New York 152 Niiightless Game Over!

[Ythan]

Mb53 has been prodded.

[Ythan]

Vote Count

5 redFF (UberNinja, Hiraki, Matias, Mogri, BBmolla) L-4
4 BBmolla (Psyche, BK201, Nobody Special, inte)
2 Mogri (Major Minor, mb53)
1 mb53 (redFF)
1 BK201 (noraaa)
1 UberNinja (crypto)
1 Blonde Doctor (Pine)
0 Nobody Special
0 inte
0 Matias
0 crypto
0 Pine
0 noraaa
0 Major Minor
0 Hiraki
0 Psyche

1 Not Voting (Blonde Doctor)

9 to lynch
Deadline May 10th

[Nobody Special]

NS contribute more than sparring jabs plz

Tell you what. I'll play just precisely how you tell me to, and we'll celebrate together after.

[Blonde Doctor]

NS contribute more than sparring jabs plz

He doesn't do more

and self-hammers as scum

not much to know more about

Several people are commenting on how Nobody Special plays, but I have yet to see any speculation on what this means for his alignment. People who are unfamiliar with his play (me) like to know what comments like these mean.

Go ahead and lynch me, I probably shouldn't be in endgame this time anyway(lol)

Lynch red tomorrow when I flip town.

I do not understand this at all. This sounds like you are trying to scare us out of lynching you.

unvote

(I do not remember if I did this already)

I actually think this is scummy and will vote for him as soon as I get my other rereads done.

I think there was something I noted about kcdspot as well, but I will have to go back and check.

[Blonde Doctor]

I think there was something I noted about kcdspot as well, but I will have to go back and check.

This was a mistake. I was confusing players in my games, I apologize.

[crypto]

All right, I'll probably do a heavy reread and post a fairly fucking decisive thing today.

[mb53]

Oh, prod already

I've been following along, I just haven't really had anything I've wanted to say.

BB wagon is... ok. I might jump on it later if we really aren't going to manage to lynch inte or mogri, but I'm not really feeling it right now.

[Mogri]

Why you gotta hate

[mb53]

Cuz u scum.

[Matias]

I do not understand this at all. This sounds like you are trying to scare us out of lynching you.

unvote
(I do not remember if I did this already)

I actually think this is scummy and will vote for him as soon as I get my other rereads done.

I think there was something I noted about kcdspot as well, but I will have to go back and check.

oh

Unvote, Vote: Blonde Doctor

1. Why the hell is desperation posting, ala BB, indicative of scum and not of EITHER alignment?

2. How the hell do you know that you're going to vote for him after your rereads are done? Why even bother doing the rereads?

Forget redFF, this is yuck.

[Matias]

if redFF really played Red Dead Redemption as a scum role, I no longer have a case on him.

I'm re-reading BBmolla tonight.

[UberNinja]

Wow, Inte is incredibly annoying.

?

Aw. I take it back. He's kind of cute.

UNVOTE: inte

What the fuck is this

[UberNinja]

sup.
VOTE: noraaa
seems like she has the urge to post for the sake of posting.

-__-

at the point this post was made, noraaa had made more sense than anyone else in the game.

[UberNinja]

Whoa, this game is way more hostile than the ones I've played on here so far. I hate playing catch-up but I didn't realize the game had started already, so I'm doing a brief runthrough.

redFF & noraa's back and forth on pages one and two and three seem rather town-on-town. I think red's joking intent seems genuine, and I think noraaa trying to latch onto it is an earnest attempt to try and decipher something, albeit misplaced.

crypto's postings make me think he's taking the game as a joke instead of actually trying to play, like when he claims he's a cop with an innocent on Vifam.

My head! It hurts! I can't keep track of who is replying to who in this redFF/Vifam/noraaa/crypto mess, but I don't feel like any of it is particularly scummy or worthy of a vote.

mb53's "Are you fucking kidding me?" post kind of fits my sentiments regarding Pine's posts so far in the game.

@Matias: What about redFF's posting style makes him scummy? He just seems to be dicking around, having a laugh, but not really taking it seriously yet. I get the same vibe from crypto's posts, and neither seem incredibly scummy.

@noraaa: Who is Elliot?

I agree with BBmolla: Pine is probably scum. The way he just stirred shit up then left under the slightest pressure doesn't sit well with me at all.

Pine only has three posts in the game so far: one that asks for a policy vote on crypto, one that mistakenly (and exaggeratedly) calls crypto's post an "ad hom attack" when it wasn't, and one that simply asks if Blonde Doctor is an alt. He's just skirting by in the shadows, not saying much of anything, hoping nobody will notice.

I noticed!

Vote: Pine

I am in complete agreement with this entire post.

Voting for the right reasons, noticing the things that are actually scummy and skipping over the "null" tells, picking up on all the subtle things I did too, and not blowing stupid things out of proportion, or being an idiot.

MM is very likely town.

towny list so far: noraaa, MM
scummy list so far: redFF, Pine

[UberNinja]

Pine is scum because he isn't yelling and pushing a bullshit case.

I don't follow. meta reasons?

Vote: Major Minor

I don't like the timing of the vote (right after BB said pine was scum) and I don't like the reasons for the vote ("He's just skirting by in the shadows, not saying much of anything, hoping nobody will notice." When the he has proposed a policy lynch/the game hasn't even been up for 24 hours).

lol major minor just made the best post of the game and now this? this is a terrible stretch

if Pine is scum look for mb53 to be scum too

[UberNinja]

(in other news I am now a fan of the Atomiks)

[UberNinja]

BK, if scum, deserves a vig shot.

Can't really read him well.

Does he not deserve a vig shot if town?

[UberNinja]

@crypto people who change votes way too much bother me, you're probably going be stuck as a scumread most of the game because of it

That is incredibly scummy of you.

saying it doesn't make it so

What's so scummy about changing your vote often? Crypto doesn't seem panicked.

? makes me think they aren't being careful with their vote or don't care whos being voted as long as they are voting

Actually it's the opposite.

If they are being careful with their vote, they are more likely to be scum.
If they didn't care who was being voted, why would they change their vote?

Does anybody have meta on inte being dumb?

[UberNinja]

@crypto people who change votes way too much bother me

Why? I disagree.

false

No. Please use complete sentences and suport your arguments with reasoning. What is false? That he disagrees? See, you can't argue whether he disagrees. It's called an

opinion.

Try harder. Even if you think we're weird.

unvote

Vote: inte

This is far too much reasoning for a vote. If inte is town, NS is probably scum.

[Ythan]

Major Minor has been prodded.

[UberNinja]

Matias, what other specifics made redFF scummy?

Just what I said. He's taken early game seriously and he's trying to lynch mb for a mistake that a person of any alignment can make

red is smarter than this; this isn't stupidity on his part, he's obviously just trying to fit in

I like this post. Matias feels town

[UberNinja]

I"m probably failing for always being on my ipod in class.

I'm going to minimize you guys and try to work on my paper for a while.

Me? I'm not on anyone's side but the truth.


(cue law and order theme song)

That first post seemed unprompted, like she felt the pressure to keep her presence up. Whether or not she is mafia might depend on how she usually plays, but have never played with her so idk how that is.

this post makes noraaa look a little scummier and bk201 look a little better

i'm not decided on either of them

[UberNinja]

I would like to get an inte wagon going

This doesn't sound like something scum would say... I'm torn on mb53. I think MM is town but he seems to think he is scum
But then more than one person voted MM for his post so I could be wrong but I really don't think I am

[Matias]

11 posts in a row, damn.

[redFF]

And Another Thing...