The Children of Húrin Mafia (GREAT REVIVAL)

[Furcolow]

still not a reason for you voting ME

[Furcolow]

yeah, lets get the guy trying to scumhunt and deduce who could be scum and third party so that he can get them lynched

[Mastermind of Sin]

your reason was "i'm going to sheep"
that is not a reason for "this is why i'm voting the person i'm sheeping on"
it was more like im going to be an idiot and proxy my vote to whoever does action A.

Actually, my reason is that I'm voting you cuz LoL is down, and I was feeling Espy-withdrawal.

[Furcolow]

If he is what he claims to be he isn't bad for town. I want to keep him around to actually possibly find out what he actually is before going and lynching him. Put simply I have no idea if he is lying or not.

And no of course you don't not scumhunt, you just don't get all serious. People need to ease into a game. Taking the first day slowly and not really doing too much early actually helps later on as people have more interest in the game. It's far to late for that though.

That's actually decent Chrono.

Kanye is too concerned about this. The issue is trivial at this point.

Vote: Furc

summary of this post: "Gandalf is good for the town
he might not be lying (when it is 100% clear that he is, as his character WAS ALREADY IN THE SILMARILLIONS TIME PERIOD AND WOULDNT NEED TO GO BACK)

it's ok to scumhunt, but guys, let's joke
lets take this slow"

then he votes me for no reason
what a joke post
this better be a reaction test, or else

[Furcolow]

anyways, gandalf's character is called olorin, he is a maiar, and he wouldnt need to go back in time as he already was there with manwe

[Mastermind of Sin]

...and?

[Furcolow]

im not talking to you.
i'm talking to everyone who isn't a sheep, the rest of the town who has competency.

Espeonage said "we don't know if Gandalf lied"
I have provided multiple reasons for exactly that

His name is a lie
His "time-travelling" is a lie, as it wouldn't be needed
He is a liar

[Mastermind of Sin]

Unless...YOU are the lie!

[gandalf5166]

Gandalf, are you told anything about the timestream?

- Oversoul

I would assume that what it means is that things have to end up the same way as they would have had I never come here, i.e. how they did in the book.

there IS no timestream. he CANNOT be gandalf, if his name is gandalf. Gandalf CANNOT EXIST in 2 places at the same time, can he? IT WOULD RIP THE SPACE-TIME-CONTINUUM.

he was alive, and was a maiar of manwe, and was called olorin
he is lying
lynch all liars
lynch gandalf 2011

This post is really lol. thanks for telling me Olorin exists at this point though. Do I need to worry about accidentally interacting with him, or is he not involved in the story?

Disclaimer: No flavor knowledge of this whatsoever.

Good.
Because if you, gandalf, and other flavor-ignorant idiots are the scumteam this should be a cinch.

LOL IF YOU END UP SCUM

Andy, your thinking is correct. Take this out of context of the last quote, I'm intentionally separating it from what it's referring to.

GANDALF5166: DO YOU KNOW HOW YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO FULFILL YOUR WINCON? Aka, killin' Balrogs, etc.?
Or are you just floating in the water too?

No, I asked. She wouldn't tell me I do know I have to survive. I'm thinking that maybe some characters that don't have a huge impact on the future might not be important to my wincon.

as winning with scum = no-go as he'd get endgamed for sure.

what. third party can definitely win with scum, see: survivor and lyncher/reverse lyncher (what gandalf probably is)

I can see Survivor, true.
I can see Lyncher to Balrog, who might be Morgoth_Scum or might be a Lyncher to Gandalf.
Basically, I want to hear from him.
And then I'll decide.
Yes, its taking a risk, but I'd like to think I know gandalf well enough to know he wouldn't be all lulzy like this as hostile scum.
Because Gandalf_Lyncher is clearly out to get Balrog, who's CLEARLY not town.

That's something I hadn't considered, that maybe the Balrog had gotten transported back with me. If so, he's probably an SK, and he would probably be immune to normal kills. I do have one mystery ability, that might be what it's for.



Furc...... you're overreacting a little bit to three votes.

Unless...YOU are the lie!

The cake is the lie.

[Ellibereth]

wut is this

[Furcolow]

I am not overreacting to votes when they have NO reason behind them, when I am adept at the subject involved (I just brought down my unfinished tales... which.... I have left unfinished after all these years), and I am actively scumhunting and calling YOU out on lying

[SpyreX]

OK,

Who is LoL? I mean I, as a beautiful princess, do giggle and lol but who IS LoL?

Esp's reasons for not voting gandalf are skeeetch

[Ellibereth]

Spy I'm doing homework and don't want to read what road is this game going on?

[SpyreX]

Its went right to plaid.

Gandalf is drinking madness and everyone AGREES its madness but keeps pish poshing him being dead.

Andy apparently doesn't have a wincon so can get shot in the face (sorry bro).

I'm a beautiful princess.

Most other stuff is ancillary and good lord if I have to put the angry hat on to explain why gandalf-gate is never, ever, ever, ever going to end welp.

[Chronopie]

By LoL, Mos and Espy mean League of Legends.

You should join us. (That goes for everyone)

[Magister Ludi]

Furc, answer my question please.

[gandalf5166]

I am not overreacting to votes when they have NO reason behind them, when I am adept at the subject involved (I just brought down my unfinished tales... which.... I have left unfinished after all these years), and I am actively scumhunting and calling YOU out on lying

But it's three votes, and you just flew into a rage over three votes. Regardless of any of that, it's only three votes.

[Furcolow]

three votes, three votes, three votes? what is this, the wizard of oz? what are you repeating yourself three times for, some ruby slippers taking you home?

[Furcolow]

unvote;
vote: Chronopie

[Magister Ludi]

Furc, answer.

[Furcolow]

Ludi, phrase it as such, and I might

basically, quit being bossy

[Furcolow]

you didn't ask a question, bub

[Magister Ludi]

I know what I want to do, just forgot how to do it
so we can slay some goblins, need to find my bro Turin

Furcolow, clarify.

[Furcolow]

Ludi, phrase it as such, and I might

basically, quit being bossy

[Magister Ludi]

This wouldn't have spanned several pages if you answered the first time.