Newbie 310: It's All Over -- WOO-HOO!

[MeMe]

"About 3.5 hours to deadline"

Vote Count

:

theopor_COD

(2):

Seol, Fircoal

Fircoal

(2):

Thesp, gorckat

VitaminR

(1):

Avinyl

Seol

(1):

VitaminR

not voting

(1):

theopor_COD

[VitaminR]

Okay... now this was what I was hoping to avoid.

I'm not going to be the third vote on the theopor or Fircoal wagon.

I really want a Seol lynch. Please?

[VitaminR]

Hello?

[Thesp]

Unvote: Fircoal, Vote: Seol.

I have zero interest in a theopor_COD lynch today.

[VitaminR]

Yay!

[MeMe]

Sorry to be late -- birthday stuff! Yay!

Deadline hits. No lynch for you.

Night choices due by

5:30 p.m. EST Thursday, March 15

(bit more than 48 hours from this post).

[MeMe]

Everyone mourn for

VitaminR

, dead

townie

.

Six alive means four to lynch. Good morning everyone!

~~~~~~~~~~

Mastermind of Sin replaces Seol, at his request.

[gorckat]

Interesting. I expected to find a guilty on VR Night 2 after learning that Fircoal is guilty (given how he'd been convinced of Firc's innocence earlier)...time to reread and see who to look at next (assuming I don't get the axe myself Night 2)

vote:Fircoal

[theopor_COD]

Interesting. I expected to find a guilty on VR Night 2 after learning that Fircoal is guilty (given how he'd been convinced of Firc's innocence earlier)...time to reread and see who to look at next (assuming I don't get the axe myself Night 2)

vote:Fircoal

Are you claiming cop?

Oh and welcome MoS good luck with the read, I'd like to hear some opinions.

Avinyl pls pipe up.

And I must say I'm dissapointed with the way Day One ended, apologies to VR aswell let's just hope his work wasn't in vain. More later.

[gorckat]

Yes- sorry if I wasn't clear enough.

[theopor_COD]

Well I gotta say Fircoal was my preferred lynchee yesterday so I tend to believe you, but I'm going to hold off voting because I want to hear everyone's opinion on it.

Either your the cop and Fircoal's scum

Or you're lieing and your the scum bum

Decisions, decisions - killing VR seems an odd move for Fircoal to make aswell especially with VR's staunch defence of him, I'm not sure . . .

[Mastermind of Sin]

Hmm, I'm going to have to reread to make sure I don't think this is a scum gambit, since we might not necessarily have a cop in the game. I'm pretty much caught up with the game (as far as what has happened), though I'm not quite sure of my suspicions yet.

theopor, remember that Fircoal is not the only scum out there, so his partner would have some say in it (assuming Fircoal is scum). Also, killing VR would just help make Fircoal look good, since VR did defend him.

[theopor_COD]

Good point MoS re the killing of VR.

I'm certainly not going to be after a quick day two. We need to nail a scum today or it's game over pretty much.

[Fircoal]

Vote: gorckat

I'm not scum. You're not cop. We both win.

[gorckat]

Indeed, welcome Mastermind- I didn't even read that Seol was replaced That has got to be a hard Day One to slog through (I know it was for me).

I guess Fircoal's response is to be expected...

[theopor_COD]

Thoughts on the other scum pls, Fircoal and Gorckat.

I'll be voting one you two mind.

[Fircoal]

My thoughts is that the other scum is Seol. Seol was gone, so Gorckat had to make the kill. VitaminR has put the most suspicion on him so he killed him. Now he wants me lynched. Also Seol fighting with VitaminR goes back to my one is probably town one is probably scum.

[Avinyl]

Gorckat is lying. I am the cop, and i got Fircoal as innocent last night.

Vote: Gorckat

[gorckat]

@theopor: Well there's two Even after they take me down, the town will win Day 3.

Convenient how the person who posted the least can swoop in and try to rescue his scumbuddy with a bogus claim.

@Fircoal: You offed VR because he defended you and suspected me. What better way to make me look bad and yourself like a saint?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Now this makes things more interesting. Scum gambit to try and off Fircoal, or scum gambit to protect Fircoal and counterclaim? Both make a lot of sense, since the cop finding scum would force them out into the open, otherwise they'd just get lynched. Well, we've gotta lynch right today, so I hope everyone else will be careful with their votes until they're sure of who they think the scum is. One thing we're sure of is this, though:

1) Gorckat is scum
2) Avinyl AND Fircoal are scum

[Mastermind of Sin]

Avinyl, if you're the cop and Gorckat is scum, who's his scumpartner?

Also, what made you choose to investigate Fircoal last night?

[Mastermind of Sin]

This is mostly for my reference, it's a summary of Avinyl's posts.

Avinyl (13 posts):
- random votes Seol
- apologizes for not posting much, bad internet
- internet fixed, no suspicions, unvotes
- gone due to illness, thinks theopor_COD, Fircoal, and VitaminR seem suspicious. lists reasons
- agrees with Seol about VitaminR
- didn't lynch theopor b/c didn't want to end day too soon, explains VR suspicion somewhat more
- here, needs to reread
- posts suspicion list of everyone in the game
- forgives Fircoal for something
- says he doesn't post much because he can't come up with much to say, still suspects VitaminR, and also theodor somewhat
- internet problems, rereading
- rereading
- claims cop, votes Gorckat

[Mastermind of Sin]

More notes for me:

Azkar/Gorckat (23 posts): Not listing Azkar's posts unless I find something overly scummy, since it's hard to defend someone you replaced.
- unvotes until reread is done
- printed out thread to reread
- had RL issues, halfway through reread
- votes VitaminR for weak tell in calling Fircoal protown
- explains that VR slipped because he posted emotionally, lists other evidence against VR for him to repond to
- retracts other evidence because he missed VR's defense of it, explains his mindset to theopor
- meant to talk to Thesp instead of theopor
- sees seol as helpful, theopor as genuine, fircoal as jumping around in votes and asking other's opinions a bit much without his own contribution
- sees thesp as even-keeled, gives avinyl a chance to catch up, questions his changing opinions on Fircoal without explanation, posts suspicion list
- read something in the wiki about Finding Mafia, can't find it anymore
- explains wiki article
- says that a "slip" is unintentional, but not sure about the tell from the wiki anymore, unvotes
- asks theopor what he wants him to comment on, sees theopor wagon and Seol/VR debate as the biggest things
- calls theopor lucky for surviving a week at -1, doesn't like Avinyl's explanation for not hammering theopor, thinks Seol might be opportunistic regarding theopor, supports asking for a claim at that point, wants more contribution from Avinyl
- votes Fircoal for floating suspicions with bad explanation
- explains his view of one of Fircoal's posts, thinks VR was a bit pushy on Seol, acted as the aggressor in the debate
- wonders about Seol's absence, realizes that only Fircoal and Seol still think theopor is suspicious, wonders about scum grouping of those two
- doesn't see a link between Fircoal and Seol due to Fircoal's voting record
- explains that he doesn't see a pairing, but his vote is based on Fircoal's ownactions
- claims cop with guilty on Fircoal, votes Fircoal
- confirms that he's claiming cop
- welcomes me to the game, expects Fircoal to vote him
- finds Avinyl's claim convenient, gives reasoning as to why Fircoal would've killed VR.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Will try to review Fircoal tomorrow, I have a huge project due tonight, and I'm going home for Spring Break, so I have to pack.

[Thesp]

Vote: No Lynch.

I cannot imagine a reason a lynch is better in this case. I will look at the claims and counterclaims when I have time - which may be a while, I'm headed out of town for the weekend.