SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[Parabollocks]

EBWOP: Bunnylover, not Vifam, vifam is the one who voted VanillaCupcake.

[DemonHybrid]

Alright, never hurts to ask.

[Kcdaspot]

Posting.

Need to reread.

brb.

[Kcdaspot]

Spoiler: This game is bad yo.

#9 Isa bandwagoning

#13 Projectmatt is my first scumread.

#17 Hoppster is town

#19 PROJECTMATT IS CONFSCUM

#23 DH is stupid

#28 Isa is dumber

#29 Xeras is town

#33 Vifam is town

#34 Hiplop is stupid

#36 and #38 Projectmatt is backpedaling.

#40 GET YOUR VOTE OFF OF OBV TOWN DH.

#42 huh?

#44 Oh so you were reaction testing. mmkay.

#45-46 DH is shaky town

#48 scumdar ping. nothing big enough yet.

#49 yep DH is town

#54 Yep Hopps is town too. Exchange w/ DH.

#58 Told ya. well, in the future but none the less.

#62 ISA SCUMALERT ISA SCUMALERT WEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

#68 vifam got dumb yo.

#70 I do not need to rvs. PM needs to DIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIEEEEEE

#73 hold on why is he suspecting everyone?

#74 I like this para guy. too bad he didn't read.

#78 Eh?

#81 EH?

#83 Sup diddin?

#84 and 85 DH isn't scum. what?

#87 I think you're town hoppster... ;_;

#89 ._______.

#90 oh hey town diddin. sup?

#92 and 93 Paranoid townies found.

#94 para is cool town

#98 DH is Solid town

#99 wat

#100 to #104 Stop it children you're on the same side. And where is PM in all of this?

#108 DEFLECTING HARDER THAN A AMERICAN POLITICIAN!

#111 huh?

#121 worthless discussion is worthless.

#132 BOUT TIME WE GET BACK ON TRACK.

#134 you know, good post. I agree where this is coming from but i think diddin is a little more town than this.

#136 manho is on the right track.

#138 DIRECTLY on track.

#139 you forgot a vote there sunset.

#141 and agian...

#142 Bunny is null for me.

#144 ATTABOY SUNSET

#145 #146 Sunset said it better, also sunset is town.

#147 OH GREAT CONFOOSED HYDRA.

#152 oh jackalope posted? huh?

#155 RISE OF THE LATE PEOPLE/ LURKERS

#158 Do. Not. Lynch. Hoppster. Full stop.

#164 How in the hell do you become THAT scummy in one post? Wrath shows us how! way to regurgitate a case.

#167 >_< WHY IN THE FUCK ARE YOU ALWAYS SCUM?

#168 I TOLD YOU THAT TOPIC WAS WORTHLESS BRAH.

#170 zzzzzzz

#171 scum scum gonna scum.

#174 This. Topic. Stops. Now. Stupidstupidstupidstupid

VOTE: projectmatt

I'm going to lynch you. This game. Here and now.

[Kcdaspot]

no this is not a drill.

PM dies. nothing less.

[Kcdaspot]

zzzzzzzzzzz

[Kcdaspot]

greatest. game. ever.

[projectmatt]

KDCA - why? No "because you are scummy" or "what an obvious scum" type comment I would expect from you. Your reads are 100% lacking of any value whatsoever if you can't provide anything close to a logical reason.

[Kcdaspot]

Unvote

It's time to quicklynch David Xantos. He is scum.

Vote: David Xantos

Fail reaction is fail.

I feel that there can't be two townies who ask the same exact anti-town question in a row. We can PoE through them if need be, but there's so much scum motivation between the two of them that I feel one of them need to die.

Why are you setting us up for two specific lynches?

Asking somebody to explain their read isn't any kind of tell at all. Don't be that person.

DH is scum for being paranoid? wat?

I feel that there can't be two townies who ask the same exact anti-town question in a row. We can PoE through them if need be, but there's so much scum motivation between the two of them that I feel one of them need to die.

Why are you setting us up for two specific lynches?

Asking somebody to explain their read isn't any kind of tell at all. Don't be that person.

Why is David scum?


At least bother to answer the question that started DH's derp vote on Xeras.

Why do you think I'm calling David scum?

WIFOM.

Good enough.

Unvote

Did you honestly expect me to have a solid scum read on page one? The purpose was to get out of RVS conversation going.

BACKPEDAL HARDCORE

No.

I'm saying that the fact that this happened:

Followed by this:

within the span of 5 minutes is fucking weird, and that I don't think that the BOTH of them could be town.

..Why? If a player says that "we should quicklynch player x, he's mafia!", the expected response to such a question is why? Both town and scum would be curious as to why somebody said this. Explain the scum motivation.

Yeah um no. You trying to falsify info here. Scum you try and exploit it. DH had a good reaction coming off of it so: fail

I don't thin scum would look so obvious out of the gate.

This was directed at the Isa wagon, right? You think that a scum would intentionally act obvious? No. A scum can act scummy unintentionally. This logic hurts my head.

