Open 13 - Double Cop (GAME OVER) - before 405

[Blackberry]

I think the best strategy would be for the cop to claim right now.

If we get a counter-claim, we have a 50% chance of hitting scum. If we don't get a counter-claim then we got one innocent (Cop) confirmed and if they got a guilty/innocent we got that out of the way and are either narrowed down to a 66% (confirmed innocent), 50%(investigation dead... so 2/4 of hitting scum) or 100%(confirmed scum) chance of hitting scum...

Otherwise we have a 40% (2/5) chance of hitting scum?

Of course, if the Cop claims he is basically sacrificing himself for the town as he'd be marked for death come nightfall. So it's his choice.

Whats everyone else's opinion on Cop claiming?

-----------------------------------

((TWITO EDIT))

--------------------------------------------

You ski all the way to the center of the lake. It's a race! It's tight between IH and Blackberry but in the end Blackberry finds extra strenght from bottle of vodka while IH falls down kinda drunk. So Blackberry is the first to arrive.
When everybody gets there.. well Fircoal is still taking a break with a sixpack of beers but he is on his way.. you unpack your bags take out the jigs and vodka and all that and start drilling holes to the ice.
Another race whoohoo! Who can make most holes? After a dozen holes you all feel pretty tired and decide to drink a bit while waiting for Fircoal to get there.

Drilling-holes-to-the-ice-Votecount:

Not voting: 5 (Fircoal, Romanus, IH, spectrumvoid, Blackberry)

[Romanus]

Well, since you hammered the other cop, yeah, I do think we need as much info as possible.

[IH]

....Nah, I think we'd kinda be handing scum the game here....

Actually, we're at lylo... scum claim cop.... clear their partner or a random townie
Real cop counterlclaims, then we have to decide which one is lying. Scum can counterclaim the real cop, and then we've got to watch out....

pheh, I'm kind of against it...

and I'm kind of for it....

I think.... looking at the pros and cons, at the moment a cop claim would be risky, and we shouldn't take it for anything confirmed.... but it would put us in a better position than we are now.

Mod

How many are alive?

[Blackberry]

FIVE are alive...

Why are you asking the Mod!?!? O_o

[IH]

Cause I'm frickin lazy.

With five alive, a cop claim would be the best btw,

[Twito]

Fircoal hasn't posted since Day 2 started so he is getting prodded.

And 5 alive indeed just check the 1st post.

[Fircoal]

Sorry, I'm still here

[IH]

Not cop btw.

[spectrumvoid]

IH was the first to vote dcowboy. Also, these posts (I skimmed through, might have missed something, but these are more relevant):

.....Why is dcowboy still alive? = |

I'm pretty sure he's a lying newbie trying to worm his way out of something. I'm saying he's scum.

He was one of the biggest pushes of the cowboy wagon, and the kickstarter, Hence why I said the wagon didn't give us info earlier. I'm cop. IH is not scum.

I did not investigate BB though she was the hammer because I meta-gamed BB, and I'm pretty sure she generally plays like that. IH can't be meta-gamed.

[Fircoal]

IH was the first to vote dcowboy. Also, these posts (I skimmed through, might have missed something, but these are more relevant):

.....Why is dcowboy still alive? = |

I'm pretty sure he's a lying newbie trying to worm his way out of something. I'm saying he's scum.

He was one of the biggest pushes of the cowboy wagon, and the kickstarter, Hence why I said the wagon didn't give us info earlier. I'm cop. IH is not scum.

I did not investigate BB though she was the hammer because I meta-gamed BB, and I'm pretty sure she generally plays like that. IH can't be meta-gamed.

Ty scum for revealing yourself.

Vote: Spectrumviod

You're not the cop, because I am the cop.
I investigated Romanus since his posts seemed scummy, and I got that he was innocent. And SV, I believe you were the hammer not BB.

[Romanus]

very interesting

[Blackberry]

First off, I am a

FE

MALE.

I'm THINKING the scum are IH + SV right now. Both cops saying they got an innocent is an interesting strategy.

I want to hear IH and Romanus' thoughts.

Typing error fixed. -Mod

[Romanus]

I wish to hear spectrumvoid's retort.

[IH]

....Even though it looks bad for ANOTHER IH+SV scum pairing (open 10 = / ) I'd be more inclined to believe SV if only because she claimed before Fircoal....

Fircoals claim looks like scum trying to draw more attention away from Romanus (from earlier yesterday), and trying to get SV lynched with a counterclaim quickly....

Though I'm not sure at the moment....

[spectrumvoid]

I'm not sure if I'm allowed to talk about this, but I'd recommended taking a look at open 9 (on-going.) Just look at my claim and what Fircoal has to say. To be as vague as possible, Fircoal-scum learnt a lesson about claiming.

Rather obviously, I didn't investigate myself. I've already explained why I investigated IH.

[Fircoal]

I'm not sure if I'm allowed to talk about this, but I'd recommended taking a look at open 9 (on-going.) Just look at my claim and what Fircoal has to say. To be as vague as possible, Fircoal-scum learnt a lesson about claiming.

6. Do not make references to other ongoing games. Violators are subject to replacement or modkill at my discretion.

Hmm, isn't that against the rules.

[spectrumvoid]

I did not talk about it. I was as vague as possible.

[Romanus]

So:
Spectrumvoid claims cop, investigated IH (innocent)
Fircoal claims cop, investigated Romanus (innocent)

Did we not have any other investigations?

Right now I am favoring a Fircoal/Blackberry scum pairing, but I need to reread.

[Romanus]

Ok, after a quick reread, I believe that Fircoal is scum.

Responses are welcome.

I am also favoring a Blackberry partner, but that is beside the point right now.

[Twito]

SV is dead in that game and didn't actually discuss it so there is gonna be no problems for her.
That rule actually might still need some fixing. Just felt the need to add it after looking at some behavior on other games.

[Fircoal]

SV is dead in that game and didn't actually discuss it so there is gonna be no problems for her.
That rule actually might still need some fixing. Just felt the need to add it after looking at some behavior on other games.

ok, I just thought it was against the rules. Sorry, Sv.

[spectrumvoid]

Just a reminder: we have 2 cops this game.

dcowboy: did you breadcrumb?

This was my lame breadcrumb, by the way.

We started in day, only 1 investigation.

vote: Fircoal

[Blackberry]

Just a reminder: we have 2 cops this game.

dcowboy: did you breadcrumb?

This was my lame breadcrumb, by the way.

We started in day, only 1 investigation.

vote: Fircoal

A: What took you so long to vote Fircoal?

B: How the hell is that a breadcrumb? If anything you're "trying to look pro-town by reminding another cop that there are two..."

I'm fairly confident you are scum.

[Romanus]

Vote: Fircoal

[IH]

FoS:Romanus