Scummies 2012 Nominations (Deadline For Noms)

[Tammy]

Been waiting for this to end so I could do this:

Nominate Zar's Rocky Horror Mafia for Best Flavor

I gave myself over to absolute pleasure reading this as it went along.

nth

[shos]

Nominate Zar's Rocky Horror Mafia for Best Flavor

3rd

5th lol

[Parama]

Nominate Shamrock for best flavor for The Room Mafia.

If you don't know the movie, you probably won't get it, but if you do, it's beautiful.

To the judges, in the event that this game doesn't win...
You are TEARING ME APART, Scummies Judges!

/lame

[chesskid3]

Two scum kill attempts (Bulletproof) = meh... + no nth from me.

nth Klick

though, because really, he's been amazing.

yeah man I did it as lyncher with no bulletproof son

[callforjudgement]

Two scum kill attempts (Bulletproof) = meh... + no nth from me.

If you're bulletproof, shouldn't you be

trying

to draw the scum kill?

[Faraday]

Hm. Arguably not so much as an SK as it can lead to them outing you.

[Faraday]

IDK, it's not really a negative either to me as you're playing the role the way it was designed.

[chesskid3]

designed as pretty op dontcha think

[chesskid3]

Since los of people targetted him with hey d00d u scum night actions
and game mechanics seemed to let him skate

[Tierce]

Hm. Arguably not so much as an SK as it can lead to them outing you.

Not if you're willing to claim bulletproof. In a vanillaless game with lots of abilities, that made sense with Vi's flavor (...you're trying to kill a mummy?). SKs don't necessarily have to play to avoid the NK in the cases soaking up scum kills works in their favor.

[Faraday]

My point was more general, in fairness. Claiming full BP townie is pretty much a bad idea as scum in most games, it was fine given the weird set-up + moderator though which I assume is knowing your mod meta. I don't remember the specific circumstances of that game other than lolnofakeclaim and FLAVOUR SAYING MUMMY IS SK.

[zoraster]

Nominate hitogoroshi for Most Enjoyable Player

.

Nominate MattP for Rising Star

See the giganto game or Always On.

[quadz08]

2nd MattP. The man is excellent.

[Nexus]

Provide links to hito things pls.

[izakthegoomba]

I'm pretty sure several MM games have been nominated, are you guys sure the OP is correct?

[zoraster]

they've been nominated between the last update and now to my knowledge.

[izakthegoomba]

Ok, turns out we're dealing with them separately anyway. Never mind.

[Empire]

3rd MattP for Rising Star

Been waiting for this game to finish (though he's really had several great games). As part of the SlumberPartyBois hydra, he basically dominated the game, had excellent reads, and led the town to an easy victory.

[UberNinja]

nth mattp

[StefanB]

nth +1

, that linked game was a great first game with Matt.

[AurorusVox]

Nth MattP

[callforjudgement]

3rd MattP for Rising Star

Been waiting for this game to finish (though he's really had several great games). As part of the SlumberPartyBois hydra, he basically dominated the game, had excellent reads, and led the town to an easy victory.

Haha! I was going to nominate him for Paragon, but I see he's already been nominated, so

nth

that. I also remember how he managed to not only catch me as scum in mykonian's 50-player game, but manage to (correctly) deduce that several players were town from my play. In the game Empire linked, MattP's hydra split the game into a "scummy half" of 8 players and "towny half" of 9 players near the end of day 1; there were 5 scum alive at that point, and all 5 of them were in the scummy half. I've heard of him doing similar great things in other games, too.

[Jarvis]

Nominate Mehdi2277 for Rising Star

Because how the hell has this not happened yet. There's plenty more, but off the top of my head, this game and this one too show his ability to lead a town efficiently to catch scum in quick time. I'm sure you all know him anyway, I don't have to go and find more examples.

[quadz08]

2nd mehdi so hard

[zoraster]

3rd