The Aftermath - Victors Announced

[Hinduragi]

trolol mason fakeclaims...

WHOOOOO BUS FASTER and trying to Pine as scum STILL?

And hindu STILL spouting bullshit

Posting in this game is painful

Yeah, and your lack of anything that even feels genuinely like YOU is pretty disturbing. Especially not calling out any meta and whatnot. Still thinking Spyrex is scum but going for Rhinox because.....? Being retarded in general.

[Kublai Khan]

Meta is relevant in the sense that these things coming from other people would be more forgivable. I've been around the site long enough to have read some of your posts, in MD for instance, and my impression is that you're a fairly rational person. The ideas that you're expressing in those posts doesn't agree with that impression.

I'm not an alt and I don't think we've played together before.

Okay. So first it was meta based on select previous games and now it's meta based on posts I've made in MD. Goalposts keep on movin'...

But I think I might see where you're coming from though. It reminds me why I created this poll a while back. Look at the responses. Most people I consider to be great logical people listed themselves as incredibly overrated at mafia. That's because Mafia isn't really a game of logic, not entirely. To me mafia is most similar to the game of poker. I do my best to be unreadable no matter what role PM I get. So I'm sorry I'm not living up to your expectations but making logical sense is not a town-tell for me.

I've explained the "psychological ploy" thing here (at the bottom). I can give you a more in depth explanation if you want.

My point was this: earlier you accuse Pine of being scum for engaging in "gotcha" scum hunting. Now, you write off a second instance of "gotcha" scum hunting, with scum pine would be dumb enough to say something like that.

No. You're (still) reading it wrong. I'm talking about the people pointing out that Pine said "Our Misled Leader" instead of "Our (positive attribute) Leader". That's not the sort of comment that scum-Pine would make.

[SpyreX]

lol, he didn't change things on the fly. No one said that. He just clarified something that I found confusing. Twist my words a little more, why don't you?

"Awesome Mason claim"? She was lying, you prat, with more holes in her story than swiss cheese, and I simply found those holes and called her on them.

So fuck you, and the horse you rode in on.

Well my horse is pretty handsome after all and I am lonely, what with being a prat and all.

DGB was lying like a professional planker. DUH there was swiss cheese in that and going "AHA LOOK WHAT I FOUND" and wanting a pat on the head is pretty tech.

I'd love to see what was "confusing" between "this will be announced" and "this is not announced"

In before "IT DIDNT SAY EITHER I DIDNT THINK TO DO IT UNTIL THEY CALLED ME OUT ON IT /QQ"

[SpyreX]

And good lord KK we're baby steps away from aggressive mind games

[Pine]

It really didn't say. I'm going to ignore you until you stop being a jackass.

[kuribo]

How can you seriously be surprised I put elli up. Even a little. Elli's pulling the grandiose beetlejuice this game and did it more than once to me day 1. Now, I didn't expect OHH SNAP THUNDERSTRUCK or whatever happened there and if I could cajole the mod to put the deathknell on hiatus until Elli can show up and do more nothing well I would.

Why not Lowell? Why not Shattered Viewpoint? Either of them have been more useless combined than Elli.

[Lowell]

@DGB- cheekiness aside (I can't help it if I'm adorable), I don't actually think I'm being useless this game. I prefer the term concise. More than one post per RL day seems, to me, to be a sane posting-rate. We can't all be kuribo.

[springlullaby]

^^
So cheeky. Lulz.

Vote rhinox

[kuribo]

keeping in mind about pine that's the second time he's been all "LAWL EYE CAUGHT You NOW SCUM!!!!!!" and been openly mocked for it


he's an idiot and bad at scumhunting but probably not scum

[elvis_knits]

I will be VLA for the next 36 hours, but will be able to check in tomorrow night.

[DrippingGoofball]

I agree with kuribo.

Rhinox is still town. His wagon is scumtastic.

[Lowell]

So you agree with Lowell, you're saying.

[Rhinox]

Rhinox and I are masons.

If only...

"This Rhinox shit is stupid."

DGB claimed Masons with him

I disproved that claim.

DGB more or less admitted she'd been caught.

DGB and Rhinox are scumbuddies. BOOM.

This is the most retarded post in the whole thread.

Well.

You forced my hand.

I'm going to have to do this the hard way.

DAYVIG: Lowell

If only...

Have you ever tried to lynch a cheeky lurker scum these days? No one sees the wisdom anymore.

i hate that shit so much.

"lawl we can't policy lynch lurkers"
(watches lurkers make it to LYLO and lose the game for town)

that's why i want to know why the hell Spyspy wants to kill Elli instead of someone useless to town. if he thinks Elli is scum, he needs to explain why.

Eh, elli's iso I guess he wasn't as useless as others but why do you think he's a bad kill?

Because it's a sound strategy, and discouraging it leads to people thinking that gambits that include lying to Town for no particularly good reason are acceptable.

I know you're not this naive. Quit playing "townier than thou".

Good lord the fakest mason claim only to be surpassed by the fakest vigclaim. DGB what in the helllll is that about.

Watching Pine go OHH SNAP SCUM FOUND over it is pretty awesome and don't make the mistake of forgetting about that - I'd still love anyone to prove this whole song and dace wrong buttt nooo.

Unvote, vote Rhinox

</3

[kuribo]

rhinox, I don't necessarily think elli is a bad kill per se, just that if you claim a hand in someone's death, you had better have a good reason. Especially if there are other targets that may benefit the town

elli wasn't the only one playing beetlejuice, so my point was, why him?

[Rhinox]

Well lemme ask another way - does one need a good reason to choose one good target over another? Is spyrex scum if he doesn't have a good reason?

Because spyrex's ability is almost certainly a town-only ability so I'm just wondering where you're going with this.

[kuribo]

you're forgetting that were talking about spyrex, there's no way he marked elli for death unless he's sure it furthers whichever wincon he has.
and aside, since we've been telling people to take elli's place, it'd be helpful to know why that wouldn't be a good idea

and his ability seems pro town, but only if he isn't omitting or fabricating a part of it.

[kuribo]

I don't even necessarily think spyspy is scum, I just want answers beyond "Well he was lurking"

come on, spyrex, for christsake, give me SOMETHING I CAN WORK WITH.

[Kublai Khan]

UNVOTE: Zdenek
VOTE: xRECKONERx

[xRECKONERx]

UNVOTE: Zdenek
VOTE: xRECKONERx

[xRECKONERx]

Also, SpyreX targeting SDC for his first knockout is very suspect but I can't believe Max would give scum a role that allows him to basically get two kills per cycle, no way no how.

[Max]

Oh my word I believe this thread has been raped in under 24 hours. No daykill has occurred and I'm still looking for a grimmjow replacement.

Once that's sorted Ellibereth is next.

[Max]

Vote Count 3

Rhinox (8): Elvis_knits, Fate, kuribo, Pine, Shattered Viewpoint, SpyreX, springlullaby, xRECKONERx

Fate (1): Hinduragi
Kublai Khan (1): Zdenek
Lowell (1): DrippingGoofball
Pine (1): chunkykev
springlullaby (1): Hoppster
xRECKONERx (1): Kublai Khan
Zdenek (1): Rhinox

Not Voting: grimmjow, Seraphim, Lowell, Ellibereth

19 Alive, 10 To Lynch

[Rhinox]

UNVOTE: Zdenek
VOTE: xRECKONERx

why reck of all people?

[Ellibereth]

HI GUYS
I'LL BE ABLE TO POST AGAIN ON FRIDAY
AKA TOMORROW

BLIZZARDS FROM HELL

[Max]

Katsuki

replaces

grimmjow