SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

Johhog · Post Post #600 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 2:23 am

In post 599, Hoppster wrote:
In post 297, Sunset wrote:BL has failed to impress us, but then again, BL isn't the sort of player who makes a lot of analysis and I have come to expect this type of play from BL sadly.
In post 594, Sunset wrote:VOTE: Bunnylover
Pretty sure there's at least one scum on the RBT wagon, maybe two. Bunnylover was fencesitting yesterday, not voting until she knew it was completely risk free.

???

I think the general trend in this game has been me considering Bunnylover scummy and my other head has considered her nullscum. I think I finally managed to convince head no. 2 now though.

Also I've never played with Bunnylover before so I can't meta her.

Sunset · Post Post #601 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 2:24 am

In post 600, Johhog wrote:
In post 599, Hoppster wrote:
In post 297, Sunset wrote:BL has failed to impress us, but then again, BL isn't the sort of player who makes a lot of analysis and I have come to expect this type of play from BL sadly.
In post 594, Sunset wrote:VOTE: Bunnylover
Pretty sure there's at least one scum on the RBT wagon, maybe two. Bunnylover was fencesitting yesterday, not voting until she knew it was completely risk free.

???

I think the general trend in this game has been me considering Bunnylover scummy and my other head has considered her nullscum. I think I finally managed to convince head no. 2 now though.

Also I've never played with Bunnylover before so I can't meta her.

Oh goddammit. Quoted for ISO reasons.

manho · Post Post #602 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 2:58 am

ok, bunnylover is scum. he knows RBT will flip town, which is something only scum knows. and that hammer is just bad. you shouldn't hammer someone you think is town. maybe he will eventually be lynched, but you shouldn't be the one to hammer.

vote: bunnylover

Vifam · Post Post #603 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 3:17 am

In post 574, hiplop wrote:he had scum reads, though KCDA. Other than for getting an easy lynch, what other explanations are there for that vote? How about town motivation? Its scummy as fuck

Agreeing with other people is scummy?

BunnyLover, who was reading null, has developed into a scumread because, like others have said he's done NO scumhunting, and as it stands, he has more votes on him.

Yeah, I have other scumreads, if it comes to the point where I'm no longer comfortable with my vote, I'll vote them.

Bunnylover · Post Post #604 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 3:37 am

Hey TheJakalope, do you mind answering this question?

In post 438, Bunnylover wrote:

TheJakalope wrote:Celeb, your post is actually true, in a couple ways. Not entirely, because I'm town. But,

I have been keeping up with the game. I just haven't had time to make any useful posts. High School just started, so it will be a bit before I can post anything huge.

I will post something large and useful. I can't make any promises, because I don't know when I have free time, until I actually have free time, but it is coming, and you can count on that.

However, RBT has done jack shit to defend himself, and so VOTE: RBT.

What kind of vote is this?
RBT isn't defending himself, therefore he is scum o-O?
How is that logical in any sense? Both scum and town would try their best to stop a lynch on them, so how can this cause RBT to be scum?

@Vifam: So your voting me because I've done no scum hunting and have the most votes on me o-o?

Vifam · Post Post #605 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 3:44 am

BunnyLover wrote:@Vifam: So your voting me because I've done no scum hunting and have the most votes on me o-o?

Yeah, basically.

hiplop · Post Post #606 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 4:03 am

Thinking this might be a scum-slip. Then again, it might just be hiplop being stupid/forgetful.

DRINKAN WHILE POSTAN etc. Admt it was stupid, just scrolled down and saw red >_<

When did "we" start to feel that Matt's town? I'm afraid you forgot to tell me.

you promised us no hydra dissonance....scum

hiplop · Post Post #607 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 4:04 am

Looking back, have to agree with hoppster, why is veryone suddenly so fascinated with a bunny lynch today? this screams easy lynch to me...

Sunset · Post Post #608 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 4:08 am

In post 607, hiplop wrote:Looking back, have to agree with hoppster, why is veryone suddenly so fascinated with a bunny lynch today? this screams easy lynch to me...

if we'd have wanted an easy lynch we'd have wagoned RBT with you guys yesterday
we're more concerned with lynching scum and that is why we want jakalope or BL today.
We have expressed suspicions of both since our first few posts.

