Flash mafia 3 (town wins)

[Fate]

Hell vote Zor HE WILL just giv hiim time to be thorough and shit

[Ellibereth]

LLAMA
THOROUGH THIS

http://mafiascum.net/forum/search.php?a ... 7&sr=posts

DEAD
MAN
WALKING

[zoraster]

Hey fate. Do you have day talk?

Not much else to say. You either think I was being honest and didn't recognize a hammer ploy or did and am scum.

As for "backpedaling" off of DGB, not at all. Just said I probably wouldn't have continued her wagon had I remembered she was going V/LA. That doesn't mean I don't think she's a swell kinda lynch.

Someone asked about Farside's post. What about it? She says I didn't make reads based off of Day 1 or 2. Not true. I gave my initial reads in my first post. I didn't do a bunch of PBPA because I find it annoying in general and extremely annoying in the case of a replacement 35 pages in. My general impressions will have to do in that case.

So yes. Take it for what it's worth when I flip town. Farside is scum. DGB is also a good lynch. Regfan and the Mason brothers are not, sad as that makes me.

PS. "DGB is survivor" is a laughable statement. Whether or not that's true, it seems like a wild guess unless you're a role cop, and we'd be stupid to act under the impression that that's what it was.

PPS. Where did Mastin go? I appreciate not having blocks of text anymore (really), but his absence is conspicuous.

[zoraster]

LLAMA
THOROUGH THIS

http://mafiascum.net/forum/search.php?a ... 7&sr=posts

DEAD
MAN
WALKING

I think you will find no meta connecting the amount I post in mafia discussion/outside games to my scumminess, Elli. Calling it up is an obnoxious act that can only serve to chill MD discussion, which is a negative. Sure, if I had been absent for a long stretch of time in the game and posting over there, I'm not on V/LA or something, but beyond that? Screw off.

[Ellibereth]

It's not suppose to accurate or right or not obnoxious or whatever
It is, I know it is. I even timed it before when I thought you would post.
It's suppose to get you dead sooner, without actually having to write stuff out
And watch, it's going to work.

[Ellibereth]

Actually I could have made it easier:
There's still no claim.

[zoraster]

omigodnoclaim? It must be because I'm scum!

Or maybe it's because I'm vanilla town. If I were a power role, don't you think I would have already said something? Use your head, son.

[Fate]

Exactly why we're lynching you today MISTER VANILLA

[Fate]

No we don't have daytalk, wtf, do you have daytalk scum?

[zoraster]

No we don't have daytalk, wtf, do you have daytalk scum?

you just sounded like you were conferring with him or something.

[Fate]

Nope no conferring here

[farside22]

Someone asked about Farside's post. What about it? She says I didn't make reads based off of Day 1 or 2. Not true. I gave my initial reads in my first post. I didn't do a bunch of PBPA because I find it annoying in general and extremely annoying in the case of a replacement 35 pages in. My general impressions will have to do in that case.

first post:

Hi guys. I was going to say no to mykonian, but I liked the player list enough to accept. I have stuff to do tonight, so I won't be able to start catching up until tomorrow.

Not lets talk about your second post here since my sarcastic bitch got a moment there.


The first part only focas on today and what was said, which by the way you have NOT responded to why I'm attacking Regfan. This where i state nothing in your read of me talks about day 1 or day 2 but focas on today and again you have not responded to what I said but OMGUS and are scum comment.

The wagon on RegFan is questionable at best. He comes across as sincere to me. I have yet to see a convincing reason to lynch him. Farside's interaction with him is weird. I think Regfan's explanation makes sense and farside seems to be wigged out about the situation for no identifiable reason. Farside, therefore, comes across as pretty scummy to me.

I had a noticeably bad gut reaction to DGB's play, but I'm having trouble finding an articulable reason why.

vague and voting for second suspect more on gut the actual reasoning.

Tajo's posts are exceedingly strange to me. He seems to be trying, for much of the game, to hide behind the joke of playing like Fate (or something). I think he's trying to do so to shroud the fact that he's not really interested in figuring out scum. He spends a lot of it yelling at Fate which is a good way to eat up the game without accomplishing much of anything. So anyway, tajo/Mastin is a good lynch as well.

What joke posting? I'm sorry why is yelling at Fate scummy?
The only town read you talk about is Fate. Really that's it?
So besides today and as you can see why I called out Regfan and I'm going to keep saying you have yet to explain why my reasoning for attacking him = scummy what else you found scummy?

