Mini 1243: Magician Mafia (Game Over)

[Vi]

This is a crap lynch. It's based almost entirely on my claim

*shakes head*
*rolls eyes*

[Amrun]

@Amrun: you seemed to push against that theory very hard yesterday, when IIRC noone was really pushing it or voting based off it. Why?

As I explained earlier, no town player should just accept people's idiotic, hole-filled theories. Sometimes, people pushing bad theories are scum trying to get away with poor logic to push mislynches. Sometimes, it's just wrong town. Until you get to the bottom of it, you can't know. And actually several people were voting off of it, as far as I know. At least ace and Vi, bare minimum. I determined they were both town but that doesn't make the theory any less unlikely.

Still v/la, just wanted to pop in while I had a few minutes.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Vote Count 3.5

Fishythefish (L-1) - Vi, Amrun, Junpei, Luxury, Crab Canon
saulres (L-5) - 4nxi3ty

Not Voting (4) - SnakePlissken, ace5993, Fishythefish, saulres

Deadline: Wednesday October 26 @ 8:00 PM Eastern
Countdown: (expired on 2011-10-26 20:00:00)

[saulres]

*impatiently points to post 1155*

That's one of mine, and doesn't answer the question

[Vi]

*impatiently points to post 1155*

That's one of mine, and doesn't answer the question

*offers you pair of eyeglasses*

[saulres]

*puts on the glasses and looks again at his own post, completely failing to see Vi's answer in the post that he made and Vi didn't.*

I'll try again. Which post in your QT with GNR did he claim to be Penn? I'm going to hazard a guess that there aren't over 1000 posts in that QT...

[saulres]

At this point I'm not going to be vigging Amrun until I can review the thread (tomorrow as I've said) so if anyone hammers before Junpei and I agree on a vig, I'm going to consider the hammerer scum.

[Junpei]

1155 is Vi's post. Furthermore it basically says two things:

1) That it may be against mod rules to out post numbers or relative numbers to the QT (or perhaps Vi has already confirmed it is)

2) That point is a red herring, essentially Vi says that it is a dead lead.

[saulres]

...

I am apparently a tad dyslexic tonight. Sorry about that. I was looking at 1115.

And while Vi may claim it's a dead lead, I don't feel it is. I asked for a reason, and just because Vi doesn't understand that reason doesn't mean it's not valid. If DDD won't let her tell me, that's one thing, but I can't understand why it would have been permissible for Ace to post direct quotes of her talking normally but not for her to indicate a number and nothing more.

[Junpei]

but I can't understand why it would have been permissible for Ace to post direct quotes of her talking normally but not for her to indicate a number and nothing more.

Well yeah... this fact seems to implicate GNR/Ace/Vi, and I'm keeping my eye out for that scum team (I highly doubt it is that, but of all the possible combination, that is the most deadly). Obviously the point I'm saying is that if those quotes were faked, then it would make sense for Vi not to be able to directly reference her QT.

So, Vi, answer the mans' question.

[Vi]

GNR

he claimed to be Penn Jillette

GNR

*shakes head*
*points to Debonair Danny DiPietro*

...

At this point I'm not going to be vigging Amrun

.........

[Junpei]

OH. GNR never claimed Penn in the QT you mean?

[Vi]

*nods*
*points to Debonair Danny DiPietro

again

*

[Junpei]

He claimed what he flipped, he claimed Sylvia Brown?

[Vi]

He claimed what he flipped, he claimed Sylvia Brown?

...

...

*does not lose patience*

...

*wants to lose patience*
*does not lose patience*

[Junpei]

That's -- not very conclusive.

What I'd like to know, however you can indicate it, is when in your QT with GNR he claimed to be Penn Jillette, before or after you claimed Teller, how long before/after (post numbers), etc.

vi, this is the post you are responding to, correct? I fail to see how DDD relates to this. My final guess before I wait till someone else comes and deciphers it/you are more clear to me (not a fault of your own, probably) is that the mod won't let you reference the QT anymore because GNR died.

[Vi]

My final guess before I wait till someone else comes and deciphers it/you are more clear to me (not a fault of your own, probably) is that the mod won't let you reference the QT anymore because GNR died.

*makes very tired expression*
*takes deep breath slowly*

*points to Debonair Danny DiPietro*

GNR he claimed to be Penn Jillette

Guy_Named_Riggs –

Sylvia Browne sawed in half D2

*makes shocked expression*




*steps off of short bus*

*points to Fishythefish*
*moves hand slowly and deliberately across throat*

*points to Amrun*
*makes hand into shape of gun*
*brings thumb down onto first finger while tilting hand up*

*goes to sleep*

[Junpei]

Oh, sorry.

GNR did not claim Penn, and was in fact not Penn but rather Sylvia Browne. He never claimed Penn to you because his role PM said Sylvia Browne. Also that he lied about his name in thread.

Also you want Fishy lynched and Amrun vigged, both ideas I can endorse.

[Luxury]

This is getting ridiculous, our theory may have been way out there but some of these are flat out terrible.

Someone hurry up and hammer, vigs when Fishy flips scum you're vigging Amrun.

-Shift

[saulres]

*nods*
*points to Debonair Danny DiPietro

again

*

Ah. I think I finally understand.

When DDD set up the QT, he indicated in his intro posts that that was a QT for Penn and Teller.

[SnakePlissken]

Ok I'm back. First off to clear up on my roleclaim, it doesn't state in my role what type of cop I am just that I can get the random result of one of a persons roles, which is why I claimed role cop over flavour cop, it's a bit of both I suppose.

Second, the Your Amazing role which a few of us seem to have is denoted with a (p) for passive. So that all it is. I think it's just Triple Ds humour sneaking through there??

Finally people want Fishy hammered, I'm fine with that. His responses have been less than helpful on the most part and I don't see anyone else currently worthy of lynching. Although I am starting to worry that Vi is white knighting somewhat, but still here goes then.

VOTE: FishyTheFish

Oh can we drop all this GNR name speculation, surely it's clear that he had a fake claim which I'm assuming all the scum team will have? I don't think Ive ever been in a game where the scum team weren't given fake claims?

[Fishythefish]

It's wrong. I wish you'd at least waited until I have time to get a decent post in. Go town!

When I flip town, tiger ANXIETY.

[Vi]

Vi is white knighting

*stares at you in disbelief*
*rolls hand in circles toward you*

Now I haven't looked at anyone else yet,

will be doing that for the next lot of hours but for now I want to put in avote here:

Unvote]

VOTE: Guy_Named_Riggs This now puts you at L-1 so a roleclaim would be good.

Finally people want Fishy hammered, I'm fine with that. His responses have been less than helpful on the most part and

I don't see anyone else currently worthy of lynching

.

[SnakePlissken]

Vi you missed this bit in your quote "I am starting to worry that"

And as far as the second quote goes. First one I'd barely joined the game and this morning I'd just got back from a V/LA and was checking through. I don't see what the problem is?

[Vi]

Vi you missed this bit in your quote "I am starting to worry that"

*rolls eyes*

Vi is white knighting

*puzzled look that also happens to be a glare at you*

And as far as the second quote goes. First one I'd barely joined the game and this morning I'd just got back from a V/LA and was checking through. I don't see what the problem is?

*prints out your posts in isolation*
*cuts out the excuses*
*cuts out the dumb questions*
*holds replica of post 1197*