Bastard Mod mafia - GAME OVER!

[Romanus]

I don't need a whole lot more discussion, pretty sure about Masterchief, or Toaster, or whomever is in that role. And even if they don't appear scummy, which they do, I still want some info about that voice. Everything else pales in comparison to that.

Good enough topic?

[Toaster Strudel]

I am waiting for my role PM.

[VisMaior]

Sorry about that.

[Thok]

I am waiting for my role PM.

So, any news on this?

[M4yhem]

Romanus- No good. I've already gave my opinion on that topic. Pick something where there's still something to talk about.

Strudel didn't get his role? I'm seeing a theme develop here.

[Romanus]

M4yhem -- you come up with a damn topic. You don't like mine, and I want TS lynched.

[M4yhem]

Romanus- Did you get out of the wrong side of bed yesterday or something?
I want Toaster lynch as well, which is why I'm voting for him. Anyway, hows this for a topic- who else is scummy?
If Strudel comes up scum, which I think he will, Pbug can probably be cleared. That voice proclaimed his innocence after all. ChannelDb is also cleared since last night was the first time we had two gunshot killings.
So that leaves the rest of us. Any ideas?

[Romanus]

Yes, I do have some ideas, but they are almost all of them based around Strudel's affiliation. So that lynch means more to me than anything else. What people actually say doesn't mean a whole lot right now, especially with the mod screwing with people the way he is.

[Toaster Strudel]

I finally got my role PM.

It does fit in the fact that MasterChief was an afterthought in the game.

And it does fit with DGB's "I have already lost" schtick.

I have already won. There's nothing more to it. I can do what I want. I have no affiliation, and no night action. That's my role. I've already won. The "bastard mod" is really a nice guy.

I haven't read the thread to check out what you found scummy about my predecessor. Does it matter?

If you need to lynch me to test your theories, be my guests! 'Cuz I've already won.

Toodles!

[Der Hammer]

Vote:Toaster Strudel

Perhaps thats the bastard bit, you think you have won but really you havenot

[Toaster Strudel]

Vote:Toaster Strudel

Perhaps thats the bastard bit, you think you have won but really you havenot

Maybe. But I have to go with what I've got.

[Toaster Strudel]

Vote:Toaster Strudel

Perhaps thats the bastard bit, you think you have won but really you havenot

Why are you voting for me after I made just one post? Quick with the trigger finger? Anxious to lynch anyone?

[Fortify]

Vote:Toaster Strudel

Perhaps thats the bastard bit, you think you have won but really you havenot

Why are you voting for me after I made just one post? Quick with the trigger finger? Anxious to lynch anyone?

Or maybe it's because MC was under pressure and your early posts should be about defending yourself? I am aware you just received your role, but if you don't start being relevant soon I will have to follow Der Hammer's lead.

[ubertimmy]

why do you care if hes voting you, toaster strudel, you won...

right?

[Toaster Strudel]

@ Ubertimmy - I don't care. That's true.

@Fortify - I gave my role information, for fun, not as a defense. I don't need to defend myself. You can follow DH's lead if you want, I don't care.

[ChannelDelibird]

That role does make an awful lot of sense considering Masterchief was so eager to be part of the game earlier. I'm prepared to believe TS but it does leave me wondering where to put my vote today.

unvote

with the possibility of revoting if necessary for a lynch today.

[VisMaior]

votecount coming up.

[dahen]

It's interesting that Toaster thinks he has won.
DGB claimed that she had lost from the beginning, but turned out to be SK. Was she a death miller? That would have the effect that we would like to hang Toaster. Or was she unknowningly an SK? Well, how could you when you are not sending in night choices. So if she really knowningly was SK all the time, was this loser thing a claim she was forced to make or did she make it up?

I hadn't replaced in this game yet when the whole DGB affair was up, but I read the thread anyway and I really didn't expect her to turn up SK. Something wasn't right.

And now we have this opposite guy. Toaster - I would really like to know what you think of DGB.

[VisMaior]

Toaster Strudel 5 (M4yhem,CES,romanus,Der Hammer,ubertimmy)

13 alive, 7 tlo lynch!

[M4yhem]

Awwww- I want that role. No fair.

I'm confused about DGB too. I really thought she was telling the truth; I don't understand what she would gain from playing like that as the SK.

If toaster's role is real, it is most bastardly- to the rest of us. I'm feeling like I want to kill him out of pure jealousy.

It sort of fits with the fact that Masterchief wanted to get himself lynched on day one. I mean, if you have nothing to play for, what's the point?

Things the role doesn't fit with: That mysterious voice. Toaster, since you've won already, you can tell us: is there anything in your pm that would make you look guilty to someone?

