SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[TheJakalope]

Alright, well RBT is lynch priority #1 today because of his bullshit "Vote for me if you're scum".

I'll do an ISO on diddin and see what I can present.

[Kcdaspot]

lookin forward to it.

[Bowser]

The "I'm drinking hot sauce to make this burn EXTRA CRISPY" votecount of Day 1

Ranmaru [L-12]
hiplop [L-12]
chkflip [L-12]
Kcdapot [L-12]

Vifam [L-11] Bunnylover

David Xanatos [L-12]

TheJakalope [L-11] Sunset

manho [L-12]
Parabollocks [L-12]
projectmatt [L-12]

Riceballtail [L-2] DemonHybrid, Parabollocks, Vifam, manho, David Xanatos, projectmatt, Celebloki, Xeras, stormer, Isa

WeyounsLastClone [L-12]

Sunset [L-11] chkflip

WrathChild [L-12]
Xeras [L-12]

Bunnylover [L-9] WLC, Hoppster, hiplop

diddin [L-12]

Isa [L-10] diddin, WrathChild

stormer [L-12]

DemonHybrid [L-11] Riceballtail

Celebloki [L-12]

Hoppster [L-11] Ranmaru

With 22 still kicking, it takes 12 to lynch, and 6 to lynch at deadline. Currently, Riceballtail will be burned at the time limit.

Deadline is

(expired on 2011-09-08 13:00:00)

or

September 8th, 2011 @ 12:00pm CDT

Let me know if this is incorrect. Prod check incoming.

[Isa]

@Mod: Sunset has two votes put out.

[Isa]

EBWOP: As does Ranmaru

[Kcdaspot]

doublevoters?

oh shi-

[Isa]

Final correction...I am at L-10, not L-9, unless diddin our WrathChild has their vote double up in value.

[Hoppster]

I don't see how applying your own meta to him would make him scum.

It's not meta, it's a scum-tell.

It's not something I always do as scum, I've done it once. But when I did it I did it very deliberately so I know how much scum motivation there is behind it.

I also see you being hypocritical in critisizing DH for not considering Vifam and that other dude as new, but you yourself don't even consider that Isa may be doing that because he is new.

Umm, no.

DemonHybrid OPENLY ADMITTED his reason for suspicion could be attributed to newb-ness.

Mine is not. Rather, I feel it's

paticularly

indicative of newb-scum. I did it in what was from memory my first or second scum game, and I haven't done it since and I wouldn't dream of doing so.

That's also not a scum tactic because I did the same myself in Into Africa as town, so essentially it's null to me.

Link pl0x.

What have you thought of Isa's recent play?

I swear I mentioned this...

Oh, yes, I did.

I hate how Isa's recent posts just ignore the RBT wagon

In addition to this, recent play has been improving and Isa is slowly sliding down in priority on my death-list.

@Hoppster: Wtf you mean follow-up?
The wagon were bad. I explained why RBT wagon was bad, not sure how I can't be clear on it. I didn't vote Project-Matt because I don't agree that he is scum for what he did. I found it weird what he did, but not sure how it = him been scum.
So exactly how does one follow up on that?

You believe the wagons are bad.

You don't then have ANY inclination to try and see who is scum hopping on an easy wagon?

And where has the Vifam thing been cleared up? What about the "reading 4 pages thing"? I can understand if you misplaced a vote on an outside vote, but not if you read a totally different game and had a reason for that vote based on the other game.
Then what about PinkLemonade, whoever that is?
Exactly what has been cleared up?

...

It's astonishing how little scum-hunting initiative you have.

I'm following up and doing all the research YOU SHOULD BE DOING, and I don't even believe in your stupid Vifam-slip idea.

My research has concluded that Pink Lemonade are a hydra account of Ranmaru + (current) GF. Vanilla Cupcake are an onsite hydra.

Tell me how this implicates Vifam-scum in any way or why this gives you a free pass to avoid scumhunting or generally being useful. If it does somehow implicate Vifam-scum, why are you not pushing it more or actually following up on it (like I've just done with providing links)?

Yeah, sorry about my inactivity. I'm having a hard time gaining interest in this game.

I'll give a few quick reads while I'm here.

Isa and Kcdaspot - Town

Vifam, Suneset - Neutral

RBT, diddin - Scum (RBT much more then diddin)

Why the hell would you go out of you way to specifically give Neutral reads on two paticular slots and then ignore 15 players?

