Bastard Mod mafia - GAME OVER!

[Thok]

Perhaps we should have CD claim a kill type (assuming he knows what his kill type is) for future reference?

vote Coron

[ChannelDelibird]

Perhaps we should have CD claim a kill type (assuming he knows what his kill type is) for future reference?

vote Coron

I'm afraid my modus operandi was not specified in my role PM, and seeing as I haven't yet made a kill in the game I can't say which mine is. I might ask the mod for clarification (i.e. a PM will follow this post, Vis).

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

The extra kill is interesting. Do you think it's possible that DBG was a serial killer without a nightkill?

Primate, if you havn't picked up on it yet, our bastard mod made DGB kind of like a death miller but the mod reveals DGB to be serial killer instead of scum. So DGB didn't have any killing power and he actually told the truth in those far fetched claims.

Now that I look at the 3 night kills for both nights, 1 is physical beating, 1 is gunshot, and 1 is explosion, so CD's explanations make some sense now.

Unvote CD, vote: coron

[ubertimmy]

Vote: Coron

[al_kohaulec]

I'm thinking DGB might have been a miller type role, making her appear SK on death. We still have just as many deaths last night as we did the first night, so her kill hasn't gone anywhere, which means that that specific killer is still out there. I think DGB might have actually been telling the truth for most of her role.

But right now I want to hear more from coron, and look at CD later.

Vote: coron

And finally, Fritz was a mafia traitor, and pro-town. This means he knew the mafia, and may have leaked some information to us. I tried looking over his posts last night, but didn't find anything, it might be worth it to look over his previous posts to see if his hints hint towards any players in this game. Most of his posts had no content though, simply votes.

[Coron]

um, right now I'm just dropping in from vacation, you think you can hold off on lynching me for a few days? I'll be back by sunday. And of course remember, the mod said maybe and this is bastard mod so probably not actually real information.

[al_kohaulec]

unvote

I don't want to give him that many votes that quickly. I want to hear from him before he's quicklynched.

I didn't realize how many he had.

[al_kohaulec]

I just looked over the mod's first post, and happened to see the first post by a player in this game was by coron, who randomly voted for MoS. only he didn't say random, or anything else, just "Vote: MoS" And now MoS has turned up as a mafia mason, and Coron has turned up as the cop commisioner's killer, I'm not going to use this as solid information for anything, because at best it's a very very loose connection, but I just found the coincidence, if it is one, very interesting.

But anyways, back to what I was going to say...


Actually, I'm still thinking about the CD situation right now.

I'm thinking of reasons for him, and against him. Against him, I was wondering why he would have targetted DGB to kill N1, and then nobody N2. Later I remembered we had day first, and DGB claimed all that stuff she claimed, and so it sounded more reasonable that CD would target her at night, however it still doesn't leave any room for him to target her as an SK or a Vig or whatever. I then started thinking that maybe he did in fact kill N1, and also N2, and he's just saying he didn't so that we think the kill is somebody else. Of course I realized I was just stupid because if this was true, he couldn't have gotten all of that information om DGB. This proves that none of the night kills are his, so he seems to be telling the truth so far.

It sounds reasonable that he would have done what he did if he is a vig, so I'm more inclined to believe him there.
However we have no kills from DGB, and she was supposedly an SK as claimed by the lynch post. I am doubtful that she was the SK, and was more closely to what she claimed. What I'm not sure about though, is if what the mod told her about her role was true, meaning CD must be mafia, or if the mod lied to her merely to implicate CD.

[ChannelDelibird]

However we have no kills from DGB, and she was supposedly an SK as claimed by the lynch post. I am doubtful that she was the SK, and was more closely to what she claimed. What I'm not sure about though, is if what the mod told her about her role was true, meaning CD must be mafia, or if the mod lied to her merely to implicate CD.

I agree with you in that this is the most confusing part. The lack of one less kill last night suggests DGB was telling the truth yet she claimed incorrectly that a vig could kill her, which I was unable to do. I thought the mod had said he wasn't going to lie on role information though...

How many is it to lynch?

[al_kohaulec]

I think about 9 to lynch. I think we have around 16 alive.

[TBuG]

Vote: Coron

I'm okay with putting Coron three from lynch.

