Mini 1211: Murder in Sicily [Over]

[Scumhunter]

I could buy noramp scum though. (Panacea, not so much)

[Scumhunter]

vote: noramp

Part process of elimination, part because he was almost too careful to explain his actions in reference to the Bob/Ninja wagons.

Will be rereading bob/ninja specifically for interactions when I get a chance.

[Maruchan]

-.-

Should've seen that coming.

Good luck town

[Hikari Link]

Here's to hoping Maruchan didn't actually jail our cop. We really really should have specified that he not jail Link if xvart flipped scum.

That just means I would've died instead. No result here. This aso means no Doc and i will die tonight, short of a scum lynch today. As such, I'm going to heavily analyze everyone again and get back to you within the next day or two. In the meantime, could we get a read list with detailed explanations from everyone. Might help in determining our scum to see their "thought process".

[iamausername]

First, I can get behind Iam's town-Whiskers justification back on #143, mainly because my read on him is more panicky-town with scummish twinges than outright scum at the moment. Plus the game he linked us to checks out.

Oh hey, Panacea actually bothered to check out one of my meta links in order to get a better read on Whiskers.

VOTE: Noramp

[Whiskers]

Noramp is the scummiest.

Um, I'm gonna look and see how many votes, don't want to LYNCH him just yet.

[Whiskers]

Okay, nevermind-- two votes, both of them on this page. x_____x

I'll have to read Day 1 stuff before I'll be able to make myself suspicious enough to vote somepony.
Day 1, because Day 2 was kind of a Charlie-Fox.

[Hikari Link]

Okay, nevermind-- two votes, both of them on this page. x_____x

I'll have to read Day 1 stuff before I'll be able to make myself suspicious enough to vote somepony.
Day 1, because Day 2 was kind of a Charlie-Fox.

If you mean clusterfuck, then I believe the correct term here is charlie foxtrot. Foxtrot is F in the NATO phoenetic alphabet. Thanks, Wikipedia!

But in all seriousness, I'd say you shouldn't ignore Day 2, because there very well could have been something of value there.

[Whiskers]

Oh man, Whiskers messed up on the CF! Gotta be scum! Get 'em!

But I think I'll click a page of Day 1 at random, start reading there. also have a look at ISOs, mostly noramp's.

[Hikari Link]

Oh man, Whiskers messed up on the CF! Gotta be scum! Get 'em!

But I think I'll click a page of Day 1 at random, start reading there. also have a look at ISOs, mostly noramp's.

Any particular reason you are going from a random page rather than the start?

[Whiskers]

Forgive me my laziness-- I don't intend to reread the whole game.

[Hikari Link]

Forgive me my laziness-- I don't intend to reread the whole game.

Perfectly understandable, but choosing a random page just seems weird. Why not ISO your suspects and just read in context where it is necessary? It seems like a more ordered way of doing things than a random page. But then, your avatar

is

Pinkie Pie, so I can see why you would be inclined towards randomness.

[Whiskers]

iso # 33. Votes bobsnox but hedges his bets.

Then his last 3 iso posts ( #36, #37, & #38. )
Votes Xvart "I feel bad for him though".
Unvotes Xvart "Barring his confession maru does Not have a confirmed scum"
Says we should lynch Xvart but does not revote.

But more importantly than that, I remembered my OTHER favorite suspect, SUBSTRIKE22!!!!
Of course, upon looking, there's nothing NEW on Substrike.

Does Substrike22 have a prod out righ tnow? Does he need one yet?

[Hikari Link]

iso # 33. Votes bobsnox but hedges his bets.

Then his last 3 iso posts ( #36, #37, & #38. )
Votes Xvart "I feel bad for him though".
Unvotes Xvart "Barring his confession maru does Not have a confirmed scum"
Says we should lynch Xvart but does not revote.

But more importantly than that, I remembered my OTHER favorite suspect, SUBSTRIKE22!!!!
Of course, upon looking, there's nothing NEW on Substrike.

Does Substrike22 have a prod out righ tnow? Does he need one yet?

He was prodded pre-night and hasn't posted since, I believe. Same for Tovarish, I think.

[Panacea]

Friend, you have been leaning on me as scum for a lot of this game, which is fine, except I've yet to see an actual case. I've asked you before to give me something more than gut to work with, and have received nothing. Sorry, I don't mean to be mean, but I dislike the gut "case" as a rule, and grow ever more suspicious of it the longer it stays just gut and acquires no evidence. You're focusing on Town, and you're not giving me a way to show you that. Also, the way you hopped onto Iamausername's suspicion so quickly strikes me as scummy. I'm interested to see how you respond to being called on it.

