Bastard Mod mafia - GAME OVER!

[dahen]

Scum isn't a person, but controlled by mod. If I'm not totally confused, I believe any scum person can PM our Mod to get the output from the Scum character. You should know that.

[TBuG]

Unvote, Vote: M4yhem

I see what dahen sees, and this response upsets me:

PBug- Ces had that awful PR, I doubt that with that he's scum.

PR =/= Town. I already think CES is scum.

[Romanus]

Are you saying there is some connection between me and scum? You do know that we are different people, right? Notice that he posted while whoever it is I replaced was away.

With what Pbug just mentioned and this quote, I don't like M4yhem either. This is just too much scumminess for me.

UNVOTE

VOTE: M4yhem

[M4yhem]

Dahen- Where exactly does it say that? I don't remember anyone telling us that was the case. You are totally confused. I see no evidence that any of the known scum were controlling the scum account. And I know for sure that I’m not; though since I’m not scum, that doesn’t disprove your theory.

Also, you really think I would draw attention to myself, the way Scum is drawing attention to me? Wouldn't I do something like proclaim my own innocence instead?
Pretty sure Scum exists to lead us astray- you know, like he's doing now?

PBug- If you think CES is scum, then vote for him. Personally I think that someone with a crippling post restriction is more likely to be town, because it seems to me the setup is intended to grief the town as much as possible.

Romanus- What, I'm scummy because I'm telling the truth? How does that work?

[dahen]

Let me clarify this a bit. Everything "Scum" says, does indeed, scum say. Its a message scum sends to the town. Feel free to chat with him.

Isn't this clear enough?

[Der Hammer]

:good posting

Thats very strange and actually quite funny.

Vote:M4yhem

[dahen]

I'll upgrade my fos.

vote M4yhem

[M4yhem]

Dahen- Okay, you have a point there. I had forgotten that he said that. But what makes you think he’s telling the truth when he’s mislead us several times already?

Here are some of the things scum has said:

M4yhem is obviously trying to distance himself from Scum.

Vote M4yhem

Apples are green.

I am saying apples are green because I assume M4yham will have some bizarre response to it, and his response will amuse me.

I am saying "I am saying apples are green because I assume M4yham will have some bizarre response to it, and his response will amuse me," because I assume M4yham will have some bizarre response to it, and his response will amuse me.

I am saying "I am saying "I am saying apples are green because I assume M4yham will have some bizarre response to it, and his response will amuse me," because I assume M4yham will have some bizarre response to it, and his response will amuse me," because I assume M4yham will have some bizarre response to it, and his response will amuse me.

...

Now, if I was the one doing it, would I really draw attention to myself in such a negative way?
What’s the probability, given that it would be stupid for me to do it?
He even got my name wrong. You think I’d get my own name wrong?

Most of what scum has been saying is gibberish anyway. It’s a distraction, and another way for the mod to manipulate the town into killing innocents.

[dahen]

He even got my name wrong. You think I’d get my own name wrong?

Hmm... interesting. The first quotation there had your name correctly spelled. Didn't you notice that? If this isn't something made as a diversion, it seems that there are more than one scum communicating through "Scum". This is in line with my interpretation.

[Romanus]

I still like M4yhem, not as much as before though. We don't even know that it is scum telling us this, it could be a way for a townie to tell us who scum is, but without directly telling us.

I hate this Bastard Mod thing

[Thok]

Since I'll need this for my reread, I'll do the following favor for the mod. Please change the opening post include this set of players with replacements, so that I know who to check when I do "Read all posts by".

M4yhem replacing marc.six
dahen replacing viper
Cogito Ergo Sum
PBuG
Romanus replacing Green Liquid
Fortify
Thok
Der Hammer replacing Ziliu
Ubertimmy
Dur Galad replacing Bethelmark

I'd like prods or replacements for ubertimmy and Dur Galad.

I think the M4yhem wagon is filled with a lot of WIFOM, IMHO. It also jumped to four votes really quickly.

[TBuG]

PBug- If you think CES is scum, then vote for him. Personally I think that someone with a crippling post restriction is more likely to be town, because it seems to me the setup is intended to grief the town as much as possible.

But I think you're scummier, silly.

Now, if I was the one doing it, would I really draw attention to myself in such a negative way?
What’s the probability, given that it would be stupid for me to do it?
He even got my name wrong. You think I’d get my own name wrong?

Considering that you could bring up how stupid it would be for you to do it, I think it is you. I've misled a town as scum before by beiing incredibly scummy and saying my scum-mates were town, and I got lynched, and the logic was used that they probably aren't scum because I wouldn't be stupid enough to out my scummates like that.

[M4yhem]

Dahen- Are you saying then that I voted for myself? What would be the point of that? Isn't it also possible that the scum are trying to frame me, if your theory is true? I thought the mod was trying to get me killed, but I suppose it could be one of the players too.

Romanus- If it is town trying to tell us something, why wait until now to start making sense? (If you can call the last thing scum said sense anyway.)

Thok is right. This is all based on WIFOM. It seems like whatever I say is being twisted to fit the theory. And I can't prove you wrong, because how do you prove a negative? Do you want me to not tell you the password to the account which I don't know? Or maybe I can prove it by not posting anything as Scum?

PBug- That's very interesting, but I'm not you. And the logic they used would have worked in most case. Why believe the less likely scenario, if there's a simpler explanation? How many times now has the mod lead us astray?

[TBuG]

PBug- That's very interesting, but I'm not you. And the logic they used would have worked in most case. Why believe the less likely scenario, if there's a simpler explanation? How many times now has the mod lead us astray?

Because you, like Romanus, are using questions to lead me into a certain conclusion.

[Romanus]

yeah, it's called rhetoric, pretty much what this game is based on.

[TBuG]

yeah, it's called rhetoric, pretty much what this game is based on.

It's also a scum tell in my book.

[Romanus]

You need a new book then

[M4yhem]

PBug- Yes, I'm trying to convice you that I'm right, for two reasons:
1. I like this game, and I don't want to die.
2. I know for a fact that you're wrong, and so I want to set you straight.

Is trying to convince other people of their case something only scum do?

Oh darn, I'm doing it again.

[TBuG]

Is trying to convince other people of their case something only scum do?

It's not what you're doing, it's how you're doing it. You are trying to force me to think a certain way with your questions. I've done it before and I've seen other scum do it before. Prove the fact that you are town with cold, hard evidence. Don't compare yourself to Scum again, as that will make me think you're scum (and Scum) even more. If you don't want to die, give me reasoning for WHY you shouldn't die.

[TBuG]

MOD

, could you please prod the following players:

Cogito Ergo Sum
Fortify
Der Hammer
Ubertimmy
Dur Galad

[dahen]

Dahen- Are you saying then that I voted for myself?

Do you actually believe that the vote from Scum vote did(/would) count?

[VisMaior]

Did we loose anything? Not like I care, just curious.

[M4yhem]

We lost ubertimmy's posts and some of my defense, your honorable bastardlyness.

Sumarry: I'm innocent, leave me alive, you crazy fools. Vote Fortify.

Unvote, vote: Fortify

[VisMaior]

OK people dont make me mad. I mean, madder than I already am.

[TBuG]

Still think M4yhem is scum.