Open 325: Paris Mafia III - Game Over

[Hoppster]

I'm willing to compromise on Reck as a possible kondi-buddy, but Hell will freeze over before I let Maruchan-scum live if Reck is town.

and if reck is scum?

wut

you said you would not let maru live if reck flipped town...so he asked what happens if reck flips scum. do you still kill maru no matter what? or does he live.

umm, we win if Reck is scum... ?

[xRECKONERx]

There are two scum, herpderp.

[Hoppster]

There's no point in pretending Don Josh is not scum at this point though, is there? >_>

(FWIW, I was however talking about you being scum on the basis that Don Josh is scum and thusly assumed Maruchan was as well.)

[Maruchan]

I'm willing to compromise on Reck as a possible kondi-buddy, but Hell will freeze over before I let Maruchan-scum live if Reck is town.

and if reck is scum?

wut

You said Maruchan scum

IF

reck is town.

so what if he is scum?

[Hoppster]

You said Maruchan scum

IF

reck is town.

so what if he is scum?

>> DonJosh is scum
>> EITHER Reck or Maruchan is scum


If by some chance DonJosh ISN'T scum, Reck's not dying first, you are. The only thing that makes Reck possible scum in my eyes in interactions with kondi.

[Maruchan]

Oh no I understand you want me to die first. I just want to know what your opinion of Reck will be when I die and flip town. So (as of right now) you are 100% sure that DonJosh, and EITHER me OR reck are the scumteam?

[Hoppster]

Well, not

100%

sure, because as soon as I say something like that it comes back to bite me on my ass post-game. >_>

[Maruchan]

Yea, but you get my point. Is what I said correct?

[Wickedestjr]

Votecount 2.7:

DonJosh - [2] - whispersilk, Hoppster

xRECKONERx - [2] - scooby, DonJosh
hahonryuu - [1] - racerman13
Hoppster - [1] - xRECKONERx

Not Voting - [2] - hahonryuu, Maruchan

The lynch candidate in

red

text is the player that would be lynched if deadline hit right now.

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 4 to no-lynch.

[Wickedestjr]

I've decided to extend the deadline two days because I had to replace a player.

New Deadline: (expired on 2011-09-08 23:07:20)

[xRECKONERx]

Fuck it, let's do it.

Vote: DonJosh

Watcher on whispersilk & whispersilk vigs _________________.

[Maruchan]

When did my vote leave kondi (/replacement)?

Vote: DonJosh

[hahonryuu]

*sigh* I would prefer letting the guy say SOMETHING before killing him >_>. but then its been like 2 days since he joined and has said nothing. Not sure i totally blame him either, he came into the game at L-2...that must kinda blow haha. hopefully he hasn't totally given up and has been silent for some other reason. anyway, like i said i would like to hear something out of him before making the decision. but i cant speak for racer and scooby, they can potentially hammer at anytime. but I want to here his side before i do something..

@maru when he arrived you unvoted ^_~

[Maruchan]

Oh yeah when he promised a catch-up.

[Hoppster]

Yea, but you get my point. Is what I said correct?

Yes.

[whispersilk]

unvote

[whispersilk]

hoppster, why are you so convinced that Maru is scum?

From my POV, Maru is town. If he were scum, there is no way in hell he would have played day 1 the way he did. He came off as almost 100% mime, and therefore put himself at huge risk of being killed by me night 1. Why would scum risk half their team that way?

[whispersilk]

Reck, what part of "we're waiting for DJ to post" didn't you understand?

[whispersilk]

Ok, I reread all the 11 pages.

Comment by poster:

Maruchan: As I said yesterday he was either mime or VItown. I don't see scum opening the game like he did and all his posting throught the game screams VI (specially the vanilla softclaims). Should probably meta him to confirm this but not going to support a lynch on him.

Racerman13's entrance feels kinda good also. I don't think scum would open the game with a reference to a previous scum game. Gets shittier as I reread. Same stupid dilemma: scum or VI?

Hoopster: I like Hoopster. First serious post is potent. Further contribution is golden. Willing to lose the game if he is scum.

Kondi: basically meh player that seems to float around and not add anything at all. Would lynch him. Now that mimes are gone, what was the plan you were trying to save for later in post 201?

Reck: not your typical recktown that catches scum in page 3, so that would mean he was either mime or scum. With mimes gone, I'd also like to lynch him.

hahonryuu: after a reread, I trust him less but still was the first one to give stances on pretty much everyone. Would lynch him after reck and kondi dies and somehow one of them are town.

This is a very good point. Kondi never bothered to share his plan with us.

[whispersilk]

@scooby

, how do you feel about lyching kondi/DJ?

I don't think reck is going to be lynched today, but depending on which way kondi flips, he might become my target tonight.

[scooby]

@scooby

, how do you feel about lyching kondi/DJ?

I don't think reck is going to be lynched today, but depending on which way kondi flips, he might become my target tonight.

I plan to hammer him if he doesn't post in the following 24 hours.

I think Reck makes a lot of sense as a kondi's partner but he is also individually scummy. Reck is a beast as town and he definitely wanted to play this game. In a light game like this one, I don't see the reason of the apathy.

[whispersilk]

@mod: any idea where DonJosh is? Is he due for a prod?

I don't like the fact that Don has made one post requesting unvotes and claiming to be reading the thread. That was on sunday

[scooby]

He is also constantly posting on GD.

[scooby]

I refuse to believe that bolded part. What makes you so sure Hoppster and racer are town? You obviously don't have an investigative role seeing as there isn't really one in this game, and even if you were there hasn't been enough time to investigate hoppster maru and racer. Like it or not, they have done shady things...how is calling them out on it stupid or scummy. last I checked it was kind of our job/goal/mission to do just that. Not agreeing is one thing, but to call it dumb/scummy? I'm gonna have to ask for an explanation.

I have town reads on Hoopster and Maruchan. Please tell me what are the shady things they have done.

[whispersilk]

He is also constantly posting on GD.

Interesting, but not for the reasons you might think. He clearly has no desire to defend his slot, and it appears he's happy to just let himself be lynched. Is this what scum would do?

Or is this what vanilla town would do?