Maruchan's demise is not super surprising, though regrettable. He was my towniest read, and he also kept the game moving.

Whiskers, I apologize for revisiting an old topic, but Yesterday (or maybe it was D1? So much Night lately, lol) I mentioned that I felt that the relationship between you and Maruchan was suspect, and the possibility that one of you was scum buddying the other. Well. Now Maruchan is conftown. Am I right to be suspicious of you in that respect?

@Iamausername: This might be a dumb question, but is there a specific order to your list in #921? I'm assuming so, since I was at the top of your scum list and you voted me in the same post, but then your next vote is on noramp, bypassing Scumhunter and Substrike.

[iamausername]

@Iamausername: This might be a dumb question, but is there a specific order to your list in #921? I'm assuming so, since I was at the top of your scum list and you voted me in the same post, but then your next vote is on noramp, bypassing Scumhunter and Substrike.

I copied and pasted the player list from the first page.

And I didn't vote you. That was Friend in the post after me.

[Whiskers]

Whiskers, I apologize for revisiting an old topic, but Yesterday (or maybe it was D1? So much Night lately, lol) I mentioned that I felt that the relationship between you and Maruchan was suspect, and the possibility that one of you was scum buddying the other. Well. Now Maruchan is conftown. Am I right to be suspicious of you in that respect?

Suspicious that I was buddying him? sure. Suspicious that I was scum doing so? no. I was in defense of Maruchan because I was confident (at least, by the time Link started trying to kill him) that he was town.

[Noramp]

I would say scum potentials right now are Whiskers, Friend and Scumhunter

Whiskers because of that extremely annoying exchange from i believe D1. he came off as scum trying to scoot me under the rug
Friend because I always have a nagging feeling he's scum
Scumhunter because his last couple posts have rubbed me the wrong way. Specifically...

Here's to hoping Maruchan didn't actually jail our cop. We really really should have specified that he not jail Link if xvart flipped scum.

Panacea has come off as town since D1 to me and I have reason to believe Substrike is town.

[Noramp]

* Whiskers, Friend or Scumhunter

[Substrike22]

I'm currently trying to catch up, a few pages behind.

I'm trying to decide whether or not it's possible that Link claimed cop, bussed his scum buddy, then gained an infallible amount of town credit in the process. As such I'm reading particularly carefully.

Cause I mean what could've happened was:
1. Link replaces in D1 and sees that Bobsnox is floundering and that LTP is also a high candidate on many scum lists. (his two scum buddies.)
2. The town is calling for a cop counter claim on Bobsnox on day 1, Link indulges us.
3. Xvart and Link decided in their scumtopic on N1 not to do a kill, or perhaps because they were both replacements, one simply didn't get sent as they hadn't effectively communicated.
4. They employ a gambit with the non kill, with Link pushing that a doc must've saved the kill, and that the likeliness of Xvart actually doing the kill (and thus being effectively roleblocked by Maruchan) was slim to none.
5. Xvart hammers himself to prevent an awkward situation from coming up with VCA on Link.

Anyone want to poke a hole in that admittedly outrageous theory?

Also I'm in the process of doing some important RL things that are kind of interfering. (i.e. considering joining the USAF) So, apologies, and if people have something to say on the above bit, I'll have answers and other scum candidates. Just needed to have something to let you all know I'm here and actually working at the game.

[Substrike22]

Here's to hoping Maruchan didn't actually jail our cop. We really really should have specified that he not jail Link if xvart flipped scum.

Also, I think this doesn't make any sense what-so-ever. Though I did not like Maruchan and the feeling was clearly mutual, he was not an idiot. He would not have jailed Link given the scenarios that he was confronted with.

[Substrike22]

Also Noramp is not the scummiest of my reads atm so I will not be voting for him. Since clearly my reads have been amazing in this game.

[Friend]

Panacea, Iama's suspicions were simply a matter of PoE + the fact that I think he's town. It wasn't just sheeping, it was the only way to go.

I'll work out a case on you soon.

[iamausername]

I have reason to believe Substrike is town.

If you're hinting at some kind of role info here, you should really just come out and say it.

[Noramp]

alright im tracker and last night I tracked Substrike and N1 I tracked monk both went nowhere