camn's temperamental - Mini 1232 - GAME OVER

[Twistedspoon]

Your reasoning is incorrect Twistedspoon. There is nothing wrong with there being two of the same role. Unless the setup explicitly states there cannot be two of the same role then assuming such on day 1 is a poor assumption.

link me to a mini with 2 cops and I'll be convinced and there will be no further objections because I'm not seeing it

[kanyeknowsbest]

What if it is the opposite? What if Parama is scum and he knows that the scum have scummy rolenames, so he sacrifice himself to lynch the Name Cop. I don't know how likely this is though, Parama is reading town to me.

Mafia have something called a night kill.

[kanyeknowsbest]

Your reasoning is incorrect Twistedspoon. There is nothing wrong with there being two of the same role. Unless the setup explicitly states there cannot be two of the same role then assuming such on day 1 is a poor assumption.

link me to a mini with 2 cops and I'll be convinced and there will be no further objections because I'm not seeing it

Did you know that a name cop and a real cop are two completely different things?

[Johhog]

What if it is the opposite? What if Parama is scum and he knows that the scum have scummy rolenames, so he sacrifice himself to lynch the Name Cop. I don't know how likely this is though, Parama is reading town to me.

Mafia have something called a night kill.

So? If Parama didn't claim and we didn't lynch BBmolla (remember that the wagon on him was starting to vanish) he would likely get protection (because I assume there is of some sort) as the only claimed PR.

[kanyeknowsbest]

You can't assume protection. Plus there was the dubious nature of his claim. You don't trade one for one in that situation.

[camn]

soonsoon

BBmolla

- 5

( Parama RedPanda Johhog kanyeknowsbest Lurconis )

Chair

- 3

( Haylen PeregrineV fishythefish )

kanyeknowsbest

- 1

( Zang )

Zang

- 1

( twistedspoon )

twistedspoon

- 1

( Chair )

NOT VOTING:

( Sathoris BBmolla )

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
Deadline is

WED, SEPTEMBER 14th

, 9am MY TIME.. . Or whenever I get around to it.

[Twistedspoon]

Your reasoning is incorrect Twistedspoon. There is nothing wrong with there being two of the same role. Unless the setup explicitly states there cannot be two of the same role then assuming such on day 1 is a poor assumption.

link me to a mini with 2 cops and I'll be convinced and there will be no further objections because I'm not seeing it

Did you know that a name cop and a real cop are two completely different things?

they still are investigative roles

[PeregrineV]

So in effect we have a counter claim to BBMolla by Parama?
Outstanding!
The last time cops counterclaimed each other, they were both allowed to live and scum killed the town cop. The scum cop was lynched the next day despite his protests, but we had already lost the cop.
But these aren't even real cops, they're claiming rolename cops.
Both town?
Maybe.
One scum, one town.
More likely.
Both scum?
LMAO- That would be a kick in the dress greens.

I might be convinced to lynch neither and let is resolve like last time, or we can take a chance and maybe get the right one.

I'd like to see more from both over the next few days while we weigh our options.

Disappointed my two-part weapon system theory doesn't seem to apply.

If you have not yet weighed in on this, you are on TDY to do so.

[Sathoris]

VOTE: Twisted

I'd rather see him go then BB. I realise I'm not providing a valid reason and I'll try to give you one as soon as I can™. Just like to make the vote official.

[Twistedspoon]

then I shall hold out for your reason (although the other vote on me hasn't been explained either)

[Zang]

Parama- Did you claim your role name? If scum have different role name types then the flavor cops could investigate eachother.

Link me to a mini with 2 cops and I'll be convinced and there will be no further objections because I'm not seeing it

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=15774

Both me and don_johnson were cops. Although a flavor cop isn't exactly a cop.

[Parama]

I am the Architect.
Also, I want everyone to take a look at this chart.
I had a small lecture on this shortly before this game started. I didn't realize it was going to be the flavor of the game until I got my role PM, then was like "WELP."
Hence why I think a flavor cop has little to no usefulness in this game, apart from catching players who lie about their role name.
If ANYONE has a character name not on that table, they should claim now.
I don't think we should full name-claim right now, though. I wouldn't doubt that character names correspond to power roles at least to some degree (there is flavor in my role PM explaining why my character is my role, so).

[kanyeknowsbest]

Lol, Myers-Briggs.

[Twistedspoon]

tricked into playing a psycology themed game....

anyways, I'll play 2 cops. I may have been convinced

[Fishythefish]

Back from V/LA. Also drunk. Reading, will only do anything else tonight if the answer is obvious.

[Fishythefish]

I am on the Myers-Briggs chart. I agree that we shouldn't fullclaim. I absolutely don't want scum to know who the Inspector is.

My instinct is that we should lynch BB, but I'm not certain enough to vote. A more considered opinion will be with you within 24 hours.

[Fishythefish]

*fullclaim -> name-claim

[Sathoris]

That's almost game breaking info, Parama.

[Parama]

No it's not. It's public knowledge. It's on wikipedia.
Though if it does break the game that'd be sweet.

[Johhog]

My post restriction also is at the Myers-Briggs chart.

[Parama]

Post restriction?

[Zang]

I'm also on the chart.

[Lurconis]

I too am on the chart.

[Sathoris]

You too are very eager to show you're on the chart.

[Parama]

I don't care if you're on the chart, I only care if you're not on the chart <_<
These are just worthless posts now.