Newbie 1138 - Game Over! Town Win!

[Honest Abel]

On second thought don't even bother putting yourselves on your own lists. It isn't necessary.

[DarkClaymore]

DC, why are you not last on your own list? That is retarded. Please redo it. Putting yourself anyone other than last on your own list is saying that you want to be able to claim before scum, which makes no sense.

Actually I thought it'd be interesting to see if IAI claims cop in the end, considering he is the one who suggested the whole thing. I personally think we don't really have a cop, but that's just a guess.

On second thought don't even bother putting yourselves on your own lists. It isn't necessary.

TBH that was my initial thinking as well.

1 Abel
2 whilst
3 dicknose
4 IAI

[singersigner]

Vote Count 3.9

DarkClaymore (1): dicknose
Honest Abel (1): DarkClaymore
whilst (2): Honest Abel, Nobody Special
dicknose (0):
I Am Innocent (0):
Nobody Special (0):

Not Voting (2): whilst, I Am Innocent

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Mod Notes:

Deadline for Day Three is September 4th, 2011 at 5pm PST.

[Honest Abel]

My list is in my first post on the subject, so I won't be reposting it. I forget, are we claiming today if we do it this way, or still tomorrow? If tomorrow, maybe we should hold of until then to do it since people's opinions may change.

[DarkClaymore]

My list is in my first post on the subject, so I won't be reposting it. I forget, are we claiming today if we do it this way, or still tomorrow? If tomorrow, maybe we should hold of until then to do it since people's opinions may change.

Wasn't the plan that only cop claims today? Though we haven't got everyone's opinion on the matter yet...

[Honest Abel]

Actually, I don't know. Cop claiming today means he might be the target tonight. And it would mean pressuring NS to protect a particular person or otherwise risk losing probably our best bet at a win. Jeopardizing the cop when he could still return results tonight might not be a good idea.

[DarkClaymore]

Actually, I don't know. Cop claiming today means he might be the target tonight. And it would mean pressuring NS to protect a particular person or otherwise risk losing probably our best bet at a win. Jeopardizing the cop when he could still return results tonight might not be a good idea.

The Jailer can clear a player as much as cop can in this situation. If someone is jailed and cop dies, then the jailed person is clear. I think cop claim could help us a lot right now, especially if he investigated you. Because as IAI said, there is a technical problem with you being alive and NS's claim.

[Honest Abel]

The Jailer can clear a player as much as cop can in this situation. If someone is jailed and cop dies, then the jailed person is clear. I think cop claim could help us a lot right now, especially if he investigated you. Because as IAI said, there is a technical problem with you being alive and NS's claim.

A JK cannot clear a player as much as a cop can. JK could jail someone, and if there's no nightkill, that player was either targeted or is scum. It's not as definitive as a cop. Cop can investigate me if he wants, but will he be alive to tell us if he claims? Maybe not.

[Bricktoes]

screw that noise. let's inform the minority.

[whilst]

In trying to think of another "win" strategy, something else crossed my mind (though it's unlikely that it could be true). This is a potential scenario where his JK claim could be bullshit:

Cavjj was the mafia goon, which means his partner was the rolecop. The rolecop has had two opportunities to take action: N1 and N2. If NS had two successful PR investigations (by luck), he would then know if there was a cop and if there was a doctor. Assuming he got both of those spot on, he would then know that there's no chance of being a JK, thus his claim allows him to move freely as psuedo-JK.

It's quite possible then (in this scenario), that the doctor saved the right person during N2. Heh, it also means that our cop knows two innocent townies. It also means, that NS could've found out who the cop was on N1 and tried to have him lynched on D2 (something to look into?). Finally, it also means that the doctor protected the cop during N2, because NS would've nightkilled the cop.

I don't know, its a bit heavy to think about. It implies that NS lynched his own scumpartner -- which is really what derails this scenario.

lot's of "it also means"...

[Honest Abel]

Why isn't whilst lynched yet?

[Bricktoes]

let's go people, chop chop.

[Nobody Special]

Why isn't whilst lynched yet?

[Scumhunter]

Official latest ever "Bah!" post. Go town, I'm following this game, good luck

[Bricktoes]

i can accept whilst.

[Bricktoes]

VOTE: whilst

[I Am Innocent]

Why isn't whilst lynched yet?

Any thoughts on the Cop claiming D3? Why is it a good idea / bad idea?

Same questions @ Dicknose as well.

[I Am Innocent]

i can accept whilst.

This sounds very convincing. Is whilst your #1 suspect?

[Bricktoes]

i don't know and no

[Bricktoes]

can a scum both roleblock and kill iin q singke night in newb games?

[Honest Abel]

Scum doesn't roleblock, they rolecop. They can do both simultaneously in a newb game, yes.

[Honest Abel]

I'm actually going to
UNVOTE: whilst
because I want to interrogate him about some of the things he said during the cavjj claim before I commit to a lynch. It bothers me that he hasn't really said anything in defense of himself about that episode and I want to force him to talk.

I will be asking questions by the end of the day today. whilst, feel free to start explaining yourself in the meantime if you want.

[Bricktoes]

to specify, i don't know any pros or cons that haven't been already stated. if we have another power role it can help us narrow the field, so i'm in favor of claim either now or first thing tomorrow.

[I Am Innocent]

dicknose, who is your #1 suspect?

[Bricktoes]

I suppose you and whilst are my top two.