Newbie 1138 - Game Over! Town Win!

[Honest Abel]

dicknose, compare cavjj's case on IAI to his cases on other townies. Very similar, in my opinion. He also kept IAI at L-1 for a long time. How do you reconcile those two facts with your suspicion of IAI?

[Bricktoes]

I haven't looked at that, will do later.

[Bricktoes]

if so, that would make me go whilst or abel.

[Honest Abel]

So after tunneling DC on D2, he's the least or second-least suspicious to you?

[singersigner]

Vote Count 3.1.0

DarkClaymore (0):
Honest Abel (1): DarkClaymore
whilst (2): Nobody Special, dicknose
dicknose (0):
I Am Innocent (0):
Nobody Special (0):

Not Voting (3): Honest Abel, whilst, I Am Innocent

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Mod Notes:

Deadline for Day Three is September 4th, 2011 at 5pm PST.

[Bricktoes]

I'm more annoyed by him than I think he's scum right now

[whilst]

I'm actually going to
UNVOTE: whilst
because I want to interrogate him about some of the things he said during the cavjj claim before I commit to a lynch. It bothers me that he hasn't really said anything in defense of himself about that episode and I want to force him to talk.

I will be asking questions by the end of the day today. whilst, feel free to start explaining yourself in the meantime if you want.

What am I explaining? When you bring up an argument against me, I'll be sure to counter. You didn't have to unvote me, I doubt anyone is going to hammer -- they'll look like crap tomorrow.

If I do get lynched (after deliberation), I have two requests before I am officially lynched:

1.

Everyone explains why they are lynching me.

2.

I get to say what I would do if I were still alive during D4.

Obviously I would have to do this at L-1 + a guarantee of the 4th lynch. Also, once I'm gone, you guys should follow my plan.

[Honest Abel]

@dicknose: Are annoying and being scum mutually exclusive?

[Honest Abel]

whilst, like I said in the post you quoted, questions coming tonight. I don't have the time to look back and take notes at work. Your plan is stupid.

[Honest Abel]

Since there is no game-winning plan to make right now, the best thing to do is let the cards fall where they may and not to tell power roles what to do tonight.

[Honest Abel]

Questions for whilst coming tomorrow. Putting him on ice for tonight.

[I Am Innocent]

I still want to hear what Nobody Special thinks about asking for a cop claim D3. Once I hear that, I will list out the pros and cons as I can see them.

***********************

i

can accept

whilst.

VOTE: whilst

Why isn't whilst lynched yet?

Any thoughts on the Cop claiming D3? Why is it a good idea / bad idea?

Same questions @ Dicknose as well.

i can accept whilst.

This sounds very convincing. Is whilst your #1 suspect?

i don't know and

no

dicknose, who is your #1 suspect?

I

suppose

you and whilst are my top two.

dicknose, compare cavjj's case on IAI to his cases on other townies. Very similar, in my opinion. He also kept IAI at L-1 for a long time. How do you reconcile those two facts with your suspicion of IAI?

I haven't looked at that, will do later.

if so, that would make me go whilst or abel.

So after tunneling DC on D2, he's the least or second-least suspicious to you?

I'm more annoyed by him than I think he's scum right now

This guy is all over the place. He obviously is doing no research, and suspecting the "popular" targets or just straight OMGUS. He uses words like "can accept" and "I suppose" which are very wishy washy and easy to turn around on. I try to get him to take a firm stance and in reply he OMGUS's me to his #1 suspect (yet I saw no evidence of that suspicion D3...)

Two seconds ago he said whilst is not his top suspect, but that me and whilst are (that makes me #1, right?). Then after one question, he drops me from the #1 on the list to somewhere 3 - 5, and adds in Honest Abel. You have dicknose who just wants to lynch anyone not named dicknose, and you have whilst who is volunteering to go first, even self voting. Sure could be a ploy, but would scum take that chance that we would call their bluff???

Still don't like dicknose's vote for cavjj in Post 728 with the line "I don't appreciate you disparaging my character." Nothing about finding him scummy, just "don't make me look bad". Oh, and he unvoted him 1 minute later. (This all took place prior to the fake claim.)

********************

Not ready to lynch as I want to figure out if a cop claim is in order or not D3, also still not sure if HA or someone other than HA makes for the best lynch today. Still I want my vote on record, and I am voting for the person I think is most likely scum:

vote dicknose

[Bricktoes]

I totally omgus for keeping my suspects from yesterday.

[Bricktoes]

Me taking you off and adding Abel was in response to Abel's post. If I found you innocent after reviewing what he mentioned, my list with Abel would be my revised list.

[Nobody Special]

I am not really in favor of a cop claim today. I feel that if we take the time and lynch the scummiest player that we will be able to go into Day Four with two more flips (potentially) and much more information.

[Honest Abel]

The cop claim makes no sense, really. Just because cop could have a town result on a living player doesn't mean we shouldn't want two town results or a scum result on living players tomorrow. I say drop it, and we can do an ordered massclaim tomorrow. Nobody claim before that, please.

[singersigner]

Vote Count 3.1.1

DarkClaymore (0):
Honest Abel (1): DarkClaymore
whilst (2): Nobody Special, dicknose
dicknose (1): I Am Innocent
I Am Innocent (0):
Nobody Special (0):

Not Voting (3): Honest Abel, whilst

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Mod Notes:

Deadline for Day Three is September 4th, 2011 at 5pm PST.

[Nobody Special]

I'm still in favor of lynching whilst over dicknose.

[Bricktoes]

i, obviously, am in favor of lynching anyone but me.

[Nobody Special]

See, that's unproductive. Not to mention scummy.

[Bricktoes]

I don't see how it's scummy. I don't expect anyone to feel they should be lynched. If you think lynching me will get the information you need, go for it.

[Nobody Special]

It's not that you don't want to be lynched; that's obviously a no-brainer.

It's that you don't have any suspects (or if you have them, you didn't state them in that post).

[Honest Abel]

i, obviously, am in favor of lynching anyone but me.

UNVOTE: whilst
VOTE: dicknose

[Honest Abel]

Oh, I had already unvoted whilst.

[Bricktoes]

My suspects have been stated, mostly in order. Do I need to restate them?