Why are your still alive what is your thoughts on AGOTI, Elli and Porochaz?

[Porochaz]

I'll be honest zor is making me not want to lynch him.

[springlullaby]

Posting tonight. Busy IRL sorry.

[shaft.ed]

mastin, where are all your words?

[farside22]

shaft: I realized just now when you replaced you didn't really say anything about what you read of the game. Who is your scum reads for the past 3 days and why?

[shaft.ed]

I have about a 5 page gap in the early game that I skimmed because I got bored and early game is usually not useful.

Fate

-Pretty strong town read. Claim is even stronger town read. Am still paranoid about Mafia Mason role. But this would be Llamarble because of roleblock N1.

DGB

-Her play was off. I read her as disinterested 3rd party. Now realizing that was just general apathy. Ignoring the meta side of her play. She's scummy.

Ellibereth

-My read on Elli jumps from town to scum depending on which game section I'm reading. More likely town.

Llamarble

-Of the masons, the more likely to have the mod harhar Mafia Mason role. Not a fan of his play, but farside roleblock is more revealing. Most likely town due to roleclaim.

Mastin2 (who replaced PopularTajo)

-Don't like tajo's play in this game. Seems too crappy to be scum, but who knows. L-1 vote on Amrun was in a good bussing position. Never played with Mastin, but I was expecting something very different given his reputation. Any meta tells?

Springlullaby (who replaced Ythill)

-I always read Ythill as town. Which makes me think he's scum. He was bleeding town N1. SL's play has been non-existent. Don't like the DGB vote yesterday. Hardly anything to look at. Costing on Ythill's D1 play might take you pretty far, but need more contribution.

Porochaz

-I think I played once with porotown before. Seemed a lot like this. I don't see scum bothering to be so stupidly and obviously contrarian

Farside

-Looks like town to me based on my experience modding her in EVERY game I've ever modded.

a girl on the internet

-Light on content, feels like valid contributions when plays are made.

Regfan

-Don't like his Amrun interactions. Don't like the convenience of his preemptive role claim. Don't like the game balance with a RB, Doc, Tracker and Mason pair along with a likely extra townie/harmless 3rd party in the game. I would REALLY like for him to confirm his ability tonight since that will 99% confirm his alignment given his N1 tracking claim.

Zoraster (who replaced Parabollocks)

-Convenient flipping on DGB, and backtracking on the vote after the "hammer". Lashing out at random people on his wagon but not others. Scummy.


On the setup, from a balance perspective I think I see RB + Doc as making more sense than Doc + Tracker. The game started with a half an extra lynch for town, so RB or Doc protect bumps the town up a lynch. Tracker getting lucky could take a scum out of the game on his own. Lot more swingy. The three combined with masons seems pretty unlikely to me. I think in order of probability one of the following is the case: Regfan is goon faking tracker, Farside is mafia RB claiming town, Llamarble Mafia Mason claiming town Mason. Given that town appears to have an extra player the Mafia Mason may be more likely as this is going really strong against site meta. However, if there is an innocuous 3rd party thrown in, I don't know that the mafia would need something like a Mafia Mason for counterbalance, so if we flip a survivor/lyncher then I'd say Llamarble is cleared.

[VP Baltar]

Everyone in this game is a dufus.

Also, save me the time of reading and who are the scums?

[mykonian]

My dear players, yet another person offered to replace in.

It's no other then VPBaltar who will read through a 40 page large themed game, just for you. I'm sure you'll think he is just as awesome as I think he is.

Thank you very much for helping us out here, VP!

[shaft.ed]

Everyone in this game is a dufus.

Also, save me the time of reading and who are the scums?

Come on your role PM couldn't be that much to read

[Fate]

This playerlist just gets better and better.

You're the scums, Baltar, but were lynching zor today

[VP Baltar]

Yeah, I pretty much just joined for the playerlist.

In honesty, I'll probably try to read this over the next couple nights. What's the bullet points on zoraster?

Also, why you being all calm this game Fate? (glanced at your iso)

[Ellibereth]

This reaction to a fake hammer for one

[Fate]

Yeah, I pretty much just joined for the playerlist.

In honesty, I'll probably try to read this over the next couple nights. What's the bullet points on zoraster?

Also, why you being all calm this game Fate? (glanced at your iso)

Being a mason has it perks. Scum haven't pissed me off by pushin for my mislynch, but I WAS pissed as hell when tajo wouldn't get the fuck off marble and onto scumRun.

[VP Baltar]

claimed masons already...I can tell this is going to be an enlightening experience.