If DGB was telling the truth, does that mean death millers don't know what they are?

No unvote for now cause I am confused. And jealous.

[Toaster Strudel]

M4yhem, there is nothing in my role PM that would make me look guilty to someone. It's one sentence. I have a feeling the Mod rushed it, and didn't give it much thought. I am guessing that he didn't want to disrupt the game's original balance in favor of the town, or the scum, by aligning me (MasterChief) with either group.

As for looking back on DGB, http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... &start=550 especially, why hasn't CD been lynched? That might be informative. But I haven't read the whole thread yet.

[Romanus]

I just thought of this:

Why would Masterchief need to be replaced if he has already won? Does he really need to post? This is Bastard Mod, the mod could just tell us he's not going to replace him.

Why is TS trying to help? He has already won. Why worry about CD being lynched or not?

It is just not adding up.

[ubertimmy]

VisMaior said earlier in the thread that any millers and death millers would know who they are. I believe he guranteed that that wasn't a lie.

Thus, DGB was an SK. And she decided to try and give herself a safe claim, I guess. I think her role was: Unnkable SK who, when targeted to be killed, doesn't die, but whoever targets her learns she is SK. Her claim would, thus, account for that being told as a "scum tell," I guess. In my opinion, not a very good plan, but hey, maybe she saw something different happening.

Pretty bastardly role , anyway.

If TS is telling the truth:

He can only hurt us by us wasting a lynch on him, and he doesn't get hurt by being lynched anyway. He can't help us in any way.

If TS is lieing: He could hurt us by being scum, or we could lynch him and it'd be awesome.

I think it's worth lynching TS. Most likely, I believe he is a Survivor. This wouldn't upset the balance of the game, and his claim would hopefully make each group think it's not worth killing/lynching him. Also, it's a challenge to survive after entering into the game late (as MC did), and having evidence which Romanus has provided (role wasn't designed for us to win with) against you.

I think TS is a good lynch for today. If he's lieing, great, if hes telling the truth, no biggy for anyone (not even him).


About CD:

I recently reread the game, not making close analysis but just to get some more perspective. CD has been very very scummy in this game. He is also an acceptable lynch, maybe better than TS. In fact, I feel like it's almost sure he'll turn up scum of some sort.

I think one of these is the lynch for today. TS is safer, but less likely. I'm just concerned because we don't know the number of scum, and lynches might not be worth wasting.

However, it's also very probable both of these guys are scum, and whichever one we lynch today, I feel like I'm going to want to lynch the other tomorrow anyway.

I think TS is the best lynch for today, as we lose less if he's not lieing then if CD is. We can lynch CD tomorrow, or if TS is scum, I have a few other ideas as well.

[Der Hammer]

VisMaior said earlier in the thread that any millers and death millers would know who they are. I believe he guranteed that that wasn't a lie.

Thus, DGB was an SK. And she decided to try and give herself a safe claim, I guess. I think her role was: Unnkable SK who, when targeted to be killed, doesn't die, but whoever targets her learns she is SK. Her claim would, thus, account for that being told as a "scum tell," I guess. In my opinion, not a very good plan, but hey, maybe she saw something different happening.

Pretty bastardly role , anyway.

If TS is telling the truth:

He can only hurt us by us wasting a lynch on him, and he doesn't get hurt by being lynched anyway. He can't help us in any way.

If TS is lieing: He could hurt us by being scum, or we could lynch him and it'd be awesome.

I think it's worth lynching TS. Most likely, I believe he is a Survivor. This wouldn't upset the balance of the game, and his claim would hopefully make each group think it's not worth killing/lynching him. Also, it's a challenge to survive after entering into the game late (as MC did), and having evidence which Romanus has provided (role wasn't designed for us to win with) against you.

I think TS is a good lynch for today. If he's lieing, great, if hes telling the truth, no biggy for anyone (not even him).


About CD:

I recently reread the game, not making close analysis but just to get some more perspective. CD has been very very scummy in this game. He is also an acceptable lynch, maybe better than TS. In fact, I feel like it's almost sure he'll turn up scum of some sort.

I think one of these is the lynch for today. TS is safer, but less likely. I'm just concerned because we don't know the number of scum, and lynches might not be worth wasting.

However, it's also very probable both of these guys are scum, and whichever one we lynch today, I feel like I'm going to want to lynch the other tomorrow anyway.

I think TS is the best lynch for today, as we lose less if he's not lieing then if CD is. We can lynch CD tomorrow, or if TS is scum, I have a few other ideas as well.

good thinking. enough to keep my vote on strudel until I think of something better

[Glork]

FoS: Everyone wagoning PopTart