BL's hammer and pre-emptive justifications for the townie flip are only the icing on the bunny cake

hiplop · Post Post #609 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 4:15 am

PERHAPS

Sunset · Post Post #610 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 4:25 am

i just don't see why everyone is going 'lol easy lynch' today when everyone was fine wagoning RBT yesterday...

I smell motives...

hiplop · Post Post #611 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 5:08 am

i wasnt

projectmatt · Post Post #612 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 5:21 am

Lynching the VI's is bad.

Vote: Jake

Bunny and Jake are my top scum reads. Want to get Jake today. It's Labor Day, so I'll be away for a while. More later.

Sunset · Post Post #613 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 5:26 am

In post 610, Sunset wrote:i just don't see why everyone is going 'lol easy lynch' today when everyone was fine wagoning RBT yesterday...

In post 611, hiplop wrote:i wasnt

what's this then?

In post 607, hiplop wrote:Looking back, have to agree with hoppster, why is veryone suddenly so fascinated with a bunny lynch today?
this screams easy lynch to me...

Hoppster · Post Post #614 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 5:26 am

In post 608, Sunset wrote:
In post 607, hiplop wrote:Looking back, have to agree with hoppster, why is veryone suddenly so fascinated with a bunny lynch today? this screams easy lynch to me...

if we'd have wanted an easy lynch we'd have wagoned RBT with you guys yesterday

wut

no

Easy lynch yesterday was RBT, not Bunnylover, shown with my screams of "HAI GUIZ BUNNYLOVER IS SCUM" to no effect,

HENCE WHY I AM SO SUSPICIOUS THAT

ALLLLL OF A SUDDEN

PEOPLE HAVE NOTICED BUNNYLOVER.

In post 608, Sunset wrote:BL's hammer and pre-emptive justifications for the townie flip are only the icing on the bunny cake

SO WHY DID YOU NOT SUPPORT MY BUNNYLOVER CASE YESTERDAY IF THIS IS JUST THE ICING ON THE CAKE?!

Sunset wrote:i just don't see why everyone is going 'lol easy lynch' today when everyone was fine wagoning RBT yesterday...

I smell motives...

See above.

I WANTED BUNNYLOVER LYNCHED

YESTERDAY

.

NOBODY SUPPORTED ME

(apart from Hiplop)

- IT

WASN'T

AN EASY LYNCH

AND SUDDENLY OUT OF NOWHERE THERE IS A BUNNYLOVER WAGON AND IT

IS

AN EASY LYNCH

So I'm thinking

"WTF?"

WHERE THE HELL HAS THIS WAGON COME FROM?

WHY WASN'T IT HERE YESTERDAY WHEN I MADE MY BUNNYLOVER CASE?

WHY HAVE PEOPLE SUDDENLY REALISED THAT BUNNYLOVER EXISTS?

In post 606, hiplop wrote:you promised us no hydra dissonance

THIS IS TRUE

In post 600, Johhog wrote:
In post 599, Hoppster wrote:
In post 297, Sunset wrote:BL has failed to impress us, but then again, BL isn't the sort of player who makes a lot of analysis and I have come to expect this type of play from BL sadly.
In post 594, Sunset wrote:VOTE: Bunnylover
Pretty sure there's at least one scum on the RBT wagon, maybe two. Bunnylover was fencesitting yesterday, not voting until she knew it was completely risk free.

???

I think the general trend in this game has been me considering Bunnylover scummy and my other head has considered her nullscum. I think I finally managed to convince head no. 2 now though.

Also I've never played with Bunnylover before so I can't meta her.

HOW DID YOU CONVINCE HIM

I WANT A FULL EXPLANATION OF HOW YOU CONVINCED TWISTEDSPOON

hiplop · Post Post #615 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 5:33 am

In post 613, Sunset wrote:
In post 610, Sunset wrote:i just don't see why everyone is going 'lol easy lynch' today when everyone was fine wagoning RBT yesterday...

In post 611, hiplop wrote:i wasnt

what's this then?

In post 607, hiplop wrote:Looking back, have to agree with hoppster, why is veryone suddenly so fascinated with a bunny lynch today?
this screams easy lynch to me...

I wasnt fine with wagonning RBT yesterday, fool.