This just reeks of giving reads for the sake of looking useful.


Willing to hammer RBT following a hammer-able claim.

[Sunset]

hoppster makes another good lurkalope point

Alright, well RBT is lynch priority #1 today because of his bullshit "Vote for me if you're scum".

I'll do an ISO on diddin and see what I can present.

these promises of your are empty

the main reason I'm voting you is because you make these promises but don't deliver

Forgot about this game for today.

Hmm. A lot of.. Null stuff going on. More thoughts tomorrow. I'm tired.

more thoughts tommorow? all we get is

Still trying to gather thoughts together, but this game is moving quickly.

Not sure about Isa wagon. Going to reread a couple of pages.

However, I do like..

VOTE: RBT

an unexplained opportunistic vote and another promise for a catchup

which leads to another post of fluff and then your bizzare reads list, the flaws hoppster has already highlighted

still comfortable with our vote

[WeyounsLastClone]

Got prodded, sorry for not posting earlier. Didn't know it'd go this quick (16 pages in three days, really).

The wagon on RBT has grown extremely quick in my opinion. His OMGUS on DH was a bit awkward, but okay.
At this point I find DH the most suspicious. It seems he takes things that are kinda null-tell, and tries to make a bit of a scum-thing out of it. First with Vifam, then with RBT.

Unvote. Vote: DemonHybrid.

[Sunset]

RBT is still obvscum but it's the not-so-obv scum I'm looking for right now

however a part of me feels AtE is just a staple of RBT play, town or scum. My past game with him tells me he plays like this as town

[Sunset]

Other head, to the QT NOW! I'd appreciate if you told me the next time you're changing our vote. I'm not sold on the Jakalopevote.

[DemonHybrid]

Got prodded, sorry for not posting earlier. Didn't know it'd go this quick (16 pages in three days, really).

The wagon on RBT has grown extremely quick in my opinion. His OMGUS on DH was a bit awkward, but okay.
At this point I find DH the most suspicious. It seems he takes things that are kinda null-tell, and tries to make a bit of a scum-thing out of it. First with Vifam, then with RBT.

Unvote. Vote: DemonHybrid.

Is that so? Throwing an FoS on a large wagon without giving any other content is null to you?

[Sunset]

We decided to keep our vote on TheJakalope.

[diddin]

Jakalope is a VI, so I'm really not interested in lynching him yet.

[Sunset]

so is RBT

she plays like this at town iirc...

[Kcdaspot]

Hey diddin/sunset:

Odds on both RBT and Jackalope being town.

[Kcdaspot]

for my money i'd call WLC a VI.

[Vifam]

What about Stormer?



He's had three post and 2/3 of those are jumping on every single wagon...

[Kcdaspot]

He's given a reason which gives him something. BUT NOT MUCH. I hope he either posts something substantial next time or gets replaced.

[TheJakalope]

Ok, so turns out, diddin's ISO is pretty uneventful. I'm not sure if I got this game mixed up or what, but I don't have scum read on him anymore.

[projectmatt]

Unvote

Not fully convinced on this wagon yet. Did RBT make a stupid appeal, yes? Can town players act stupid? Correct indeed. I don't want a hammer quite yet. I might re-join.

Vote: Isa

This wagon is better.

[Bunnylover]

@Hoppster: Any inclination? Yes I do, but I won't do it yet. Two bad wagons in my opinion, but does that mean the two people are town? I am a very careful player, and I don't like placing a vote on a person unless I have enough evidence to back it up. With a few days, then I believe that I can make a confident decision on which votes where town, scum, etc.
About the VC thing. Ok VC is a player, but then whats with the reason behind the vote? Did you read VC recent post? Their is nothing about not reading "a thread" that was only 4 pages long, so where is this reasoning coming from if it does not have some connection to this game.
I still don't understand the point of mentioning PinkLemonade.
I have never said I get a free pass of scum-hunting o_o. I just have more trouble doing it then others.
I've already said why I think its a slip, I'm not sure how to push it more.

[Vifam]

The whole point of my vote on that is that he was "ignoring" the thread, if he DID say something about this game why the heck would I put my vote up?



This is hypothetical but holy shit, you're not even making sense

[chkflip]

Whoa, missed a fair amount. Catching up now.