Any Band U-Pick (Town Wins)

[Nikanor]

It's probably three left, Spy, and CSL and I are town.
Where is all of the CMAR hate coming from? I still think he's town.
Speaking of which,

Vote: DemonHybrid.

He's pulled a 180 on his opinion on CMAR from yesterday, and CMAR hasn't made any posts since then. This right here is our lynch for today.

[SpyreX]

CSL more than any single person I think is scum. (OHH NOES SPYREX VOTING BLAH BLAH BLAH).

If I could spill my own blood to put a bullet through him RIGHT NOW I would do so without question.

[Regfan]

I have absolutely no problem with CSL dying at some point later in the game but now, now is the time for CMAR to get hung.

Nikandor, ISO CMAR, seriously do it and then hammer him when you're done. He starts a replacement in post, never continues, never finishes it instead gets into a semantics argument with Juls and then later throws together a pathetic case trying to say that Nintendo is scum (Who is actually obvtown) because he's voting wrong previously.

[tarsonisocelot]

Continuing reread:
Gaoth is scum.
Juls is very town with the reads.
Juls, leave GroundSpoon alone! Alts are not scumtells.
Really? LAL? No. Why do you have to be townie Juls?
CMAR being reasonable or mediating, time will tell.
AntB calling a scumteam after barely touching the thread. Not a very good idea. Null.
If I didn't know that CES was town I'd have them near the top of my scum list, bother.
Poweroxx is townie-ish.

ToD: A sample size of 4 is way too small for you to pull something like "If it's not correlated I'd have been wrong more than once." Even being right 5/6 times would be enough to indicate a genuine tell. 3/4 is 50%+1.

Parabollocks is scum for using too many ellipses in 286.

This is a joke, right?

The game would be much better if CES was vigged. I know my scumread on them is wrong, but every time I read one of their posts it's just blargh.

Ok so EPM town and I'm reading N1 as Juls vigging Pine (nice shot) and scum killing Furry.

Don't entirely follow the Poweroxx case.

Seraphim seems town. Nice call on the Pine contradiction. I agree ToD is almost certainly not scum with Pine and therefore town.

Stopping for the night on p29.

[DemonHybrid]

It's probably three left, Spy, and CSL and I are town.
Where is all of the CMAR hate coming from? I still think he's town.
Speaking of which,

Vote: DemonHybrid.

He's pulled a 180 on his opinion on CMAR from yesterday, and CMAR hasn't made any posts since then. This right here is our lynch for today.

If we have people 100% sure on a Gaoth being town and others that -highly- suggest CMAR dies, then I'm cool with that. I don't trust my old read.

Question: do you believe your vote has any use?

[Magua]

Not voting CryMeARiver because I'm being a dick.

Actually, he was my second suspect rereading through the night, but the massive wagon to L-1 in less than 24 hours makes me leery and so I'm going to wait for Regfan to badger me a bit, because that's how I roll.

Seraphim. Your town, Demon. Seraphim is scum. So is Gorilla. They need to be our next two lynches.

I agree on DemonHybrid-town.
I'm meh on Seraphim either way.
But I disagree on Gorilla-scum, so I'd like it if you could enlighten me there.

[Regfan]

Magua, the speed of the wagon is largely influenced by the neighbourhood power and you certainly should hop on it and hammer this. Before you do that an explanation of your Nikandor town read and your read on Tarson would be appreciated.

[Magua]

I liked Nikanor's overall play and styling. His targets seem a little slanted at the "easy" end with Nintendo, powerrox, EPM, etc. I just noticed that he made an exception for CSL in #973 -- like, he didn't care about EPM or powerrox, but he's willing to (slightly) defend CSL with the "He's just terribad" card. Even with that, though, I'd prefer to lynch CSL and then look at Nikanor if CSL flipped scum.

Tarsonisocelot seems useless. Parabollocks voting *only* town *ever* seems more "terribad townie" than scum. Also, diddin's vote on Parabollocks actually holds me back a little, as diddin's not much of a busser, so I say useless-probably-town. I held a "useless and therefore town" read on TO in 00's Band, which was incorrect, so I keep backtracking on this....but there you go.

Only slightly relatedly, I'm surprised that CES died, so I suspect that scum have a rolecop.