[Fortify]

So obviously you guys think that true roles are not always revealed. Otherwise DGB's "true role" would be written instead of SK.

With this in mind realize that all the details of the roles might not be mentioned. Isn't it possible that the SK could have had killing restrictions? Maybe something had to happen in the day for the SK to earn his/her kill. We don't know.

It is also possible that DGB just decided not to kill her first night to try to play the role she was claiming.

I still think she took a risk at the beginning, we didn't buy it, and she payed for it.

Also, I agree about the coron. While I find it hard to trust anything the MOD says in this game I think we should put some pressure on our best lead. I will

FOS Coron

. That would be a vote but I don't want to encourage a quick lynch.

[Glork]

Ten bucks says that DGB's role was real, except that she was (much to her own surprise) a Death Miller. I'm going to

Vote: Channel Delibird

because I feel he is likely to be a scumbag. I don’t believe that DGB was a nonkilling SK. I believe her role was as claimed, and I feel that CDB tried to kill her maliciously.

[ChannelDelibird]

Ten bucks says that DGB's role was real, except that she was (much to her own surprise) a Death Miller. I'm going to

Vote: Channel Delibird

because I feel he is likely to be a scumbag. I don’t believe that DGB was a nonkilling SK. I believe her role was as claimed, and I feel that CDB tried to kill her maliciously.

If I said there will be death millers involved that may or may not be true. Any millers/death millers will know they are that.

[Primate]

Thing is, if Channeldlibird

is

scum, and genuinely did target DGB that night, where's the nightkill from that night? Vig-Miller is exactly the type of simplistic, but honestly bastardly role I would expect. I don't see how ChannelDelibird could possibly have a role that encourages him to kill every night, otherwise they'd be a missing kill after the first night. Add that to the fact that DGB was the perfect target for a vig, and as no other vig has come forward to say they also targetted DGB, I don't see why he should be disbelieved.

[Glork]

Hmm, then maybe DGB just didn't claim to be a Death Miller as well?

Unvote Vote: Coron

. It's time we began testing the integrity of flavor and info in Death Posts. I'd rather lynch a likely scumbag than a likely good guy in PBuG. The CDB case will likely be revisited later. Too bad DGB is not alive to talk with us.

[ChannelDelibird]

Hmm, then maybe DGB just didn't claim to be a Death Miller as well?

That would be a very stupid thing for her to leave out, IMO.

Let us lynch Coron!

[Glork]

According to DGB, only the Mafia can fail to kill her.

CDB claims to have targeted her.

Obviously, she didn't die.

Unvote, Vote: CDB

[Glork]

Fuck.

[ChannelDelibird]

According to DGB, only the Mafia can fail to kill her.

CDB claims to have targeted her.

Obviously, she didn't die.

Unvote, Vote: CDB

*sigh* This is why I still believe she was scum. This is old news, Glork.

[Primate]

According to DGB, only the Mafia can fail to kill her.

CDB claims to have targeted her.

Obviously, she didn't die.

Unvote, Vote: CDB

Then why is there a mafia nightkill from that night?

DrippingGoofball was lying. I don't believe for a second that she was a 'Death miller/serial killer" as CDB has proved that would mean that she would know about it, and her behaviour said that she didn't want to get lynched.

[Coron]

Hmm, then maybe DGB just didn't claim to be a Death Miller as well?

Unvote Vote: Coron

. It's time we began testing the integrity of flavor and info in Death Posts. I'd rather lynch a likely scumbag than a likely good guy in PBuG. The CDB case will likely be revisited later. Too bad DGB is not alive to talk with us.

fos:Glork

give me a chance to defend myself when I get back

[TBuG]

I, too don't think DBG was truthful. The "scumtell" was probably an excuse to say someone is scum.


P.S. Note Scum hasn't posted recently.

[Primate]

P.S. Note Scum hasn't posted recently.

Betcha it's Thok.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Nah, Glork, I tcepxe Death Millers ot eb told they era htaeD Millers and I tcepxe them to mailc ti. There is on nosaer at this tniop ot make wild snoitpmussa tuoba DGB's alignment.

ehT tcaf that Coron sah ton claimed yet sesirprus em.