Starcraft Mafia Mini 1210 (Over)

[Espeonage]

Unvote, Vote: Vifam

[Morthas]

Ice sounds very town so far.

Who is he replacing?

Don't have an opinion on Scooby. Edit:Scum.

No opinion on Scott since he comments on minor stuff and not enough to work with hence not enough for me to detract my read which previously was gbevil's. Scum

Kiwi is being an idiot as per usual.

Wtf, Vifam shows up and just prod dodges without showing any intention to answer the suspicions of anyone about her or any otherr comment on game? Interesting.

No, not reading any backstory. All I know is what i got from the SC2 campaign and that should be more than enough.

Why unvote Rewq Psyche? If that was your reason to unvote then it's stupid, hence scummy. We need votes by all people especially so close to the deadline.Interesting.

Scooby is trying too hard to lynch Vifam because of her ''inconsistent claim''. Opportunistic scum.

If i believe Scooby's claim then for Vifam it would make sense to be Kerrigan since by starcraft lore that would make sense. (Already explained why) Which would mean Vifam is lieing.
Lieing is bad..Vifam. Although the mod said not to outguess him, this isn't something i want to risk on while i have stronger scum reads. Neutral and neutral scum only because of her inconsistent nameclaim plus the real possibility of lieing.

There are too many people i would want to lynch. I'll decide who i want to place my vote on sometime tomorrow. So far, I am rooting for Scotty-Gbevil, Kiwi, Scooby.

Whoever isn't voting, VOTE. We are 2 days from deadline.

[Morthas]

That was longer than expected.

[kiwieagle]

Im rooting for morthas or vifam.

[scooby]

If it weren't more obvious, Morthas is pretty clear scum with Vifam. Not only he calls me "oportunistic scum" for attacking Vifam. He also believes there is a possibility of Vifam lying and she being neutral scum for her "inconsistent claim" (ironically enough the reason why he is suspecting me. However he has "stronger scum reads".

Morthas can wait until tomorrow. Today we need to lynch Vifam.

Kiwieagle, why aren't you voting Vifam?

[Iecerint]

I was thinking in part that Selendis=KJ would be the obvious Kerrigan fakeclaim.

[Iecerint]

Kiwieagle -- Zeratul
killerjester -- Selendis
HellloooNewman -- Artanis (and he is also claimed inno cop+ for the hell of it???)
GBE=Scott Brosius -- Valerian Mengsk
Morthas -- Gabriel Tosh

Espeonage -- ???

Iecerint kondi2424 -- Samir Duran
scooby -- Raynor
Vifam -- Overlord (and he also claimed watcher, similarly for the hell of it???)
rewq455 -- Fenix
Psyche -- Tychus Findlay
Stels -- Edmund Duke

Espy has not claimed.

I agree with Morthas about the tone of scooby's attack on Vifam.

[HellloooNewman]

More to the point, Scoob why aren't you voting Vifam?

[kiwieagle]

unvote

VOTE: vifam

[Espeonage]

There was a mass nameclaim?

Matt Horner.

[Iecerint]

Matt Horner is Raynor's bland sidekick in Starcraft II. He doesn't like Mengsk very much for reasons the player doesn't really know. He's kind of a crap character tbh. The main reason to like him are the homoerotic undertones between him and Raynor, but they mess that up when Raynor magically forgets that he wants to kill Kerrigan for ruining his bromance with Fenix.

/character-summary

[Iecerint]

I'm totally bummed that Ariel Hanson didn't make the cut, if we're going to use boring SC2 characters. I hope she's scum with Kerrigan. Maybe with Nova, too. That, or DN just hates women.

[Scott Brosius]

My role PM confirms Arcturus Mengsk is in this game. Obviously nobody has claimed him.

Again I don't know if he is good/bad in terms of SC flavor, but this suggests possible fakeclaims? If so then I would believe the flavor to be much more literal.

Was waiting for all claims to be out before revealing this.

[Iecerint]

Oh, neat.

Arcturus Mengsk is Valerian's father and the Emperor of the humans. He was portrayed with shades of grey in the original game, but became a boring Lawful Evil authority figure in the sequel.

GBE=SB is scum and/or Arcturus is scum in the game.

[Iecerint]

I have to admit that I hesitate on Vifam/Kerrigan partially cuz I wanna see if she can recruit me and give me simultaneous town and scum wincons. ^^

And there's KJScumenderrigan. Oh well.