[Seraphim]

Who did gorilla target last night? Also, is this neighborhood one communal thing or multiple QTs with gorilla?

Are we 100% positive that Gaoth is not CES's result?

I connected some dots, nvm.

Regfan is town. Nikanor is town. Magua replaced nintendo who is town. ToD is town. SpyreX is town.

Who does that leave?

It leaves Gaoth, DH, CMAR, tars, CSL/Bowser, and Gorilla. Gorilla, I don't know if he's town(scum does look rather underpowered so far compared to all the power role flips we've had) but lynching him seems like a poor, poor idea. So, of those remaining, from scummiest to towniest:

CSL/Bower - CSL hates being scum, with a burning passion, generally resulting in lurkage. This, coupled with just really bad vibes and some rather opportune wagon jumping, puts CSL at the top of my scum list.
tars - did not like the person he replaced and his actions so far have not changed my mind. Looking forward to what he does after he finishes his reread.
DH - DH has been lurky and generally opportunistic but I'm not sure how scummy that makes him. I'm rather confused with him, actually. Nik makes a good point that he did sort of 180 once a wagon got going but I don't know how much of a scumtell that is given the circumstances. I'll iso him later.
Gaoth - is only under DH because of Spyre's insistence that he's town.
CMAR - I need to reread CMAR. He and the person he replaced has not done much at all but the crapwagon on nintendo does not speak well for him(though it could be honest...blegh)
gorilla - probably isn't scum due to actions he's made but his posts do not read off the greatest vibes. Definitely don't want him lynched, just want this for posterity to prevent *spreads arms wide*.

[Regfan]

Yeah, I had made a note somewhere in the neighborhood saying that Diddins scum flip increases the likelihood that Tarson is town and I can see where you're coming from with the Nikandor town-read and agree with it. I think we can own this game using PoE, I have quite a few strong town-reads whereas with the exception of CMAR my scum-reads are relatively weak.

Magua, have I mentioned that hammering CMAR means fulfilling your cheese win condition yet?

[DemonHybrid]

People saying that my read went 180 on CMAR obviously haven't been paying attention to the fact that diddin flipped scum.

There's a reason why I'm not really talking that much this game. Some of you have figured it out, some of you haven't.

[DemonHybrid]

Also, Seraphim, it's too bad you're scum.

If you believe SpyreX is town, then you should believe Gaoth is town as well. You're not paying attention and you can bet that I want you dead tomorrow.

[Magua]

I see no reason not to wait for a CMAR claim.

Or until CMAR has been prodded, one of the two.

[SpyreX]

Because swift bloody death is WAY more fun than waiting.

Sheesh

[Magua]

I would've thought my bloody-minded methodological nature would've been obvious to you by now.

[SpyreX]

Sometimes isn't it fun to dream? To let loose the mortal coil and release the inner hounds?

To murder without question or thought. To send them to the hereafter with nothing but a ? of what happened.

YOU CAN BE THAT MAN.

Blooooooood

[Magua]

SpyreX, your wise speeches and honeyed words have convinced me. From now, I shall live life according to your ways and me....BLOOD

BLOOD

BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GOD

SKULLS FOR THE THRONE OF KHORNE



Vote:

CryMeARiver

[Bowser]

The only access point I have is this laptop, which is shared by three other people, until I actually get a house, which will be sometime in September. Until then, I have

Limited Access

.

And that's hammer?

[Regfan]

Magua, not in the mood for fake hammer gambits, CMAR is getting lynched regardless of what he claims so please just proper hammer it for me.

Bowser, at least attempt to participate or attempt to other than prod-dodging.

[Slaxx]

The only access point I have is this laptop, which is shared by three other people, until I actually get a house, which will be sometime in September. Until then, I have

Limited Access

.

And that's hammer?

How limited is limited. If limited is too limited I'm going to have to find someone who has limitless time.

[Magua]

Regfan: No.
PS, Regfan: Fuck you.
PPS, Regfan: Still no.

VOTE: Bowser

[SpyreX]

:'(

[Regfan]

Magua, this is why Scumhunter/Eritas is a better player than you, even when he trolls and fucks around he still hammers mafia plus he's always MVP.

[Magua]

even when he trolls and fucks around he still hammers mafia

Only when he *is* mafia.

[Slaxx]

Modkilled players can be MVP?