Flash mafia 3 (town wins)

[Ellibereth]

heeeeeeeheeeee
haaaaaaahHAAAAAAAAAA
WHAT NOW REGFAN
THE DOC IS SO FUCKING OBVIOUS ISN'T IT
YTHILL WAS SO OBVIOUSLY THE DOC
YEAAAAAAAAAAH
I'M CLEARLY RIGHT
ELLI IS SCUM
KISHISHISHISHISHISHISHISHISHISH

I'M NOT A DOC
WHITE MAGE
OR WHITE WIZARD
OR WHATEVER THE HELL IT'S CALLED.

THERE
THERE

[Ellibereth]

That means protections last two days btw.

Ythill
Fate
Regfan
Farside

Crumbed in second post so none of that tracking me shit necessary.

LLAMA YOU MISSED. TRY TO RUN OVER DIFFERENT DEER.
Anyway guys. I promise I'm town. I'm not happy as scumz. I'm happy right now. THEREFORE ha.

Unvote, Vote Fate

Missed. Run. Deer.
Mithrandir
Gandalf
The White wizard
jah

[VP Baltar]

vote: Mastin

question - does your protection continue after you're dead? That'd be wonderful.

[shaft.ed]

elli why did you claim VT first?

[Ellibereth]

Confusion entertainment/wanting to see how long Reg would go on.
I have some thoughts and stuff now since I've been trying to avoid being Nk'ed for days so wait on blood.
Later.

[shaft.ed]

Of course the only useful protect is on the deadguy

OK so Regfan/Elliberth circle target. Elli or Farside die during the nightphase unless farside hits scum/scum fake a no kill (which would be stupid with 2 confirmed town power roles running around the next day)

So in all likelihood we come in tomorrow with a confirmed tracker and a likely town roleblocker and three or so shots at the remaining scum

Ythill was quite likely the NK target N1 meaning Doc protect is slightly more likely than Llamarble block. Regfan is town so Doc protected Fate. VPB was blocked last night so unless fourth scum Doc also saved Regfan N3.

And all this means is that my main suspect is less likely scum

wippie. Why did we have to massclaim again?

[farside22]

That means protections last two days btw.

Ythill
Fate
Regfan
Farside

Crumbed in second post so none of that tracking me shit necessary.

LLAMA YOU MISSED. TRY TO RUN OVER DIFFERENT DEER.
Anyway guys. I promise I'm town. I'm not happy as scumz. I'm happy right now. THEREFORE ha.

Unvote, Vote Fate

Missed. Run. Deer.
Mithrandir
Gandalf
The White wizard
jah

wait, what? I so thought spring was the doctor. But damn that makes too much sense now.


I now more then ever seeing this list believe there is two scum left.

I'm not searching for a 4th scum member today. I'm lynching confirmed scum.

vote: VBP

.

[Ellibereth]

guys stop voting and wait for me to finish this work shit then post actual stuff
>.>

[farside22]

guys stop voting and wait for me to finish this work shit then post actual stuff
>.>

But mom.....

unvote

I already have a good idea on whom the second scum suspect is but I may completely ignore that and listen to what Fate said yesterday.

[shaft.ed]

SL wasn't the doctor because Ythill was the obvious N1 kill target. Unless you believed that Llamarble was blocked trying to kill Ythill N1

[farside22]

SL wasn't the doctor because Ythill was the obvious N1 kill target. Unless you believed that Llamarble was blocked trying to kill Ythill N1

I know that know. I thought I was protected night 1 since I claimed.

If it was so obvious to you that Ythill was protected N1, then why did you think Elli was scum?

[shaft.ed]

Elli's been a pretty obv townread for me the whole game
not sure what you're getting at

[farside22]

This does not sound like someone who finds a play obvious town shaft:

That's a really piss poor example of Elli town. That's definitely something a scumbuddy would point out because it's ridiculously obvious that it is a blown fakeclaim. Someone is going to notice that, might as well get town points.

How is that piss poor example? So you think Elli scum would not tell his scum buddies about the flash and keep the janitor safe. Instead he buss's his buddy and is the first to show the lie.