Vote: Xeras

Thinking hurts your head? kay. Nice WIFOM again.

My bad. Your logic is still a tad illogical though.

Good news is, I was wrong about me finding it weird and Xeras/Vifam are probably town. See how magical RVS is?

I don't like this post. Did Xeras and Vifam objectively towntell to you, or did they just prove that you were attacking them based off of faulty logic? Why are they now town reads?

Says the non contributor.

Just in case you didn't know, the vote on David wasn't a "joke". It was a pressure builder and an attempt to get the discussion out of RVS.

I'm not going to jot down a list of my reads because I would be lying if I told you I had a specific scum read.

With that being said..

Unvote

Bunnylover

for this post:

@Sunset: I do not do catch-up post. Kinda useless to make a stand on something that has already ended imo.

and this cam NEARLY 100 POSTS LATER!

lurklurklurklruk HEY I'LL FAKEVOTE BUNNY FOR LULZ

[Kcdaspot]

a lot of do-nothing.

You're trying to seem helpful while really you're just skating by

LYNCH PLZ KAY THX

[Kcdaspot]

OH YEAH WHERES THAT DEFLECT DEFENSE NOW BUDDY UH HUUUUUUUH??

[projectmatt]

Fail reaction is fail.

Reaction to

what?

You also didn't tell me why you had a scum read on me because I silently voted Vifam on page one. Why did you find that post scummy?

DH is scum for being paranoid? wat?

DH is scummy for setting up two specific lynches and using poor logic to tunnel. Did you read?

WIFOM.

HOW IN GOD'S NAME DOES THAT POST EVEN HAVE SLIGHT CORRELATIONS TO THE CONCEPT OF WIFOM?

BACKPEDAL HARDCORE

Have you ever seen a player get a solid scum read on page one, when the player who is getting attacked has only made one post? Yeah, I don't think so. You know very well that it's not a backpedal.

Yeah um no. You trying to falsify info here. Scum you try and exploit it. DH had a good reaction coming off of it so: fail

I don't get this.

Thinking hurts your head? kay. Nice WIFOM again.

First of all, you should look up what "wifom" means. Secondly, logic that makes no sense whatsoever that was used to justify somebody as town "hurt my head". Where do you even..

Says the non contributor.

KDCA FOR COME BACK OF THE YEAR 11'

and this cam NEARLY 100 POSTS LATER!

lurklurklurklruk HEY I'LL FAKEVOTE BUNNY FOR LULZ

Your first post didn't come until one hundred and seventy seven full posts! It's not like you have human needs like eating, sleeping or not being on the computer every single minute of your life. This really is..

Your logic is honestly so completely "out there" that I hope to God Almighty that you are scum.

[Bunnylover]

@Sunset: I've done one catch-up post in only one other game. It was called terrible. Therefore I avoid catch-up, as you will note in my first post I said I was going to "read the thread" not make a "catch up post".
But I will answer you about Isa.
I do agree that its a weird vote that Isa placed down. I mean even Isa agreed that she/he intentionally made it vague. What kind of logic is that?
But I do not get how it makes Isa scum. If it was a non-serious vote, Isa would remove it before DH got lynched. If it was a serious vote, Isa would keep it on DH.

@DH #168: I do not know if that is his QT name. I am only assuming since Palla was the only one that Vifam commented on not reading the thread whole before making a post (top of page 4, like the second post). If Vifam does flip scum, I would be more incline to believe Palla is scum.

@Hoppster: Because I don't know about that function, so when I found out about it I checked and didn't see a Vanilia Cupcake name.

[DemonHybrid]

Um, matt, I certainly didn't set up a lynch. In fact, I was never committed and I noted that specifically.

[WrathChild]

I'm gonna go ahead and put Kcd on my town list for now. Too bold to be scum IMO.

@Kcd: Do you think project has been scummier than our current vote leader Isa? Why?

[WrathChild]

PS I have no clue about Kcd's meta, so please feel free to enlighten me if you've played with him before.

[Kcdaspot]

Reaction to

what?

You also didn't tell me why you had a scum read on me because I silently voted Vifam on page one. Why did you find that post scummy?

Vifam was RVS. AND you stopped playing around with the David vote, you said yourself. Look, He says he sees the OMGUS meaning he NOTED it. AND WHAT DO YOU DO? "OBVSCUM GOGOGOGOGOGOGO"

nope.avi

DH is scummy for setting up two specific lynches and using poor logic to tunnel. Did you read?

Better than you. He fosed 2 different people and voted one. your point?

HOW IN GOD'S NAME DOES THAT POST EVEN HAVE SLIGHT CORRELATIONS TO THE CONCEPT OF WIFOM?

With a straight face type down you weren't trying to WIFOM there. Simply put going of the origin of the phrase: You're trying to confuse poeple by saying "what kind of man am i? Why do YOU think I suspected him?" Then they try to Meta you to figure it out and it hurt their heads buying you time to sneak a lynch. GREAT TRY THOO. not.

