SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[DemonHybrid]

RBT has had 9 pages of non-content to do something other than put an FoS on a popular wagon.

I would have voted. Maybe you should try reading some?

Vote: DH

[DemonHybrid]

Are you that terrible at scum, RBT?

-You put down an FoS on a popular wagon and comment on nothing else
-I vote you for not commenting on a single thing and placing an FoS on a popular wagon

-....you reply back, and vote me, somehow completely forgetting your "suspicion" on Isa?

[DemonHybrid]

This is what I want to see happen to you at the end of the day, RBT.

[Parabollocks]

Unvote, Vote: Riceballtail

I approve of this vote, and would be willing to join it with you on the fact i'm not tentatively sold on Isa even though to put in another's word "the only scum i could find, the rest are lurking."

unvote

ote: Riceballtail

[Parabollocks]

fjdsaio

unvote

Vote: Riceballtail

[Vifam]

Alright, this is the only wagon that you guys put up that I want to be apart of:


UNVOTE:


VOTE: RBT

[manho]

project is town. kcd is nulltown. so stop the town v town.

i will let rbt explain before deciding his alignment.

[Bunnylover]

Wtf is going on in this game, is everyone freaking scum or just been a little on the stupid side?
RBT But a FOS on the person she/he WANTS to vote.
But, does not put a vote BECAUSE she fears a quicklynch.

I find Isa to be a good tenative vote.

Don't want to potentially quicklynch or allow for it.

FoS:Isa

The bolded.
So where is this RBT wagon coming from.

[Parabollocks]

I never really liked the Isa vote, i'm content with the reasoning DH gave on the RBT vote, and i wouldn't mind the pressure of it.

all the rest of the banter has been very TvT.

[diddin]

BEFORE I PACK UP:


Town:

DH
Hoppster
Isa


Null-Town:

Xeras


Null:
Bunnylover


Null-Scum:
David
Diddin


And to preemptively strike down everyone who will ask for reasoning on the David Xanthos FOS, check his ISO, it's all fluff. Every bit of it.

Good Night.

Bullshit. You spent like two posts asking people why Dave is scum. This SCREAMS Scum trying to bus for towncred.

Yeah, I'm done. KDCA is resorting to petty insults and apparently fails to grasp the idea of a vote for reaction. If I say someone is scum, it is then my dedicated read. A+

Also, it's scummy to FOS people FOR NO REASON AT ALL or if it has NO LOGIC WHATSOEVER. Like what you are doing right now. With that being said, I like to think you are scum so I can excuse this ...logic.

Unvote

Vote: KDCA

This is a terrible vote, kcda is bleeding town right now. But still, I have a townread on projectmatt, he seems too agressive and confrontational for scum D1.

I find Isa to be a good tenative vote. Don't want to potentially quicklynch or allow for it.

FoS:Isa

....that's it?

Obviously you have never played with RBT before.

RBT has had 9 pages of non-content to do something other than put an FoS on a popular wagon.

I would have voted. Maybe you should try reading some?

Vote: DH

In other news holy SHIT this post is bad.


O hai here's those Vifam posts I mentioned.

I feel that there can't be two townies who ask the same exact anti-town question in a row. We can PoE through them if need be, but there's so much scum motivation between the two of them that I feel one of them need to die.

Why are you setting us up for two specific lynches?

Asking somebody to explain their read isn't any kind of tell at all. Don't be that person.

Why is David scum?


At least bother to answer the question that started DH's derp vote on Xeras.

Don't pull that mess.


Why is David scum?

So yeah. Vifam and DX have a STRONG chance of being Scum together. Isa's still the best wagon, but I could vote any of Vifam DX and RBT as well.

[DemonHybrid]

Wtf is going on in this game, is everyone freaking scum or just been a little on the stupid side?
RBT But a FOS on the person she/he WANTS to vote.
But, does not put a vote BECAUSE she fears a quicklynch.

I find Isa to be a good tenative vote.

Don't want to potentially quicklynch or allow for it.

FoS:Isa

The bolded.
So where is this RBT wagon coming from.

You must have missed the post where he threw all of that shit out of the window at the first sign of pressure.

[Kcdaspot]

...all right all right.

I'll drop it.

UNVOTE:

[DemonHybrid]

diddin: I HAVE played with RBT before, but that does not excuse that shit. I'm not willing to move my vote. Before she voted for me, I was willing to change it based on the content she put down, but my god.

[Kcdaspot]

yeah it's overwheliming.

VOTE: RBT

You had your chance and you blew it pretty big.

[Vifam]

What the fuck, Diddin? Those posts were EARLY in the game, not only that, but you're implying I had some type of prior town-read on him.

[Riceballtail]

Wtf is going on in this game, is everyone freaking scum or just been a little on the stupid side?

Most protown post I've seen all game.

DH you are just playing dumber than all get out. Seriously. I know you're better than this. My suspicion didn't go anywhere. But since I wasn't already voting, I just put it on another scumbag that needs to choke on some rope.

[diddin]

What the fuck, Diddin? Those posts were EARLY in the game, not only that, but you're implying I had some type of prior town-read on him.

o umad bro

I just don't think it's natural that you're quasi-defending David, then when you post reads you're like "Oh hey David is scum just read his ISO."

[DemonHybrid]

Wtf is going on in this game, is everyone freaking scum or just been a little on the stupid side?

Most protown post I've seen all game.

