Trouble in Minas Tirith! Game over!

[Phoebus]

Two (or even more) vigis see, quite a likelihood here. We must've had atleast one kill by a vig last night and we had ages as well...

I wonder if the orc was on his own? Or with a mixed team of some sort?

Intriguing...

[Dragon Slayer]

I want to hear a little more from Dragon Slayer. Whatever games I've played with him/seen him play, he's never been so quiet.

Yeah, this game honestly confuses me a bit. I like LotR and saw the movies, but I never read a word of any of the books. I know the characters and all, it's moslty the evil groups and their names, etc that confuse me. I'm sorry I haven't been putting in a lot to this game.

[mathcam]

Okay, here's the thing. I may have some information concerning a particular player and whether or not he was responsible for a kill last night. Ideally, I would like to trap him by getting him to claim that his role didn't kill anyone last night.

A technique that has worked in other games has been to go around in a randomly determined order, each of us either confessing to killing someone last night or denying that we did. I won't reveal until we've all gone around. We do expose our vigs, but that's not that horrible. With 9 alive, even a mass role claim could be fairly helpful.

So unless anyone objects, I think we should start with a random player, and after each player reveals, they pick the next person to reveal.

Cam

[Scalebane]

I agree with cam, I think that could be quite useful.
Am I random?
If so, then I did not kill anyone last night.

and phoebus should go next.

[Phoebus]

I didn't kill anyone last night either.

DS?

[mlaker]

I'll be next and I did not kill anyone last night. Do I say who goes next?

[Phoebus]

Um, mlaker, I already requested DS to come forward...

[mlaker]

Oh sorry didn't know it was you (didn't see your name or avatar) and thought you

were

DS. Sory stupid mistake!

[mathcam]

So....DS?

Cam

[Dragon Slayer]

I did not kill anyone last night.

-DS

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I didn't kill anyone last night, either.

[CoolBot]

I think part of mathcam's plan was after noting whether or not one killed, one would name the next person. I'll go now; I didn't kill anyone.

UT?

[mlaker]

This could be stupid but maybe UT is not saying whether or not he killed last night on purpose. Maybe he's trying to come up with a good vig claim? Well for now it warrants an

FOS UT

at least.

[Scalebane]

actually, I forgot to mention the fact that UT is out of town until sunday, due to the fact that he is in all district band.

[CoolBot]

Bah! Leo, then.

[Leonidas]

Hmm?

Well I've been cleared by a cop, so... Next.

[mathcam]

Who's left? I sure didn't kill anyone.

Cam

[Macros]

discussion has dropped to a standstill

deadline (varyable) Friday 6 pm GMT

[CoolBot]

Here's a list of who's gone so far:
Scalebane
Pheobus
mlaker
Dragon Slayer
Mr_Gnome_It_All
CoolBot
Mathcam

Those who haven't:
Untrod Tripod
Leonidas

Though Leo has apparently been cleared. I don't know if that should mean Leo shouldn't say whether he killed or not. After all, there are pro-town roles that may kill.

[Werebear]

I didn't kill anyone last night.

...oh wait, I'm dead.

[Leonidas]

Why volunteer information, Coolbot? I've been cleared, so:

If I'm a vig:
- what good is it for the Town to know if I'm a vig?

If I'm not the vig:
- why should I deny being a vig? Wouldn't it make for scums to find the vig?

[Leonidas]

I meant:

Wouldn't it make it easier for scums to find the vig?

[mathcam]

I suppose this makes sense, but I can't help but feel that some time in the near future, we're going to be having a mass role claim anyway.

I think Leo should hold off and UT should answer.

Cam

[Macros]

bump, deadline is friday, i'll poke ut.

[Scalebane]

UT is being really irresponsible recently when it comes to mafia, although he has had a lot of work recently. But on that note, I shall give him a physical prod tomorrow and a good reminder to not do this sort of thing tomorrow.