[quote="shaft"So you're saying that DGB scum would? I really dont see how anyone could let their teammate have such a piss poor fakeclaim. But I can also see scum assuming their buddy wouldnt be thick enough to claim a non-existent role in a semi-open game. However, if this is the product you're selling we should be lynching someone who is absent minded, stupid or inexperienced.[/quote]

[shaft.ed]

I was just arguing that what you were providing wasn't a reason for Elli to be town
Don't think there arent others
Main thrust was to point out that VPB is a bad lynch because it assumes four scum

[VP Baltar]

>roles point to elli or mastin as last scum
> elli is doctor
> vote confirmed town VPB

lol, dis game

[Llamarble]

So we have Tracker + white mage + roleblocker vs Janitor + goon + ?
Sounds about right to me. I'm still pretty much entirely convinced there are 3 scum.
I've played tracker + doctor + Masons vs roleblocker + goons, which about lines up with this.
So yeah we stick to plan autowin.

Mastin trying to push the 'there are 4 scum' angle makes a lot of sense if he's scum as people buying into that silliness is the only possible way for scum to win.
Elli can keep both Farside & Regfan protected for a bit, which means we'll find the last scum quite fast.

Oh and by the way following our plan is still quite good against 2 scum, since even if there are 2 scum tracker/RB clears substantially lower odds of being scum.

[Llamarble]

Like Tracker, roleblocker, and white mage each only have 1 or 2 targets that are super strong each night.
We don't have killing power, and we don't the super strong investigative roles (cop or masons).
So yeah I am very convinced that this setup makes most sense with 3 scum.

[shaft.ed]

I'm voting for one of mastin or Llamarble today

Elli, which one should it be?

[Ellibereth]

I'll figure it out tonight. Just random thoughts and stuff for now
Scum aren't scared of farside at all was something I've been finding wierd.
I expected shaft.ed to die if the scum were dochunting.
from their pov
they know it's not ythill par n1.
not reg, poro, or far
wait wait but they killed fate so they never nk'ed fate previously (which means whatever farside did that night worked???)
aergeag

okay
basically
last night shouldn't the scum have narrowed down the pool down to 2 peoples at most for doc? i think. Too tired to go through the logic now someoneelse do it.

[shaft.ed]

Fate could have been doc, but fakeclaiming masons would be a ridiculously stupid thing for a Doc to do.

And yeah I've been dropping "hopefully subtle" Doc crumbs here and there to try and draw the kill.

Maybe we can assume scum don't know what theyre doing?

mastin also doesn't seem to know what he's doing...


still annoyed by the massclaim btw

[Ellibereth]

yeah I thought I could go unclaimed another day with my play + shitload of vanilla drops...
What doc crumbs >.>

[Porochaz]

So we have Tracker + white mage + roleblocker vs Janitor + goon + ?
Sounds about right to me. I'm still pretty much entirely convinced there are 3 scum.
I've played tracker + doctor + Masons vs roleblocker + goons, which about lines up with this.
So yeah we stick to plan autowin.

Mastin trying to push the 'there are 4 scum' angle makes a lot of sense if he's scum as people buying into that silliness is the only possible way for scum to win.
Elli can keep both Farside & Regfan protected for a bit, which means we'll find the last scum quite fast.

Oh and by the way following our plan is still quite good against 2 scum, since even if there are 2 scum tracker/RB clears substantially lower odds of being scum.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KRzMtlZjXpU

Seriously. (It'll be blocked for shaft.ed)

I once played a game with a lightning rod, a part vig,coroner, a mafia with an extra day kill and only one vanilla townie. It about lines up with this... see http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KRzMtlZjXpU

Dont click that link Im obviously being facetious.

[Regfan]

Yeah, I really thought it was Spring but Eli is right last night mafia

should

have had it narrowed down to very few realistic doctor candidates. I've played a lot of games with janitor elsewhere and it's a common occurrence to use the power night one so personally I don't think Llarmable was roleblocked then. That essentially means that Spring was saved and is clear.

Clears:

Farside, Regfan, VPBaltar, Elibereth, Spring.

Unclears:

(1) Shafted, (2) Llarmable. (3) Porochaz, (4) Mastin.

Four unclears and we have four lynches, we don't even need to coordinate night actions for this to be a guaranteed win if there's one mafia left. We need to be slightly more careful if there's two scum though because then VP moves out of the clear section so we should still attempt to organize actions. Farside mind taking over, I'm going back to bed.

[Porochaz]

Im going to be away for the next 3 days by the way.

[shaft.ed]

Im going to be away for the next 3 days by the way.

so you should probably reply to your PMs then

Unclears:(1) Shafted, (2) Llarmable. (3) Porochaz, (4) Mastin

Poro is semi cleared

can we lynch Llamarble now?


Does the Janitor have to make the kill to use their power? I thought that it was an independent ability.