Open 9 - Basic Twelve Player (Game Over!) - before 400

[The Central Scrutinizer]

vote:IH

I think the IH wagon needs a little more steam. I believe I've already outlined my reasons for voting him.

[Akbar]

I would like to point out SV was scum in that game, and I gave no reasoning whatsoever.

And that time she wasn't throwing suspicion and now she is.

Do you feel that conclusion was intended by the quoted? Thus clearing SV of suspicion.

[spectrumvoid]

Erm... in Switch Mafia I was scum. I purposely left you alone because I knew we were going to night-kill you. We (scum-group) planned to attack people who mentioned the list, blame them on wifoming, then push for lynch.

Obviously, the same is not true this game.

[Twito]

I would like to point out SV was scum in that game, and I gave no reasoning whatsoever.

And that time she wasn't throwing suspicion and now she is.

Do you feel that conclusion was intended by the quoted? Thus clearing SV of suspicion.

Kinda yes.

[spectrumvoid]

Pokes everyone.

[Twito]

Now that I remember I found Fircoal uberscummy on another game aswell and he turned up town.
And I don't like so much being poked.

Unvote
Vote: SV

[Lowell]

I want to bandwagon.

unvote, vote IH

SV is next. Don't think you're free.

[Ripley]

Are you

still

rereading, IH? I'm all in favor of being thorough, but a week to read a 9 page thread?

[IH]

= | I'm seriously not seeing too much, though I am having problems to actually get time to do a reread pbpa.

I've been sick alot also, so lately I've mostly only been able to respond to current things in my game.

[Twito]

= | I'm seriously not seeing too much, though I am having problems to actually get time to do a reread pbpa.

I've been sick alot also, so lately I've mostly only been able to respond to current things in my game.

So what is your illness?

[spectrumvoid]

IH caught a virus.

Twito: I find you uberscummy in most games I'm in with you, but you don't see me accusing you or defending you on that basis. Bad bad metagaming.

[Twito]

IH caught a virus.

Twito: I find you uberscummy in most games I'm in with you, but you don't see me accusing you or defending you on that basis. Bad bad metagaming.

Oh well I'm sure you are not the only one. And yes it if someone has similar behavior in two different games and I find that behavior very scummy, then that someone dies on other one and turns up town obviously I'm gonna doubt whether I'm wrong in the other game aswell.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Why isn't IH lynched yet?

[Patrick]

The get well soon IH votecount

Battle Mage (1) -- Ripley
Spectrumvoid (1) -- Twito
AndrewS (2) -- IH, Battle Mage
IH (4) -- Shadowlurker, Spectrumvoid, The Central Scrutiniser, Lowell
Akbar (1) -- AndrewS

Not Voting: Akbar, Fircoal
11 alive, 6 to lynch.

[Akbar]

Why isn't IH lynched yet?

Ok, I'll help ya bandwagon. Of course, if he turns out to be town, this combined with my earlier suspicion of you, will confirm your scum.

Vote IH

[Battle Mage]

i implore everyone not on the IH wagon to think carefully about what it signifies. This game certainly hasnt been the most lively ive participated in, and i somewhat feel sorry for those who are Mafia in it, as it must be a real drag. It is my OPINION (as believe me when i say it is nothing more than speculation) that those who are pushing for a lynch most, are these frustrated Mafia.
I personally dont think we have enough evidence to lynch him, and i am greatly suspicious of those who are piling him.
The Central Scrutiniser has been especially keen to lynch him recently.
Im not saying that i think IH is innocent, but TCS has been exhibiting some pretty scummy behaviour recently, and is certainly worthy of my vote.

[Battle Mage]

I will also

FOS: Akbar

, as a likely candidate for Newb Mafia award. If it turns out that TCS is Mafia, i am pretty certain that Akbar wont be far behind him.

Vote: The Central Scrutiniser

Why isn't IH lynched yet?

Ok, I'll help ya bandwagon. Of course, if he turns out to be town, this combined with my earlier suspicion of you, will confirm your scum.

Vote IH

[ShadowLurker]

i implore everyone not on the IH wagon to think carefully about what it signifies. This game certainly hasnt been the most lively ive participated in, and i somewhat feel sorry for those who are Mafia in it, as it must be a real drag. It is my OPINION (as believe me when i say it is nothing more than speculation) that those who are pushing for a lynch most, are these frustrated Mafia.
I personally dont think we have enough evidence to lynch him, and i am greatly suspicious of those who are piling him.
The Central Scrutiniser has been especially keen to lynch him recently.
Im not saying that i think IH is innocent, but TCS has been exhibiting some pretty scummy behaviour recently, and is certainly worthy of my vote.

Good Appeal to Emotion

Unvote Vote BM

[Battle Mage]

I prefer to think of it as a good attempt at avoiding a Townie-Lynch.
Afraid of the fact that i have worked out ur scumbuddies perhaps?

i implore everyone not on the IH wagon to think carefully about what it signifies. This game certainly hasnt been the most lively ive participated in, and i somewhat feel sorry for those who are Mafia in it, as it must be a real drag. It is my OPINION (as believe me when i say it is nothing more than speculation) that those who are pushing for a lynch most, are these frustrated Mafia.
I personally dont think we have enough evidence to lynch him, and i am greatly suspicious of those who are piling him.
The Central Scrutiniser has been especially keen to lynch him recently.
Im not saying that i think IH is innocent, but TCS has been exhibiting some pretty scummy behaviour recently, and is certainly worthy of my vote.

Good Appeal to Emotion

Unvote Vote BM

[ShadowLurker]

I prefer to think of it as a good attempt at avoiding a Townie-Lynch.
Afraid of the fact that i have worked out ur scumbuddies perhaps?

Yes both are obviously true.

[Battle Mage]

well i can certainly vouch for the former. The latter is of course just suspicion, but the fact u have no response does little for your defence...

[Akbar]

i implore everyone not on the IH wagon to think carefully about what it signifies. This game certainly hasnt been the most lively ive participated in, and i somewhat feel sorry for those who are Mafia in it, as it must be a real drag. It is my OPINION (as believe me when i say it is nothing more than speculation) that those who are pushing for a lynch most, are these frustrated Mafia.
I personally dont think we have enough evidence to lynch him, and i am greatly suspicious of those who are piling him.
The Central Scrutiniser has been especially keen to lynch him recently.
Im not saying that i think IH is innocent, but TCS has been exhibiting some pretty scummy behaviour recently, and is certainly worthy of my vote.

I have to agree with you BM, things have been a bit quiet until IH came under some pressure. Course instead of IH stressing, seems your taking that burden yourself.
You say there isn't enough evidence to lynch IH as Mafia. Would you please outline the evidence against IH and for TCS?

[The Central Scrutinizer]

To BM:

Bandwagoning =/= scum.

The actions of IH = scum.

I wonder if you're not uncomfortable that we are onto

your

scumbuddy.

On the other hand, I would like for IH to post his defense before we lynch him. It would make scum easier to track.

[spectrumvoid]

That's probably the most grammatically correct post I've ever seen from BM.

I'd say those on IH are frustrated town who've spotted scum.

[Battle Mage]

well im not Mafia, so that kinda rules your theory out, but nice try.
@ Spectrumvoid-i suppose you would say that, being on the wagon yourself.

To BM:

Bandwagoning =/= scum.

The actions of IH = scum.

I wonder if you're not uncomfortable that we are onto

your

scumbuddy.

On the other hand, I would like for IH to post his defense before we lynch him. It would make scum easier to track.