DH you are just playing dumber than all get out. Seriously. I know you're better than this. My suspicion didn't go anywhere. But since I wasn't already voting, I just put it on another scumbag that needs to choke on some rope.

"LOL U DUM"

Oh, and no reasoning. And you FoSed someone else without even mentioning me, only voting me when I vote you. And I'm the dumb one.

[DemonHybrid]

So, why did you vote me? Because I'm "playing dumb", which doesn't indicate alignment at all?

[Bowser]

Votecount is incoming.

[TheJakalope]

Still trying to gather thoughts together, but this game is moving quickly.

Not sure about Isa wagon. Going to reread a couple of pages.

However, I do like..

VOTE: RBT

[Bowser]

The "12 days left" votecount of Day 1

Ranmaru [L-12]

hiplop [L-11] Sunset

chkflip [L-12]

Kcdapot [L-11] projectmatt

Vifam [L-11] Bunnylover

David Xanatos [L-12]
TheJakalope [L-12]
manho [L-12]
Parabollocks [L-12]

projectmatt [L-11] David Xanatos

Riceballtail [L-7] DemonHybrid, Parabollocks, Vifam, Kcdaspot, TheJakalope

WeyounsLastClone [L-12]

Sunset [L-11] chkflip

WrathChild [L-12]
Xeras [L-12]

Bunnylover [L-11] WLC

diddin [L-10] Xeras, Isa

Isa [L-6] Hoppster, hiplop, diddin, manho, stormer, WrathChild

stormer [L-12]

DemonHybrid [L-11] Riceballtail

Celebloki [L-12]
Hoppster [L-12]

With 22 still kicking, it takes 12 to lynch, and 6 to lynch at deadline. Currently, Isa will be burned at the time limit.

Deadline is

(expired on 2011-09-08 13:00:00)

or

September 8th, 2011 @ 12:00pm CDT

[Kcdaspot]

Care to make a good post? at all?

[Isa]

TIME TO CATCH UP

First day at university yesterday, I am STILL hella tired.

@LORD BOWSER: Ranmaru needs a visit from your son.

[Isa]

Post #164 seems to summarize what I've made and why it's scummy. Everyone who feels like I haven't addressed their reason for voting me, tell me what post and I'll reply.

Ok now my obligatory RVS is out of the way:

Isa

ISO #0: "Hydras scare me" Personally I find Hydras to be good for town and hate them as scum. Hydras are unpredictable because of the nature of the slot and scum hate unpredictable things.

ISO #1: The RVS is not a total waste. I find that scum are most likely to vote scum during the RVS. With that sidenote out of the way, I feel that this RV is not funny or sincere, just awkward.

ISO #2: Is called out on ISO #2 by Hoppster and Isa finds it necessary to defend, what should have been an RV in no need of defense.

ISO #3: Interesting, he sheeps the guy he just RVed in ISO #1

ISO #4: Wait, Isa just said that ISO #1 was a serious vote, but in ISO #2 it was a serious vote and a joke vote. Oh wait, now it's back to being a joke vote again. Flip floppy flip flopper.

ISO #5: "I don't see why I'm scummy just because I'm acting scummy"

ISO #6: "I don't care if it was a serious vote or not" But why did you feel you needed to defend it in ISO #2?

ISO #7: A rather civil reply to Demonhybrid.

ISO #8: Deflects onto Hopster and Diddin. Keep in mind Hopster was the first person to attack Isa. Then OMGUS votes on Diddin.

Conclusions: Isa is probably scum. If Isa flips scum I wouldn't be surprised if Demonhybrid is scum too. Judging by the over-reactions and deflections, if Isa flips scum, Diddin and Hopster are probably town.

VOTE: Isa

Count me in on this bandwagon.

ISO #0: RVS. Had this kinda of hydra in mind when I did the post...http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lernaean_Hydra
ISO #1: That assumes that I am scum with DH. Spoiler: I am not. Also, even if you find it awkward, that's null.
ISO #2: I think it's good form to defend yourself when asked to. Why not?
ISO #3: What? No, my reply was to post #49, and I meant to say that Vifam sheeped for emphasis. In no way did I sheep DH.
ISO #4: Yeah, I said it was both in post 2, and I said it was both in post 4. It was a serious vote, made to put pressure on DH, and the reasoning I provided was meant to explain why I put the vote. So I did, in a little more humorous way than most votes are put.
ISO #5: Alright, (almost) everyone who's on my wagon and who has been on it: This seems to be the post that everyone has some kind of problem with. Hoppster had earlier said (#50) that he had did what I had done as scum once. That does not make my earlier post a scumtell in my book, which I stated. I've received a lot of votes with this post as the main motivation, and I am honestly curious as of why it is so scummy. What is it that makes it fishy and deflective? I'm not trying to steer attention to Hoppster (he's a townread to me), I'm just not seeing the case.
If it's the "Nah, I'm not."-part, that was aimed at "Isa is scum.", not "Looks like scum appeasing his attacker to me" (which I dunno, I suppose I was. I honestly didn't care how my vote was perceived).
ISO #6: Because I think it's good form to defend yourself when questioned.
ISO #7: Null
ISO #8: Everyone who said that this was an OMGUS vote needs to look it up. I think I provided sufficient reason to move my vote.
Hoppster is, again, a townread for me. He bothered forming a case. Look for the reasoning diddin provided though, and I see nothing.

Now, time to read up on the projectmatt/Riceballthingy cases.