Scummies 2011 Nominations

[MagnaofIllusion]

Is that a selfnom I see?

I'm not the first person here to nominate Town / Scum group they were a member of for a GROUP scummy. Not a peep when that happened. But look ... the Scummie thread troll posse appears.

This is a far cry from nomming myself for Paragon of Mafia Hunters, for example.

[zoraster]

Yeah, maybe it's preferable to have someone else nominate, but realistically for a town nomination that leaves roughly 4 people who might potentially nominate the town: the scum members and the moderator. Maybe someone else comes in and sees it, but it's unlikely. A self-nomination in this case is fine.

The problem with self-nominations is that it sounds entitled, lacks humility, etc. When a self-nom for a team goes up those problems are defanged because it takes more humility to say, "I had a great team."

[SleepyKrew]

I'm not saying the self-nom was bad. I just thought it was a self-nom and wanted to make sure. Others can say what they want.

[kiwieagle]

Self-non =/= unwarranted

2nd Back to the Future Mafia

3rd

[lewarcher82]

Nominate chkflip

for

best third party performance

in this game. Serial killer win. He deserves to inherit the gif that is now floating under my name.

[GreyICE]

Yeah, maybe it's preferable to have someone else nominate, but realistically for a town nomination that leaves roughly 4 people who might potentially nominate the town: the scum members and the moderator. Maybe someone else comes in and sees it, but it's unlikely. A self-nomination in this case is fine.

The problem with self-nominations is that it sounds entitled, lacks humility, etc. When a self-nom for a team goes up those problems are defanged because it takes more humility to say, "I had a great team."

Which is all BS.

Self noms are fine in all circumstances. If you really don't deserve it, you just look like a right twat.

3rd and/or nth Back to the Future

[Mr. Flay]

Self noms are fine in all circumstances. If you really don't deserve it, you just look like a right twat.

Not really, because some people will second

anything

, and it vastly increases the reading load on the judges.

Also, if self-noms are okay for teams, then the team can nom and second itself in Every Single Game. That's stupid.

[SleepyKrew]

But if you nom yourself and don't deserve it, you'll be shunned and mocked.

[SleepyKrew]

Nomimate Lost Butterfly (Faraday+Mina) for Best Flavor for Scummer Fantasy Camp U-Pick thingthatjustended

The flavor was funny, it was clever, and unlike most flavor, you actually wanted to read all of it.
Honorable mention to Gammagooey.

[Fate]

Second

[chkflip]

Third LB

I think I deserve a "Worst Role Claim That Actually Somehow Fucking Worked" award instead, but I appreciate the nomination lew.

[Lost Butterfly]

Thanks for the nominations, from the both of us <3

[xRECKONERx]

4th LB

[Beck]

But if you nom yourself and don't deserve it, you'll be shunned and mocked.

How do you classify if someone deserves it? I felt I deserve a nom but I won't self nom mysekf

[Faraday]

2nd Reck for Prof Mafia

, for Mashups and Mafia. I feel it provides good mafia discussion, probably as good as anything on the wiki/MD and there's always something new being discussed on the show each week.

[SleepyKrew]

But if you nom yourself and don't deserve it, you'll be shunned and mocked.

How do you classify if someone deserves it? I felt I deserve a nom but I won't self nom mysekf

You deserve it if people don't shun and mock you for selfnomming.

[zoraster]

I'll

3rd

... edit: I'll actually take my criticism to the thread.

[Scummies]

I think best performance in a losing cause is a backhanded compliment, and think the category should be abolished.

Just ftr, I think it *has* been, I'm updating it anyway but pretty sure it's gone.

Edit: thread updated, any mistakes pm the scummies account if you see anything is wrong.

[Beck]

Well I'm used to being ridiculed so..

nominate myself for best replacement

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=18523

I replace DK in lylo with him most likely to be lynched, during my re-read I catch both scum and town wins.

[gandalf5166]

Third LB

I think I deserve a "Worst Role Claim That Actually Somehow Fucking Worked" award instead, but I appreciate the nomination lew.

Lol you claimed hider as SK? That's like, classic. SKs claiming hider is more frequent than actual hiders >.>

You definitely get props for pulling that off.

[Fate]

Well I'm used to being ridiculed so..

nominate myself for best replacement

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=18523

I replace DK in lylo with him most likely to be lynched, during my re-read I catch both scum and town wins.

look what you've taught the noobies vi

fuck this shit

[zoraster]

Maybe the rule should be that nominations don't show up until they've at least been seconded.

[GUNNAHAVETWOSOUPS]

Maybe the rule should be that nominations don't show up until they've at least been seconded.

this is a good idea

[Fate]

^This alt needs purging and fire

[Nobody Special]

Nominate GUNNAHAVETWOSOUPS for

Worst Hydra name ever