Have you ever seen a player get a solid scum read on page one, when the player who is getting attacked has only made one post? Yeah, I don't think so. You know very well that it's not a backpedal.

you tried to push a case and a lynch, then you say "fair enough"? that's not a backpedal?

I don't get this.

Scum would try to exploit something from this. It wasn't DH because of his reaction so it must be another person and you were one of the if not the only person(s) to twist it upon DH sooo..

Nice try scum.

First of all, you should look up what "wifom" means. Secondly, logic that makes no sense whatsoever that was used to justify somebody as town "hurt my head". Where do you even..

"So how do you think scum would act Xeras?" is what i see there. sneaky backdoor WIFOM.

KDCA FOR COME BACK OF THE YEAR 11'

None of your posts to this point does the town any good. Get over yourself.

Your first post didn't come until one hundred and seventy seven full posts! It's not like you have human needs like eating, sleeping or not being on the computer every single minute of your life. This really is..

Your logic is honestly so completely "out there" that I hope to God Almighty that you are scum.

A. No one PM'd me that the game had started until today. (razzafrazza bowser razza)

B. Pray harder, maybe your scumminess will disappear too... NOT.

[Kcdaspot]

I'm gonna go ahead and put Kcd on my town list for now. Too bold to be scum IMO.

@Kcd: Do you think project has been scummier than our current vote leader Isa? Why?

Read. my. cases.

[Kcdaspot]

I may be mistaking David for DH somewhere in the wall up there but still.

Yeah.

Projectmatt votes PLEASE.

[David Xanatos]

VOTE: projectmatt

I've enjoyed watching him dig this hole.. I'd like to see what he unearths when he starts flailing again that deep down.

[DemonHybrid]

Um, matt, I certainly didn't set up a lynch. In fact, I was never committed and I noted that specifically.

projectmatt, please comment on this. Avoiding this will warrant a vote.

[Vifam]

Um, matt, I certainly didn't set up a lynch. In fact, I was never committed and I noted that specifically.

projectmatt, please comment on this. Avoiding this will warrant a vote.

Ultimatums rub me the wrong way.


Have not read the PM case yet, I'll get right on it.

[projectmatt]

Vifam was RVS. AND you stopped playing around with the David vote, you said yourself. Look, He says he sees the OMGUS meaning he NOTED it. AND WHAT DO YOU DO? "OBVSCUM GOGOGOGOGOGOGO"

What's important to note is that I had no specific read on David when I posted "david is scum. quicklynch him" or whatever. As I explained many times, the vote was a vote for pressure and to get discussion out of RVS. You seem to view it as "being scum scum and attempting to quicklynch whoever says anything against me". That's not the case. It just isn't.

Better than you. He fosed 2 different people and voted one. your point?

NO. Saying "I fos x and x for (insert something very illogical here)" is not pro-town in any way, shape or form. It's just trying to sound pro-town. It's not good.

With a straight face type down you weren't trying to WIFOM there. Simply put going of the origin of the phrase: You're trying to confuse poeple by saying "what kind of man am i? Why do YOU think I suspected him?" Then they try to Meta you to figure it out and it hurt their heads buying you time to sneak a lynch. GREAT TRY THOO. not.

Or, I was trying to get the discussion out of RVS and I was asking Vifam questions so he could say something interesting and get us out faster.

you tried to push a case and a lynch, then you say "fair enough"? that's not a backpedal?

I didn't try to push a case. My only thing that called David was the ONE post where I voted him. I said "fair enough" and unvoted once enough people had stopped being silly and started playing very seriously. Read my posts.

Scum would try to exploit something from this. It wasn't DH because of his reaction so it must be another person and you were one of the if not the only person(s) to twist it upon DH sooo..

Nice try scum.

I don't get this.

"So how do you think scum would act Xeras?" is what i see there. sneaky backdoor WIFOM.

That's not WIFOM. It's a legitimate question that I want him to answer. And even if it was WIFOM, it's not scummy.

A. No one PM'd me that the game had started until today. (razzafrazza bowser razza)

You missed the point. You tried to twist the fact that I didn't post for one hundred posts into being a bad thing. It means that I was doing something that wasn't pertaining to the internet.

Your logic is terrible. I'm helping the town by retorting it and showing everyone how twisted it is.

Demon

Um, matt, I certainly didn't set up a lynch. In fact, I was never committed and I noted that specifically.

When you were seen as very scummy, that's what you were doing. You were going "there is one scum between x and x, and we should lynch one today, and if he doesn't flip scum we should get the other tomorrow." You get the point.

David

VOTE: projectmatt

I've enjoyed watching him dig this hole.. I'd like to see what he unearths when he starts flailing again that deep down.

Paraphrase: I am going to sheep this lynch because.

[DemonHybrid]

Unvote, Vote: projectmatt

That's not what I said at all.

[DemonHybrid]

I feel that there can't be two townies who ask the same exact anti-town question in a row. We can PoE through them if need be, but there's so much scum motivation between the two of them that I feel one of them need to die.

First of all, I never said I was 100% committed. Second of all, I didn't say that if one flips town, the other needs to die.