SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[David Xanatos]

I find it ironic that a magikoopa's accusing someone of being an invader. :3

[TheJakalope]

BunnyLover, what's the question?

How is not defending yourself a trait that scum will do.

When I play as scum there's sometimes a point, depending on my play during that game, where I say "Shit. I'm most likely going to get lynched." That's what it seemed like with RBT. Some people Flail before they get lynched, I give up. Both should be signs to hammer.

[hiplop]

What would you consider "flailing" jakolope? It seems to me you just said "if they give up hammer, and if they defend themselves, hammer"

[diddin]

"Day 2 Starts"


"OH YEAH VIFAM IS OBVSCUM LOLOLO"


"OH WAIT LOOKS LIKE I CAN'T START A WAGON ON VIFAM, GUESS I'LL SHEEP THIS"

I'd rather be on a Scumlynch that can actually happen then be sitting being the only vote on another scum.

So why didn't you vote BunnyLover originally? Why did you start out with your initial vote on me when a BunnyLover wagon was OBVIOUSLY building up.


No, you're scum.

Idunno, because I thought I could start a wagon on you leading to a lynch? Pity me for trying to make a case on someone.


Jak wagon is eh I'd prefer a Bunny lynch.

[Vifam]

"Day 2 Starts"


"OH YEAH VIFAM IS OBVSCUM LOLOLO"


"OH WAIT LOOKS LIKE I CAN'T START A WAGON ON VIFAM, GUESS I'LL SHEEP THIS"

I'd rather be on a Scumlynch that can actually happen then be sitting being the only vote on another scum.

So why didn't you vote BunnyLover originally? Why did you start out with your initial vote on me when a BunnyLover wagon was OBVIOUSLY building up.


No, you're scum.

Idunno, because I thought I could start a wagon on you leading to a lynch? Pity me for trying to make a case on someone.


Jak wagon is eh I'd prefer a Bunny lynch.

You didn't make a case, you've decided to give up and fall back on the BunnyLover wagon. Which you've done more then once.

[TheJakalope]

Flailing is saying "I'M NOT SCUM BECAUSE I'M TOWN, YOU'RE ALL STUPID"

Giving up is giving up.

Defending yourself is explaining the scum reads on you, and probably presenting a better case on someone else.

[Isa]

Guys

diddin needs more votes

He misreps, refuses to build cases and sheeps to the Nth degree, and on day 1, he said "Bunny is just being Bunny" in a way that suggests that he believes her to be town (#309) and now he has made another quick sheep, throwing his old implied read away and is voting Bunny.

SO DO IT

[manho]

diddin is still not scum.

[Isa]

Reason being?

[Ranmaru]

#619

Good catch Hoppster. I'm starting to like you.

Vote: Sunset

I don't think your defense really explains the contradiction, Sunny. I mean, it appears like you did intend on letting BL go with the meta, and it seems like a fake scum read.

---

Vote: stormer

explaix?

once he pops his head up i will

Where you at soup? He did pop his head, when you voted him.

Stormer, why haven't you said anything?

---

GUYS DONT GET DISTRACTED.

LYNCH BUNNYLOVER FOR BEING WEIRD AROUND THE RBT WAGON.

RBT's flip looks more like an independent flip, since he's in the island, and not with others, meaning he's solo. (possibly) How does this look like to you from this pov? (wrt to Bunny)

Don't like Bunnylover, probScum, but Jakalope seems worse to me.

VOTE: Jaka

Analysis when my stomach stops churning.

How's that analysis coming

Everyone

: KCda is still town to me. IF you think he's scum, state your reason as to why.

[hiplop]

definitely wouldnt be opposed to sunsets death.

[Bunnylover]

@Ranmaru:
Can you explain this again or tell me if I understand you correctly:
"RBT's flip looks more like an independent flip, since he's in the island, and not with others, meaning he's solo. (possibly) How does this look like to you from this pov? (wrt to Bunny)"
What your saying is that RBT flipped third party or am I misunderstanding you?

[Hoppster]

i don't think the Jakalope is scum.

@hoppster, bunnylover is not that scummy until his hammer and the RBT flip. that's why no one cared about your case.

Disagree strongly with both of these.

