Open 347: White Flag Mafia (Game Over)

[Fruit Basket]

pidgey feels p sincere, @ the top of the page

[Twistedspoon]

Uhm, the only name I recognize on the player list is TS but I doubt he remembers me since it has been months since I played on this site.

Anyways, I will try and have some posts up later.

I remember you; how could I forget that game.
Nice to have you back anyways

very tempted to unvote [J] and vote quilford soon. The only thing stopping me at this moment of time is because I still think it's the townie mindset to be the first to provide a reads list in the game.

This really isn't the quilford I enjoy playing with

[Morthas]

Day 1 Votecount

: Twelfth

Nobody Special

: Fruit Basket, ScreamingHawk, SleepyKrew, bvoigt, fatlikepig, Equinox, L-1

Twistedspoon

:Amrun, L-6

DonJosh

: Quilford,L-6

trekker

: DonJosh, L-6

Quilford

: pidgey L-6

Equinox

: Nobody Special L-6

pidgey

[J] L-6

[J]

: Twistedspoon, L-6

With 13 alive, 7 to lynch.

Current Deadline:

6th of November

I'm getting a feeling I made a mistake somewhere...

[Twistedspoon]

how is the DonJosh replacement going?

Not too great since I'm procrastinating because of illness and schoolwork.

[ScreamingHawk]

I'd really like to know why those

NOT

voting for NS find whoever they are voting for more scummy. In particular those voting the recently replaced players.

[Quilford]

Twisted I'm not into the game at the moment and exams literally start tomorrow.

Why do you want to vote me apart from "This really isn't the quilford I enjoy playing with", which is the worst reasoning a player could ever use anyway?

[Twistedspoon]

I'm not voting you for that, don't misrep. I'm voting you for being hardly pro-town at all this game whereas the old quilford knew how to hunt scum.
You've done zilch

I see no reason to continue voting [J] at least for now

VOTE: Quilford

I feel good about this vote

[Twistedspoon]

I'd really like to know why those

NOT

voting for NS find whoever they are voting for more scummy. In particular those voting the recently replaced players.

NS is on L-1. do you seriously want a lynch at this stage before DJ has even been replaced?

I've said enough times already why I am not voting NS and no-one has convinced me otherwise along the reasoning I am using for not voting him.

[Quilford]

Oh my god, continue making broad statements with no evidence

"I'm voting you for being hardly pro-town at all this game whereas the old quilford knew how to hunt scum."
Hardly pro-town is my town meta. Check the recently completed Pick Your Poison Open in which I acted just like this.

[Twistedspoon]

no, I'm familiar with your town meta. This isn't it

and I'm not going to check one game which you cherry picked. Everyone has one bad game as town.

[Quilford]

It's quite relevant that all these bad games have been happening so recently.

Twisted my play in Campaign Mafia is also quite reminiscent of here.

The only place I can think of that we've played other than that is Nomination, where I replaced in to a town slot.

Tell me otherwise? And look at the game.

[Quilford]

What is my town meta then?

[Twistedspoon]

neruzian mafia?
royal mafia?

how can you not remember these. You shouldn't be using meta as a defence anyways if you're town. Pointing out your own meta is a moot defence

anyways my point is I feel you're coasting and I'm not prepared to vote anyone else at the moment except for donjosh who is utterly unreadbale from his few posts and fat who i hope to review again as I said earlier and will probably do this during N1

ninja: you at least try as town. I don't even get the impression that you're trying to be logical from half of your posts (posts 98, 141, 366 and 641 come to mind)

[SleepyKrew]

So J looks like fun. Lynch NS already Jesus.

[Twistedspoon]

I'm not lynching NS yet.

1) we haven't heard from DJ's rep
2) his uncaring play is similar to his town play
3) I still find some of his moves too bold for D1 scum

[SleepyKrew]

NS hasn't made any moves... and his play more resembles his scummeta. Hence why I'm voting him.

[J]

Leaning more silly town then scummy with SK as I continue to read. Just not seeing the mal-intent from his slot and more just his reasoning and justification on things are not up to par with what I would expect. Otherwise, he is cool but not really liking any of his rationale.

