TV Tropes: A Battle Worth Fighting [Endgame]

[Fate]

Vote Count

Parama (1): Quilford
GhostWriter (0):
Slaxx (1): GhostWriter
Quilford (0):
SpyreX (1): Silavor
Katsuki (0):
Elliebereth (1): AlmasterGM
Gandalf5166 (0):
Silavor (0):
AlmasterGM (0):
Packbat (6): Parama, Katsuki, gandalf, SpyreX, Slaxx, TheLonging (L-1!)
The Fonz (0):
TheLonging (2): The Fonz, Packbat

Not Voting: Elliebereth

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.
Deadline: September 22nd

[Katsuki]

DONT YOU DARE FUCKIN NINJA ME KATS YUO KNOW I WANT THIS TOP

=.="

[Packbat]

I'm sorry to hear it, TheLonging - good luck.

[SpyreX]

<3 TL. Hope it all works out as alright as it can.

To point out that assuming he's town solely on the basis of that is retarded, and thus shouldn't be done.

Well, yea but - what do YOU think of his claim specifically?

[Ellibereth]

Good luck Longing.

Is this ghost claim people are all talking about?
Yeah the only reason I'm not gunning all MILLERPOLICY is you people won't follow me on it.
If you will I'll be happy to oblige anyday.

[Ellibereth]

even with my claim fetish I'm not feeling this pack stuff

[SpyreX]

Unvote

I TOTALLY wouldn't hammer. I promise.

I absolutely would wait for a claim too.

[The Fonz]

<3 TL. Hope it all works out as alright as it can.

To point out that assuming he's town solely on the basis of that is retarded, and thus shouldn't be done.

Well, yea but - what do YOU think of his claim specifically?

That, as with pretty much any D1 miller claim, it's the wrong move for town and a good one for scum, but that site meta at the moment is such that most people who draw miller roles will claim like that, making it somewhat null.

[silavor]

unvote
Vote: Packbat

L-1 again

Not liking packbat or Quilford. Slaxx is town, and ghost is probably town even without the miller claim; he's just derping up the wrong tree right now.

[Quilford]

I think Quilford is derpingtown, if I recall he has a really passive scum meta.

I think you recall incorrectly good sir


anyway original scumread on Slaxx comes from

Ghost is town, fairly sure.

Packbat wagon is an alright P1 wagon. Not for sure what Packbat is hoping to accomplish with that question.

the last two sentences read to me as scum trying to justify what had previously been an RVS vote, especially the last sentence which seems to say 'hey look everyone Packbat's wasting our time'

Quilford, my role PM doesn't have Slaxx listed as one of my scumbuddi- hey wait a minute you're trying to trick me aren't you?

but this is just terrible; the 'joke' completely falls flat

and only scum joke about themselves being scum


Packbat's giving odd vibes just with his tone but due to Slaxx + Parama's interactions with the wagon I'm going to stay away from it for now

[Slaxx]

My point on Packbat wasn't lolwasting time, it was loltryingtolookproductive

I'm actually leanins scum on Parama too at this point, but the only scum do x tell is SHIT

dont ever say stuff like that

I think Parama has just avoided stuff a bit too much today
His lol L-2 norly L-1 thing is a big EH, cant tell if hed play that boldly as scum.

[Quilford]

I'm actually leanins scum on Parama too at this point, but the only scum do x tell is SHIT

dont ever say stuff like that

guess who's never heard town players joke about being scum (non-sarcastically)

*points to self*

I think Parama has just avoided stuff a bit too much today
His lol L-2 norly L-1 thing is a big EH, cant tell if hed play that boldly as scum.

yyyyyeah you're scum
VOTE: Slaxx

[Packbat]

Good luck Longing.

Is this ghost claim people are all talking about?
Yeah the only reason I'm not gunning all MILLERPOLICY is you people won't follow me on it.
If you will I'll be happy to oblige anyday.

My chief objection to millerpolicy is not that claimed millers are rarely scum, but that many Theme games contain non-cop roles that can test the claim - like the Lie Detector in Sherlock Holmes Mafia.

And I think Quilford might be on to something with his Slaxx/Parama observations - the quote from post 85 has a weaselly quality to it. Not convinced yet, though.

[Packbat]

And I think Quilford might be on to something with his Slaxx/Parama observations - the quote from post 85 has a weaselly quality to it. Not convinced yet, though.

Oh, wow, that's hypocritical. Let me make this concrete: if I see behavior that supports the scummy interpretation of #85 from Slaxx, I will be moving my vote.

[Parama]

I have no idea who's town or scum in this game honestly.
I'm 3rd party anyways though so I don't really care.

unvote

[Slaxx]

And I think Quilford might be on to something with his Slaxx/Parama observations - the quote from post 85 has a weaselly quality to it. Not convinced yet, though.

Oh, wow, that's hypocritical. Let me make this concrete: if I see behavior that supports the scummy interpretation of #85 from Slaxx, I will be moving my vote.

/points to paramas above post

I wasn't completely right but I knew I was onto something, I can read him well. Also, how does 85 feel weasily? Parama was obviously avoiding talking about the bandwagon, I even states that before I came under pressure. I sensed something was wrong and I was right, apparently.

[Slaxx]

Unless it was sarcasm. Then ig I was wrong.

[Fate]

AurorusVox replaces TheLonging. Thanks AV!

[gandalf5166]

Keeping my vote where it is lol.

[AurorusVox]

Haigaise

Gonna read over when I've finished proof-reading my dissertation.
Almost there.

[SpyreX]

I'm 5th party so I don't care even more than you Parama.

That, as with pretty much any D1 miller claim, it's the wrong move for town and a good one for scum, but that site meta at the moment is such that most people who draw miller roles will claim like that, making it somewhat null.

Well, sure, its not a slam dunk either way but I'm saying look at it a bit more in-depth. With flavor being what it is what scenario makes the most sense for that claim here?

[The Fonz]

The claimed flavour is a reasonable fit, but the nature of TVTropes is that there are several tropes that could fit if you wanted to claim miller as scum, one or more of which could easily be safeclaims. IE, the flavour tells me absolutely nothing about the veracity of the claim.

Why press this issue so hard without giving your own opinion?

[SpyreX]

Miller as a safeclaim?

And I did give my own opinion, actually.

[GhostWriter]

Policy lynching over a miller claim is about as anti-town as automatically attributing that person to "obvtown" status. I claimed because it would be anti-town of me to allow the cop to waste an investigation on me. Not for anyone to decide, by the action of claim, whether I was mafia or town. You read me as you normally would, because the claim wasn't for you.

[Fate]

Need something witty bump post here...