@Hoppster how do u know that BL is scum, i found him scummy aswell but you wer there screaming like you KNOW he is scum.

Bunnylover was scummy yesterday, and as such I was trying my hardest to get him/her lynched. Most of the playerlist didn't even

acknowledge in passing

my case though.

Today, BAM. Bunnylover wagon. That's dodgy.



Please don't make me spam caps/font 300. TheJakalope is still ignoring my case and needs to die. It would seem that he has no scum-reads as well.


I would be reasonably satisfied with a Sunset/diddin lynch (both of whom are voting Bunnylover, how about that), but seriously, Jakalope death is the pro choice for today.

[Sunset]

Can anyone please explain the case against us again?

[Hoppster]

First point against you - that dodgy hydra dissonance which you promised wouldn't occur.


Second point - BOTH PLAYERS of the hydra somehow missed my requests for information on hydra-QT-discussionz, despite acknowledging other parts of those posts:

HOW DID YOU CONVINCE HIM

I WANT A FULL EXPLANATION OF HOW YOU CONVINCED TWISTEDSPOON

Twistedspoon, tell me how Johhog convinced you that Bunnylover was scum.

^^^^ yes, that is BOLD and font-size ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY.

While you're here you can tell me though.

[WeyounsLastClone]

Am I really the only one who finds DH suspicious?

[projectmatt]

Am I really the only one who finds DH suspicious?

Make a larger case and I'll re-consider it. I've been getting "whatever" vibes from him all game. Jake and Diddin are a probable scumteam at the moment. Diddin for betraying his read on Bunny in favor of lynching him and avoiding the Jake wagon, and for stating he wants to lynch Bunny more with no legitimate reason.

[Sunset]

First point against you - that dodgy hydra dissonance which you promised wouldn't occur.


Second point - BOTH PLAYERS of the hydra somehow missed my requests for information on hydra-QT-discussionz, despite acknowledging other parts of those posts:

HOW DID YOU CONVINCE HIM

I WANT A FULL EXPLANATION OF HOW YOU CONVINCED TWISTEDSPOON

Twistedspoon, tell me how Johhog convinced you that Bunnylover was scum.

^^^^ yes, that is BOLD and font-size ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY.

While you're here you can tell me though.

Well, your making a hen out of a feather (or whatever the English expression is) here. Head #2 said that WE had a townread on Matt. Do you think I should just sit back and watch?

As for your second point, Head #2 already answered it. Do you want quotes from the QT, or what?

[Hoppster]

Well, your making a hen out of a feather (or whatever the English expression is) here. Head #2 said that WE had a townread on Matt. Do you think I should just sit back and watch?

As for your second point, Head #2 already answered it. Do you want quotes from the QT, or what?

Point 2 - touché. Ironically I missed the response from Twistedspoon. >_____>

Paraphrased quotes from the QT would be swell though.


Point 1 - If you accept that there will be disagreements, why aren't you signing your posts?

[stormer]

@WLC, yesterday DH from what i remember felt town to me but today he has lent towards the other side because of his tunneled vision against, now again im not saying BL is clean but all these people jumping this easy wagon caught me and i smelt something fishy.
hence why most of the people on the BL wagon i find either null or leaning scum.

[DemonHybrid]

I just don't really care much if people are presenting cases like "Bunnylover wasn't voted for yesterday and now he is so fuck that shit" when RBT was such a huge distraction last night. If people aren't going to look at all sides of the argument, I'm not going to care.

[manho]

diddin is still not scum.

Reason being?

his actions are not that scummy. at least i've done that before as town. BL is much more scummy than diddin.

[chkflip]

VOTE: TheJakalope

No time. Case in next post.

[Isa]

diddin is still not scum.

Reason being?

his actions are not that scummy. at least i've done that before as town. BL is much more scummy than diddin.

Hey, this seems familiar...remember when Hoppster and Ranmaru said the same thing about my actions? "I've done that as scum so it's a scumtell." "I've done it as town so it's a null tell!" It's still a worthless argument.

But then tell me, what's not scummy about first dismissing the Bunny wagon and then jumping on it without acknowledging your previous read? Or sheeping ALL the cases you believe have merit without any fresh input? And what about his misreps? Are they pro-town behavior?

[stormer]

may i remind you all that jakalope is L-3 right now