Mini 1194: Reverse Mafia [Game Over]

[ToastyToast]

Ok. SC or MrTrow should be today's revive. The question I asked (which I would like to be answered by everyone) suggests that SC is the least likely person to be scum of those 3 players.

MrTrow has been active and a great hunter. Awesoma sucked but he's put the name back up for argument.

Everyone answer this plz. I'm ready to vote but I want some opinions, yo

[IceGuy]

I'd be OK with both revives.

[Packbat]

Judging by malpascp's behavior, the scumteam is most likely that trio - malpascp, Bub Bidderskins, and Pomegranate. I'll back StrangerCoug or MrTrow.

[malpascp]

We don't know his role. There are reasons why town fakeclaims.

IF (only if) we agree that the current setup is way too unbalanced, we must assume that there is someone that is fakeclaiming town.

[StrangerCoug]

We don't know his role. There are reasons why town fakeclaims.

There aren't that many The first role that comes to mind as the real role of someone fakeclaiming is bomb, followed by cop depending on how you interpret Kokusho's gambit.

[malpascp]

This game has special *unpredictable* roles. We never know for sure.

[MrTrow]

We don't know his role. There are reasons why town fakeclaims.

- Who`s role?
- name a good reason in this situation

IF (only if) we agree that the current setup is way too unbalanced, we must assume that there is someone that is fakeclaiming town.

Let me rephrase:
your post concluded such imbalance: you assumed fakeclaiming town bacause you assumed an (otherwise) unbalanced setup.
My question (after you recheck the purger), can you explain WHY YOU believe in the imbalance.

[AntB]

methinks malpascap is looking for the wrong kind of people... Why so keen to flush out FC'ing town dude?

[Bub Bidderskins]

There's a lot of meh going on right now. I'm still the best revive, though.

[ChannelDelibird]

Vote Count

Bub Bidderskins - 2 (

IceGuy

, Pomegranate)
AntB - 1 (Packbat)

Not voting - 1 (ToastyToast)

3 votes to revive.

Best wishes to malpascp.

[Packbat]

UNVOTE: AntB
VOTE: StrangerCoug

Follow the conftown. :/

[malpascp]

@Mod

: IG is not voting Bub, I am

Well, I did forget to italicise it, but technically, it's his vote you're using. -Mod

[IceGuy]

@Mod

: IG is not voting Bub, I am

Well, I did forget to italicise it, but technically, it's his vote you're using. -Mod

Get my/your vote on SC already. You're still voting scum.

[ToastyToast]

Vote:SC

[malpascp]

Bub's not scum. (I forgot the fact that IceGuy replaced Crypto, dumb me)

[ChannelDelibird]

Vote Count

Bub Bidderskins - 2 (IceGuy, Pomegranate)
StrangerCoug - 2 (Packbat, ToastyToast)

Not voting - 0

3 votes to revive.

Mod V/LA:

I am going to be under limited access from the 14th-19th August. I will be able to come online and check the game at least once every day but it won't be constant. Just an FYI, should not disrupt my ability to run the game in any way.

[Packbat]

Bub's not scum. (I forgot the fact that IceGuy replaced Crypto, dumb me)

Then why did (a) you get the vote and (b) Pomegranate sheep you onto Bub Bidderskins? That only works if Pom is lying town and IceGuy is scum.

[Packbat]

If there was a power to

give up your own vote

to limbo, it would have to come with some sort of double-voting feature or it would be useless or worse. crypto is

not

the one with the medium power.

[malpascp]

Scum hopping for WIFOM around my previous townread on Bub?

Besides the obvious WIFOM of Pom making the vote switch. If scum could let the kill unused, it is more than likely that they could do the same with the vote-switch thing.

[Packbat]

Scum hopping for WIFOM around my previous townread on Bub?

Besides the obvious WIFOM of Pom making the vote switch. If scum could let the kill unused, it is more than likely that they could do the same with the vote-switch thing.

This post makes no sense.

[malpascp]

If Pom is not scum, then someone else alive is (obv)
If scum was alive in a kill-less night, that means that they didn't want to kill (kinda obv)
The most likely reason to scum to no-kill would be to "show" us that everyone alive was town. (obv)
If scum would waste a kill just to try do convince us that everyone alive was town, then they would have no problem with doing the same thing about the vote-switch thing. (also obv)

Any flaw on that line of thought? If you assume the first sentence as veridic (and that was already done by various people here), then you MUST assume that the last one is also true.
In that case, scum could give me the vote so I would think "wait, I always pushed for Bub's revival, so if I got Crypto's/IG's vote, then it's because scum wants me to vote for Bub" (WIFOM).

[StrangerCoug]

I'm obviously liking where this is going.

My two scumpicks are Packbat and malpascp at this point. I think bobsnox is telling the truth about his role but I still don't feel confident enough in him to have him revived.

[Packbat]

I'm obviously liking where this is going.

My two scumpicks are Packbat and malpascp at this point. I think bobsnox is telling the truth about his role but I still don't feel confident enough in him to have him revived.

Actually, if:

(a) we have two townies and two scumbags,
(b) bobsnox is town, and
(c) malpascp is scum,

reviving bobsnox might be our best shot at victory, because bobs could purge malpascp. In a 10v3 situation, that would mean a forced town win because scum could no longer acquire a majority.

[Packbat]

Not unless scum have an extra kill somewhere.

[ToastyToast]

Very Odd V/La Coming up

V/LA from the 13-14, and 17-20