Double Vote Mafia -Mini 1239- Over

[Voidedmafia]

RD, it's ALNARA -_-. Are you trying to misspell it on purpose or something?

Robotnik (can I please leave out the c?): The logic behind RD's "real" VC is to hold us accountable for our primary vote, so we can't go "oh, he was just my secondary pick" after the lynch. RD could explain it better, but I think that's the gist of it.

Nin, I hope to god you're scum.

[nintendoaddict1]

Nin, I hope to god you're scum.

I don't know why people call me 'nin'. nintendo I can handle. NA1 too.

[Voidedmafia]

What? It's shorter and easier to write than the two alternatives.

[ThAdmiral]

Vote count

AurorusVox - 3 (Voidedmafia, Friend Marisil, Alnara)
Voidedmafia - 1 (killerjester)

nintendoaddict1 - 7 (AurorusVox, killerjester, Voidedmafia, Christine, Whiskers, Rainbowdash, nintendoaddict1)

Christine - 1 (Hiraki)
Robotnick2
killerjester
Friend Mairsil - 2 (Whiskers, Hiraki)
Hiraki
Alnara - 2 (Robotnick2, Rainbowdash)
Whiskers - 3 (AurorusVox, Nobody Special, Friend Marisil)
Rainbowdash - 3 (Alnara, Nobody Special, nintendoaddict1)
Nobody Special - 2 (Christine, Robotnick2)

Not voting - no one


nintendoaddict1 has been lynched

He was a

Mafia

[ThAdmiral]

You wake up and find Alnara dead

She was a

Townie

It is now Day 2. With 10 alive it is 6 to lynch

[Hiraki]

i am stunned

[Whiskers]

I'm not sad, either.

Means we don't have to lynch them today.

[killerjester]

Hiraki, who's nintendo's buddy?

[Rainbowdash]

So town group is: Me, AV, Whiskers, NS

Vote Robot
Vote Friend

Today we double lynch

[Whiskers]

Wait, why?

I mean, I understand why statistically we double lynch, but why did you pick those two? (Don't need a big long case, just a refresher, please.)

[Rainbowdash]

They work very well with nintendo, especially Friend.

I just don't feel much like making a big case right now, specially lazy feeling today and ive been doing enough work elsewhere. You can either just sheep me here or read them for youself and decide or something like that, becuase most likely I won't be able to make a case on Friend until tomorrow. Robot has like, one post of substance which he takes a leaning town but with outs opinion against nintendo.

So those two ponies are my picks for today.

[Whiskers]

Kk. I'll wait to sheep you until I've read them myself.

[Voidedmafia]

I'd be glad to sheep Friend, but not Robot. I like Robot and think he's town and whatnot.

I still find NS scummy (unless someone can convince me otherwise), and I suppose I'll have to accept Vox as being town for now.

Vote: NS

Vote: Friend

[AurorusVox]

I feel pretty.

More thoughts when I get home later tonight.

[Rainbowdash]

@AV , cuz both of you are playing the same game. for lack of a better way of saying it. in my experience when people get into the type of argument you and NIN did one tends to be scum. i voted whiskers because she was defending NIN. now if either of you flip scum, then i know exactly who im going after tomorrow. if neither of you flip scum then again i know who im gonna go after.

This is a big post for why Friend is scum, pay close attention to what is being said here. Friend is calling for the nintendo partner to whiskers, and ninentdo and AV not scum togethere it would seem. The big one to me though is she actually says Whiskers is scummy for defending nintendo. Now, how is that scummy from a null perspective, especially as AV-nintendo seems to be out as pairings and AV is scum?

I think this is Friend trying too hard to tie Whiskers to Nintendo before nintendo actually flipped.

no i think one of you are scum. cant get a read on either of you. so im using the double vote to my advantage. truthfully im gonna leave my vote where they are, and hope when the day is over we have more information. so i can actually do something of relevance.

This is exactly the type of stuff I was expecting scum to pull. The whole "oh I will just vote both of them" so they have no way to actually be accountable for their actions.

