-or-no answer!" I didn't say anything though, in the 0.001% case, where Panacea would stoopid-scumclaim and out both of you.

As to your vote on bobsnox:
Magikarp uses Splash!! It's Super-Effective!!

[Maruchan]

oh damn. Gah. I am not sure if I should take your "lets be honest" ploy at face value, or if I should assume you saw me use the same general "statement" then quickly threw up a reply, and added in the PREEDIT to make it look like you came up with it on your own as an attempt to AtE me.


SAOIT@)(*Y^%(TOUH

If your time stamp had honestly been like 2-3 minutes earlier I would have taken it at full face value without a question, for now, I'm not sure.

Whether or not it is a AtE on me, kudos for being honest and not taking an easy scapegoat credit when it isn't true. even if it is an AtE and you're scum, that is throwing away an easy out as scum, trekking for the harder path.

I was hoping I could ask EVERYONE that question, but then the results wouldn't be accurate for more than the first 1-2 people, as the scum would just copy earlier answers that seemed to sound right, or if the first player (like you) realized it was a trick question, the whole thing would have been a waste and I would have only gotten a read on the first player from it. So I settled with asking the one player I wanted to be on the same alignment with, so it would be most helpful to me, Panacea. Purely due to familiarity you could say.

[monk]

As to your vote on bobsnox:
Magikarp uses Splash!! It's Super-Effective!!

No it puts him at L-1, all sorts of funky things happen when peeps are at L-1

[Maruchan]

monk I know thats my point. earlier I felt it was to early to put someone at L1. I didn't want the day to en without anyone having ANY interaction from me. Now I feel a bit more confident in putting him at L1 because I want to see what this causes in the other players.