Hi, so one thing you should know about me is that im ESL (English second language). Still, I think I can manage pretty well. Just expect a couple of grammar mistakes and what not.
Also people at the forums I play are way much more reserved with their votes (I always leave my vote for like the last 20% of the day in those forums), even if the days are shorter (like 6 real life days). So that’s gonna be a little hard to get used to, but here we go!
Unlike some people, I really can’t use meta at all since I know none of you. So bleh. The style around this board is overall waaay different from other stuff I’ve played in. Anyway, I want to point out that I started writing this at about page 10 and kept adding lines. So I might go from “Guy looks scummy” at the beginning of paragraph to “Ok, he did this which does look town.” which I maybe read on page 20 at the end of paragraph
Equinox
Guy looks pretty townie to me right now. Good reasoning sometimes, brings fresh content into the table. There’s not really much here I can point out. Solid reasoning mostly. I agree with most of his content about Screaming Hawk, for example…. Except for the part when he suddenly believe he is town when SH explained about his vote thing early in the day.
Amrun
Im actually leaning a little bit into scummy here. IMO he tries to look helpful, but then he’s also asking a lot about previous experience. I’m not a fan of this. It feels to me like if he sometimes tries to poke for information and content, trying to make someone look bad a little bit each time.
Quilford
Gotta be honest, I have a lot of doubts here at the moment. But the fact that not many people have gone against Quil and the fact that he has played the game safely, mostly echoing other players, makes me feel unsafe. Wouldn’t be surprised if he was scum. When town players play it safe, they get called out a lot. When the scum does it, its hard for the town to point this out. They just look like active, not very aggressive town. Was also metaing me (Kondi) a lot. But so were other people… I still find quil scummy.
SleepyKrew
Throwing out a lot of questions at almost every move done in the game. Not really controlling the game or anything. Seems to be quite helpful, but then again scum would like to look exactly like he does. Asking a lot of questions and following them through. Dunno, kinda 50/50 here.
Nobody Special
Super bad logic. A lot of his posts are slightly scummy. But then again, he’s been put under pressure for a long time. Not sure about this, but I can see the case against him. The way he bandwaggoned hawk on page 13 is just so bad. But is all this just bad town or scum? Would probably vote for him but im more comfortable about others. I can see both sides of the coin though; A bad townie player with a couple of votes from the scum in there already, or a bad scum player with just votes for being bad.
bvoigt
Not much of a read here, to be honest. Not a lot of content, looks kind of townish since he hasn’t really gone to bandwagons and when he gives content its not as recycled as what others do.
DonJosh
Very puzzling behavior. Not sure what to think of here. He hasn’t been nowhere near as active as other members, but he hasn’t lached unto bandwagons and shit like that. Then again, he could just be playing dumb a bit.
Fruit Basket
Seems townish to me from what I read so far. Confronts stuff when it’s thrown at him. Nothing much stands out I dunno.
trekker
This guy looks as scum to me from what I read. However he’s getting replaced or something so not sure how to proceed here. His play has been really bad, his reasoning has been worse. Umm… Guy just comes in and says “These are the town… oh, and these are the scum!”. Cool buddy. Although I think that’s kind of a null tell. Gets into a lot of 1 on 1 conversation with people and just kind of ignores everything else until he comes back. Dunno, scummy. Would probably vote him if he wasn’t getting replaced. Might still vote him anyway!
fatlikepig
The guy gives me a town vibe so far. Although I don’t necessarily agree with some of the stuff that he’s been throwing around. He’s been helpful and pushing certain targets when he feels someone is scummy. I think he’s cool in my book for now.
ScreamingHawk
I think SH is I actually have no fkn clue. His first posts of the game are bothering, kinda. Like when he decides to go for a vote on Pig rather than Quil, that reasoning sucked. He also got a little offended when his name started appearing in votes at the beginning of the day, which I found suspicious. Still, when people began to question you about your unvote/vote thing early in the day, you kinda didn’t went into raging mode, you just went “haha yeah guys honest mistake” or something, which I find townish. Of course he had no big defense against this. It was a dumb honest mistake, town or scum, and people kinda latched into it. Seems to be you might be telling the truth at times, but why so scummy if you are town?
Cross_Pollination Twistedspoon
Cross pollination was playing a little bit too safe from what I could gather. Didn’t voiced many suspicions and threw out some votes here and there that were kind of safe. Not sure how I feel about this. A lot of people defended this guy, dunno why.
Now for twistedspoon he made a fkn big post which is gonna be hard to read… here we go… ok! That was a long read, gonna have to read more out of you to get any kind of idea though.
Ok im done and yeah I find a lot of people suspicious. Im just paranoid sometimes I guess.
Would not vote:
SleepyKrew
Fatlikepig
Bvoigt
Maybe Don Josh
Equinox
Would vote as of now:
Nobody Special
Amrun
Quilford
Treeker
For now im actually going to vote for Quilford. No one has called him out for some reason, yet his play is much weaker than a lot of other players. Not a lot of original content. Playing it safe. Etc.
##vote: Quilford