Friend has done nothing in this game productive, he just hung around on AV who im pretty sure was the scums mislynch of the day, while taking some jabs at Whiskers who I wouldn't be shocked if I also played spoiler for for scum getting a mislynch. The one quote here is big though, Friend uses Whiskers defending nintendo as a scumtell here.

There is no scumhunting, lots of calling nintendo town, but at the same time seeming to prep for the scum flip.

[Robotnick2]

And the case against me?

Your point about "only 1 substantial post" is somewhat invalid; as I explained, not only did I forget I had replaced in, but I am a slow reader. Might I note that my reads post (the post you deemed my only significant one) was

the same day

that Nintendo was hammered? How was I supposed to do anything ELSE substantial if we lynch the same day? I put my hands up, I was wrong about both reads, but that's not a scumtell, is it?

[Whiskers]

Not yet.

I'm cool with a Friend Maresil lynch, but I agree, let's remember that Robotnick2 is a replacement.

[Robotnick2]

Oh, and a Friend lynch works for me. As does a NS lynch.

Vote: FM
Vote: NS

[AurorusVox]

Pretty clear Rainbowdash is town.

Vote: FM
Vote: NS

I can sheep this.
Also, still looking at potential WhiskersScum. I seem to recall that I had strong reasons for suspecting they were partners yesterday and when I get some time I'll remember why that was.

[Nobody Special]

Define "tunneling," the way you were using it. Because I think you mean something slightly different, while "Confirmation Bias" (redirected from "Tunneling") is what you were really doing.

Remember to answer the question I asked.

"Tunneling" to me, is focusing on one player to the exclusion of all others, even going so far as ignoring obvious scumtells from people aside from the player you're tunneling on.

Firstly, it's Robotni

c

k, not Robotnik.
Secondly,
Thirdly, explain exactly how idiot==scum. I could find numerous examples of idiot!town winning a game.
Fourthly, please explain WHY you think Rainbow is an idiot/scum in the first place. It was a failed gambit, but I don't see how it was scummy.

Firstly, sorry. I was going from memory.
Secondly, below.
Thirdly, In my own little private world, I tend to label idiots as scum. It's a bad habit, and it stems from my real-life irritation with stupid people. I need to be more aware of that, and thank you for pointing it out.
Fourthly, I think it was a stupid, idiotic, pointless gambit. I tend to assume that my fellow players are involved enough in the game to actually read the game; therefore, I would never attempt something as idiotic as this. Since it was idiotic, it was scummy (see Thirdly, above).

Oh damn.

EBWOP: Secondly, explain how your "tunneling" (not the right term for it, as Whiskers pointed out) is protown.

I don't believe I ever said it was. Just because I'm town doesn't mean I always act that way.

For the moment,

unvote, unvote

I need to catch up. May not be until tomorrow, though.

[Rainbowdash]

I still have to lean away from a NS lynch today.

I read Nintendo as town, his logic makes sense and he is also actively scumhunting, pushing the game forward. I do agree however that the logic surrounding the whole "ad hom" controversy was a little shady.

I just dont like this because its wrong.

Nintendo was not actively scumhunting or pushing the game forward. You even leave yourself a way to get on the wagon if needed.

[Whiskers]

The reason Nin and I might have been buddies is that I defended him for a while (didn't feel strongly enough about the case on him) and pretty much 180'd later in the Day (when RainbowDash came around and Nin refused to play along).

[AurorusVox]

Okay, going back over my own ISO (lol ego) I see that Whiskers was defending Nin, and Nin wasn't letting us double lynch me and Whiskers, as well as Whiskers' original scumminess. I need someone to sum up why Whiskers is town because I'm not sure I buy that really...

[Rainbowdash]

I just don't feel it.

Mostly due to how little she seemed to know about the setup. I entirely believe that scum would be more likely to all know it since it only takes one to have realized and then mentioned this to the rest of the team. I dont think its feigning ingorance since there were a few posts before I came in that shows the same thing. Then again I would see scum thinking there are PRs if they missed it being open. Heck I think this only starts coming close to 'balanced' if we had three of us as masons.

Could I be wrong here and am a little biased? Yeah maybe. Just think scum would have been a little more likely to notice and get the point across since this is daytalk.

[Rainbowdash]

unvote Friend
Vote Hiraki