Unvote

It seems my vote is on someone but didn't realize. Still reading but that should be apparent as of this post. =P

@TS: Is it sad to say I don't remember anything besides nailing scum that game and arguing in game with Faraday? Liiiiiike I barely remember the players. Can I ask you what made you decide to move off of me somewhat suddenly after you had just said you were still keen on the vote on me? What about my posts made you change your mindset?

[bvoigt]

TS, I self-voted as a reaction test, but no one bit.

did you feel it worked? What reactions were you hoping for?

Nope, it really didn't work at all. I'd rather not explain exactly what I was looking for, so I'll be able to use it in future games.

In other news, look at the VC. Nobody Special is our lynch today. Nothing else is happening. Can we get it done?

[J]

Lol trekker, you are retarded.

Also VOTE: kondi

Ahaha clever.

UNVOTE: , VOTE: Amrun. This won't change for a while.

This post seems really out of place nor do I get why he voted Amrun at all besides what seems to be to try and latch onto FB's suspicion of Amrun as of this post. Over the course of this game, people had been voting Kondi and I didn't get why. Probably because I am still new to this site or something but nothing scummy rang from his posts besides these type of posts (because this isn't the first) however he at least tried to explain his FB vote which did nothing at all. Here he just votes and leaves it there. Seems scummy to me.

He can replace SK for now on my scum-list.

[J]

TS, I self-voted as a reaction test, but no one bit.

did you feel it worked? What reactions were you hoping for?

Nope, it really didn't work at all. I'd rather not explain exactly what I was looking for, so I'll be able to use it in future games.

In other news, look at the VC. Nobody Special is our lynch today. Nothing else is happening. Can we get it done?

What in the world makes you say that NS is our deffo lynch toDay? There is stuff happening with replacements coming in. Of course the lynch could happen but to say that it is already determined is meeeeh. I don't like it because things could change. ;D

[Fruit Basket]

That's silly.

fos: amrun

[Fruit Basket]

J can I get a link to your previously played game on here. do you have offsite experience?

[J]

I have offsite exp for over a year now on another site.

I joined a newbie game here before because it said you needed a game's exp to join others and that was interesting.

What seems silly FB?

[J]

Now, lynch SleepyKrew. Do what I say.

Sigh..
UNVOTE: NS
VOTE: SleepyKrew

As there's really noone going for NS at this point

Confusion to a high degree. No-one going for NS? From what I was reading, that's the opposite (especially looking at the game now). He voted SK purely because Trekker (my slot) said for him to do as such. There was no reasoning from Trekker to vote SK besides question dodging (seems hypocritic of SK to not answer questions considering his first few suspicions were based on this but he called Trekker scummy for calling him out on it.).

Speaking of, I don't like the complete sheep attitude to everyone once one person (Equi) saying that SH was town. No one decided to give reasoning but just sheep him. However, this town has a lot of baaa-ers in here.

[J]

On page 17 so I thought this would be a good page to drop a few reads.

FLP I really like as town. He seems to be trying to question things and also seems to be looking for scum which I like. The intent behind his posts is fine with me for toDay so I have no problem with him.

SK I do feel is town moreso now. The reason being is the way he reacted to NS and him trying to clear himself off meta and SK seemed to legitamately go back and try to re-read the slot to get the right side of the story. Seems like town trying to take the initiative to try and figure things out rather then just skate on by. His constant meta analysis is not really good for me but I don't see anything bad behind it besides I think the reasoning of meta is faulty.

Dislike bvoigt. I haven't seen a single post I really care for that doesn't give me a read that isn't null/scummy. He seems to just be skating along doing nothing and trying to just blend in. Thing is, it's been working so far and no one has really called him out on it so far this game due to the fact of massive lurkers. Thing about his lurking I don't like is that he comes in with BS reasoning on things to just hop on wagons that he can seem to hide on to not get called out on anything.

Still don't get the SH town look besides how one post could come across as sincere. Equi, could you go into more detail as to why you like SH this game if you still feel the same?

Heading onto page 18 now.