Sunset · Post Post #616 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 5:38 am

In post 614, Hoppster wrote:
In post 608, Sunset wrote:
In post 607, hiplop wrote:Looking back, have to agree with hoppster, why is veryone suddenly so fascinated with a bunny lynch today? this screams easy lynch to me...

if we'd have wanted an easy lynch we'd have wagoned RBT with you guys yesterday

wut

no

Easy lynch yesterday was RBT, not Bunnylover, shown with my screams of "HAI GUIZ BUNNYLOVER IS SCUM" to no effect,
HENCE WHY I AM SO SUSPICIOUS THAT
ALLLLL OF A SUDDEN
PEOPLE HAVE NOTICED BUNNYLOVER.

In post 608, Sunset wrote:BL's hammer and pre-emptive justifications for the townie flip are only the icing on the bunny cake
SO WHY DID YOU NOT SUPPORT MY BUNNYLOVER CASE YESTERDAY IF THIS IS JUST THE ICING ON THE CAKE?!

we did, but we had other targets

we have had bunny lover suspicons for some time, ever since he failed to provie a catchup post and then claimed that everything previously had ended

we had not 'just realised bunny lover exists'

we found him suspect yesterday, but Jakalope more suspect

but after BL's hammer of scuminess he has risen again in our suspicions and overtaken jalakope

so BL is our top suspect again

simple

@hiplop:my mistake

I blame the mod for not providing I final VC. I asked for one

hiplop · Post Post #617 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 6:06 am

^^ BS

Isa · Post Post #618 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 6:20 am

VOTE: diddin

Is terrible cases what you're best at? All game you've thrown horrible cases around you, and the recent one against Vifam, for what she said more than a WEEK ago, half a thread ago, is no different.

Hoppster · Post Post #619 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 6:45 am

In post 616, Sunset wrote:we did [support your Bunnylover case]

No you didn't.

In post 297, Sunset wrote:BL has failed to impress us, but then again, BL isn't the sort of player who makes a lot of analysis and I have come to expect this type of play from BL sadly.

^^^^ quite clearly not supporting the Bunnylover case/wagon.

In post 616, Sunset wrote:we found him suspect yesterday, but Jakalope more suspect

but after BL's hammer of scuminess he has risen again in our suspicions and overtaken jalakope

so
BL is our top suspect
again

simple

orly?

Twistedspoon, tell me how Johhog convinced you that Bunnylover was scum.

Sunset · Post Post #620 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 6:51 am

I realised It was a logical fallacy on my own behalf

the only shred of defence I had for BL at the time was that I had played in a town game with him where he contributed little also. Sunset II convinced me that that didn't neccesairily mean that BL was town here as we had no scum meta to balance it out so my view was incomplete.
This realisation combined with my suspicions (as they were just suspicions)of BL yesterday and the circumstances of the hammer made me realise BL to be the prime lynch candidate for today

Sunset · Post Post #621 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 6:53 am

We have no intention of giving BL a get out of jail free card due to a brief encounter in one past game where he also failed to impress

The scuminess far outweighs the small flickers of townieness that I thought I once saw

Celebloki · Post Post #622 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 7:11 am

Prod Dodge, I'll post more tomorrow when I get time. I am caught up in Labor Day activities. I'm sad to see RBT flipped town, he just confirmed that he is a horrible anti-town player that is now blacklisted for me.

I am unsure about the Bunnylover wagon but I can see where the case is coming from. I still thinking TheJakalope was incredibly scummy yesterday and would like to see him get more pressure and post his thoughts. The way he promised more content and then threw diddin's name out as scummy (which he admitted to just latching onto because his name was getting thrown around, not actually believing he was scummy himself) and then hopped on the easy wagon to coast away the day on when he read diddin and got nothing.

Vote: TheJakalope

TheJakalope · Post Post #623 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 7:22 am

Find Hoppster's post interesting.

"EVERYONE, BUNNYLOVER IS SCUM, I SAID THAT YESTERDAY, NOW WE ARE ALL SAYING IT, I THINK BUNNYLOVER IS SCUM, BUT EVERYONE ON THE WAGON NOW IS SUSPICIOUS, SO I'M GOING TO VOTE SOMEONE THAT ISN'T ON THE WAGON AND ISN'T BUNNYLOVER"

Like.. what?

Vifam · Post Post #624 (ISO) » Mon Sep 05, 2011 7:26 am

I don't think anyone was "ignoring" BL, it's just that there was more focus on RBT's scummy/antitown play. It simply stood out more.