The Children of Húrin Mafia (GREAT REVIVAL)

[Empking]

Def. 3rd party.

So you're going to vote him right?

[Andrius]

Def. 3rd party.

So you're going to vote him right?

Maybe. I don't think he's hostile. If he were, again, he wouldn't have claimed.

But we can get clarification from him when he gets back. Because I want to know just what he has to do to complete his wincon. It might be some sort of hoakey "win with the town" deal he doesn't know about, as winning with scum = no-go as he'd get endgamed for sure.

Meh.

[kanyeknowsbest]

as winning with scum = no-go as he'd get endgamed for sure.

what. third party can definitely win with scum, see: survivor and lyncher/reverse lyncher (what gandalf probably is)

[Andrius]

as winning with scum = no-go as he'd get endgamed for sure.

what. third party can definitely win with scum, see: survivor and lyncher/reverse lyncher (what gandalf probably is)

I can see Survivor, true.
I can see Lyncher to Balrog, who might be Morgoth_Scum or might be a Lyncher to Gandalf.
Basically, I want to hear from him.
And then I'll decide.
Yes, its taking a risk, but I'd like to think I know gandalf well enough to know he wouldn't be all lulzy like this as hostile scum.
Because Gandalf_Lyncher is clearly out to get Balrog, who's CLEARLY not town.

[Katsuki]

Apparently I'm someone irrelevant.

BUT GANDALF NEEDS ROPE

VOTE: GANDALF

P.S. FOR THOSE WHO WANT AN EXAMPLE OF NON-HARMFUL 3P PLAY FROM GANDALF, READ SITMOA II MAFIA


THIS GAME ALSO NEEDS SIGNIFICANTLY LESS FLAVOR TALK AND MORE MAFIA RELATED TALK!

[Katsuki]

TL;DR VER OF LAST POST:

GANDALF IS SCUMMMMMMMM

[Katsuki]

Andrius really needs to stop this dancing around gandalf and flavor nonsense

[Plum]

But Andróg said: 'But whom shall we serve, if not ourselves? Whom shall we love, when all hate us?'

'At least my hands shall not again be raised against Elves or Men,' said Túrin. 'Angband has servants enough. If others will not take this vow with me, I will walk alone.'

The Children of Húrin (114)

VOTE COUNT #1.1

SpyreX - 1 - Gut
Gut - 2 - MagnaofIllusion, PeregrineV
Katsuki - 1 - VitaminR
Andrius - 1 - Mastermind of Sin
kanyeknowsbest - 1 - Magister Ludi
gandalf5166 -

6

- Empking, SpyreX, kanyeknowsbest, Furcolow, LordChronos, Katsuki
Furcolow - 1 - Andrius

Not Voting (9): Sun and Moon, Chronopie, gandalf5166, Ellibereth, Dekes, mockingjaye, Wraith, Espeonage, Will-o-wisp

With 22 alive it will take 12 votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day 1 will be in approximately (but no less than) 14 days and will be exactly determined soon.

[Espeonage]

Currently rereading the Silmarillion. I have 'some' flavour knowledge but not much.

Also Andy I believe is town as the exact same thing happened to me in a SC game and everyone who didn't know their role ended up town. Then again it could be random or whatever. But for now Andrius goes in town pool.

Gandalf's claim is bullshit imo. Any self respecting person who knows flavour wouldn't do that I hope. Looking at you Plum.

Dislike that we are having a serious day one. I hate games that do that.

Also an open claim of how much flavour knowledge everyone knows or has quick access to would be good. EG, I have The Sillmarillion sitting next to me with an index even though I am still rusty on details.

[kanyeknowsbest]

Dislike that we are having a serious day one. I hate games that do that.

whats wrong with serious day ones? the sooner shit gets real the better.

[kanyeknowsbest]

also if you think gandals claim is bullshit wheres your vote

[Espeonage]

I don't think he's scum. Just an idiot. He aspires to great things and trys to mimic good players. His execution however is bad.

[Espeonage]

Also serious day ones usually end badly from my experience.

[kanyeknowsbest]

so you would rather.. what, everyone just not scum hunt d1 and randomly lynch someone?

so you think gandalf is lying about his claim but is town then?

[Mastermind of Sin]

The first counterwagon that starts on someone voting gandalf, poke me. I'll be down for that.

[Chronopie]

This thread moved fast. I possess

some

flavour knowledge atm, and I'm expecting a copy from the library to arrive in the next few days.

That being said, I believe gandalf's claim, and as such, those pushing the wagon have an increased likelyhood of being scum.

A great smoke rose about us, vapour and steam. Ice fell like rain. I threw down my enemy, and he fell from the high place and broke the mountain-side where he smote it in his ruin. Then darkness took me, and I strayed out of thought and time, and I wandered far on roads that I will not tell.

~Gandalf the White, The White Rider, The Two Towers.

[kanyeknowsbest]

whether or not you believe his claim isnt the issue, its whether or not you think he is third party that is beneficial or detrimental to town.

[Chronopie]

I believe he is a third party that is not directly in conflict with the town wincon, thus his lynch would be detrimental.

[Espeonage]

If he is what he claims to be he isn't bad for town. I want to keep him around to actually possibly find out what he actually is before going and lynching him. Put simply I have no idea if he is lying or not.

And no of course you don't not scumhunt, you just don't get all serious. People need to ease into a game. Taking the first day slowly and not really doing too much early actually helps later on as people have more interest in the game. It's far to late for that though.

That's actually decent Chrono.

Kanye is too concerned about this. The issue is trivial at this point.

Vote: Furc

[Mastermind of Sin]

Fuck, LoL is down.

Unvote, Vote: Furc

[Furcolow]

...?

[Furcolow]

2 votes in a row, 0 reasons
cool story

[Mastermind of Sin]

Hey, be fair. I gave a reason.

[Furcolow]

i was just making a huge post about why gandalf is lying, the detriments of what third party he could possibly be based upon the story, and then there is an idiotic flash wagon forming on me? not cool

i'm at 3 votes, and 0 reasons now
good job

[Furcolow]

your reason was "i'm going to sheep"
that is not a reason for "this is why i'm voting the person i'm sheeping on"
it was more like im going to be an idiot and proxy my vote to whoever does action A.