I can reveal another piece of modtalk at this point. When I asked the Mod if the game had been advertised bastard, he specified that the only kinda bastard-y role was my own Duran role on the grounds that [REDACTED]. This weakly implies that giving someone only the Overlord name ala Vifam's claim is not very likely, since that would also appear to be a bastard-y move. However, this depends on what the Mod considers bastard-y.

He did NOT specify that my role was the only bastard-y aspect of the game -- only that insofar as roles were a bastard element of the game, that bastard element was limited to my own role.

Maybe he's Kerrigan and he wasn't given a fakeclaim, or his fakeclaim was the human version of Kerrigan and he was afraid to claim it.

[killerjester]

So far, I am rooting for Scotty-Gbevil, Kiwi, Scooby.

Kiwi lynch isn't a very good lynch. In fact, kiwi is a terrible lynch when compared to the other candidates. I'm also finding it scummy that you are calling scooby an "opportunistic scum" and using that theory as grounds for fencesitting on Vifam, as if scooby's attack suddenly make Vifam's play more pro-town.

FoS Morthas

VOTE: Vifam

Beyond a Vifam lynch, I suppose Scott Brosius and Morthas are my top two scumreads.

My rolename is confirmable by Newman's ability, should he choose to use it on me, and we should have at least one protective role to save our only claimed PR.

[Iecerint]

What made you change your mind about Kiwi?

[killerjester]

This is an outstanding post.

Im rooting for morthas or vifam.

[Morthas]

So far, I am rooting for Scotty-Gbevil, Kiwi, Scooby.

Kiwi lynch isn't a very good lynch. In fact, kiwi is a terrible lynch when compared to the other candidates. I'm also finding it scummy that you are calling scooby an "opportunistic scum" and using that theory as grounds for fencesitting on Vifam, as if scooby's attack suddenly make Vifam's play more pro-town.

FoS Morthas

VOTE: Vifam

Beyond a Vifam lynch, I suppose Scott Brosius and Morthas are my top two scumreads.

My rolename is confirmable by Newman's ability, should he choose to use it on me, and we should have at least one protective role to save our only claimed PR.

Scooby did not make Vifam pro-town, Scooby is a much better lynch than Vifam IMO. I never said that something made Vifam more pro-town.
I won't support no Vifam Lynch at this point.

[killerjester]

You can't sell the idea of opportunistic scooby unless you assume town Vifam. That's my point. I have no reason to believe Vifam is town and therein no reason to believe scooby is unfairly pushing a mislynch.

If one post summed up my entire feelings on you it would be this post.

[DeathNote]

Vote Count

(L-6)Kiwieagle- Morthas
(L-7)killerjester-
(L-6)HellloooNewman- rewq
(L-6)Scott Brosius- Iecerint
(L-6)Morthas- scooby
(L-6)Espeonage- Scott
(L-7)Iecerint-
(L-7)scooby-
(L-3)Vifam- HelloNewman, Espeonage, kiwi, killerjester
(L-7)rewq455-
(L-7)Psyche-
(L-7)DemonHybrid-

With 12 alive, its 7 to lynch

~Stels is replaced by DemonHybrid~
~Deadline will be extended for the replacement, please wait while i figure an appropriate date.~

[DemonHybrid]

Hello.

And with that, I'm going to sleep. Any help with catching up will be grand, but I will have time to read through tomorrow night and I will come up with reads. 17 pages is more than enough.

[killerjester]

Welcome!

[kiwieagle]

So far, I am rooting for Scotty-Gbevil, Kiwi, Scooby.

Kiwi lynch isn't a very good lynch. In fact, kiwi is a terrible lynch when compared to the other candidates. I'm also finding it scummy that you are calling scooby an "opportunistic scum" and using that theory as grounds for fencesitting on Vifam, as if scooby's attack suddenly make Vifam's play more pro-town.

FoS Morthas

VOTE: Vifam

Beyond a Vifam lynch, I suppose Scott Brosius and Morthas are my top two scumreads.

My rolename is confirmable by Newman's ability, should he choose to use it on me, and we should have at least one protective role to save our only claimed PR.

Scooby did not make Vifam pro-town, Scooby is a much better lynch than Vifam IMO. I never said that something made Vifam more pro-town.
I won't support no Vifam Lynch at this point.

You obviously wont support a vifam lynch cause all she has done is call you town.

[Iecerint]

Morthas, what do you think about my modtalk allusion in 414?