Yeah, this will kinda suck for you but basically the tone and wording just feels unnatural and feigned.
Admittedly not as SLAM-DUNK as I'd imagined last night/early this morning, but still enough for me to be satisfied with my vote.
In post 1094, Sleepless Assassin wrote:Khan - ... it looks like he's back after Kuribo after pushing him, letting up, and being called out for letting up.
Actually, no. Looks like I'm wrong.
He was defending himself against Kuribo, not attacking him. Posts some reads with reasons. Meh, I don't agree with a lot of what he's saying, but he's definitely pushing hard for what he wants. I think he's scummier than I thought he was before, but still not a top scum read.
Seriously, what?
I appreciate that sometimes opinions change but you just do not type out "well I think KK is blablabla because etc. WAIT ACTUALLY HE'S NOT DISREGARD MY LAST PARAGRAPH" all in one post.
Maybe that's what went inside your head, but if it is you just press the backspace key and rewrite "Well KK is X" into "KK is not X". Not difficult. I really don't understand the town-thinking behind "hmmm well I just changed my mind and KK is actually not X but I'll keep the bits where I say that he is X because lolbackspaceis4losers!" It just comes across as scum trying to maximise the percieved content of their post.
In post 1094, Sleepless Assassin wrote:Kuribo - I'm not going to waste the time sifting through everything for this. My opinion on him should have been clear throughout the game. He was really scummy, slowly got a little better, them BAM! Dropped that town tell looking back and realizing scum were daytalking. He's probtown.
Usage of 'BAM' (paticularly capitalised) feels forced. Feels like scum over-justifying an inconsistent read.
In post 1094, Sleepless Assassin wrote:Lowell - This one is hard for me. He's very non existant. I think we are more likely to find something out about him after we get some flips because people seem to have clear thoughts on him somehow. Let's see. He was confident kublai and myself were scum early on. Reck, Spring, Socio, and Kuribo town. I'd be interested to know why. Most of that is different from my early reads. His vote post on me looks pretty genuine, actually. You know what? When I look closer, Lowell doesn't seem the way I've been picturing him. I thought he was quiet, lurky, kind of inactive, but I had it wrong. He's just concise. Plenty of reads. Plenty of reasons. Just not a lot of words. Lowell is town.
Again with the "well this but wait no actually it's not that".
In post 1094, Sleepless Assassin wrote:Malth/Sera- Malth didn't do anything except joke vote, say he couldn't keep up, and ask to be replaced. Therefore, I couldn't get a read on him. Sera has two posts saying he has homework and is working on the game. I'd like to see at least partial stuff. Slight scum read just because he claimed to be "working on it" but has provided absolutely nothing. Not one read. Not one vote. Nothing.
You claim that you
could not
get a read on math (ie. it was
impossible
to obtain a read on him) but you have a slight scum-read on Sera (bearing in mind this was before his #1098)?
I used the multi-ISO to ISO them together... absolutely boggled.
In post 1094, Sleepless Assassin wrote:Rhinox - My first thought is that he seems quieter than usual. That can easily be explained by the large game though. I lean town, but am definitely interested to see what I'll find when I read up. Kublai vote looks legit. Calls the first 12 pages noise. Seems like he'd be able to pull
something
out of it. At least something more than just Kublai is scum. He's going on about the noise thing too much and I don't like the "I don't fit in" stuff about a dinosaur era and whatever. It looks like excuses to me. You have to adapt. Sees me at L-1 and says the case sucks but I'm not townish. So he's fencesitting. Avoiding the wagon, but leaving options open. Hmm. Wonder why I didn't see this scum earlier.
oh man this whole thing just stinks of scumbuddy-distancedistancedistance
You soft-attack him for being quiet but then straight away defend him. Then you lean town on him and make a vague attack that isn't
necessarily
indicative of alignment ("Seems like he'd be able to pull
something
out of it"). More vague attacks ("excuses... You have to adapt") which again could just be personal criticisms rather than anything indicative of alignment, and then the last bit is just "welp my scumbuddy made a weird stance on me how should I react to that" and you end up concluding scum from leaning town.
In post 1094, Sleepless Assassin wrote:Spring - She's escaping attention very well. Did the sideline thing by "siding with kuribo". Voted me cuz it was the cool thing to do (Or maybe because I called her scum). A lot of discrediting on my case on her. And my Fate case (connection?). Votes Kuribo for being vulgar. She keeps popping in with maybe a read or two just to seem like she's not lurking. I don't like it.
lolconnectionz let me just put it in brackets with a question mark so I seem like town weighing up somthing in my head
In post 1094, Sleepless Assassin wrote:- Seemed like Chunk and Pine earlier as far as reads/reasons and what not, but seems to have fallen off the radar. Hmm. Actually, first few posts don't look that way at ith the case, but it looks genuine. Switches to Khan because he has no support for Elvis. Meh, I think he's town, but not as town as I thought before.
Again with the "Blablabla... actually NO!"
"
Meh
, I think he's town" feels forced.
Finally I'm confused as to why you've distinguished between green-town and turquoise-town. Reading your reads I would expect all of them to be on the same level: both Grimm and DGB open with "Still town" yet they're different colours (and at extreme ends of each colour).
(sidenote: when the fuck did we get this smiley?
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile")
)
Benmage: First, for the sake of irony. I'm going to illustrate how completely idiotic and hypocritical scumhunter is.
