Open 11 - Pie C9 (Game over) - before 400

[Fircoal]

^Ernie Skruffs is replacing Shadowlurker.

I agree with your suspicions of Ripley. And so the game I'm playing is called Follow the leader?

[Patrick]

I agree with your suspicions of Ripley. And so the game I'm playing is called Follow the leader?

This strikes me as oppotunistic. I could see a Skruffs/Fircoal scumteam here, and would be happy lynching Fircoal.

[Nightfall]

1) I dont think Twito has played diferently
2) I stll dont get the dice...

[Patrick]

CDB and Ripley seem quite reasonable to me.

Shadowlurker's last few posts were focussed on Ernie/CDB, the relatively easy target. Skruff's first serious post of the game felt off, and I didn't really agree with the attack on Ripley, which seemed to misrepresent him in certain ways. Indirect attempt to save Fircoal perhaps, while maintaining a wishy washy stance on him.

Fircoal's last post set off alarm bells too, since I don't think he ever voiced any suspicions of Ripley before, and I think was last seen calling him pro town. I think he does seem to play follow the leader too much. My guess is Ernie was just the lynchbait and Fircoal is scum.

[Skruffs]

I in no way meant to defend fircoal. I think it's likely that fircoal is tagging along behind goofy twito to seem innocent - because twito is more likely than him to get lynched for spamming and such.

If I misrepped ripley, it is because I am misunderstanding the way he isportraying himself, in which case, an explanation will ease my concern and i'll continue looking elsewhere.

[Ripley]

Something I just noticed is that Skruffs left Nightfall out of his analysis. Skruffs. was this deliberate or accidental, and are you going to remedy it?

I'm not sure what to do next. Patrick can see Fircoal/Skruffs as scum. I'm unhappy with how Skruffs didn't pursue his observations of Twito playing completely differently. And also with how he misrepresented me. So, given how his predecessor SL was so very unhelpful, I was thinking maybe Skruffs is the better lynch.

But then I looked at it the other way - Skruffs, a new player under time pressure (we are deadlined) did at least make a long and content-filled post, and maybe some mistakes were inevitable. Quite probably a similar post from Twito or Fircoal would have contained mistakes too. At least Skruffs gave us

something

.

SO - I'm still not decided, though we really must make a move soon. When exactly is the deadline? Fircoal is currently on 2 votes with the promise of a third from Nightfall. Fircoal is looking the most likely lynch therefore, so should we be asking him to roleclaim today, so we have time to decide what to do about the claim?

[Fircoal]

I in no way meant to defend fircoal. I think it's likely that fircoal is tagging along behind goofy twito to seem innocent - because twito is more likely than him to get lynched for spamming and such.

If I misrepped ripley, it is because I am misunderstanding the way he isportraying himself, in which case, an explanation will ease my concern and i'll continue looking elsewhere.

Twito has been acting the best so far. And also you haven't the claim which I claimed Wolf on Night 1 (or 0). (But that was after that a bit.) Also, I don't think Twito will get lynched for that.

[bird1111]

When exactly is the deadline? Fircoal is currently on 2 votes with the promise of a third from Nightfall.

Deadline's in first post, but its not at an exact time, simply whenever I wake up tommorow morning, which could be anywhere from around 6:00 AM EST to 10:00 AM EST, with anywhere from 7-9 being likely.

[Skruffs]

I'm really not sure on my opinion on Nightfall yet. IE while there is some things about him that irk me, there are some other things that reassure me. I wil put a special post for him later, when I have a bit more time.

Fircoal, I'm not saying I think he will get lynched. I actually like how he claimed scum and tried to get people to react.

Actually I cut it out because I didn't want to add flame to the fire, when I initially read through I thought shadowlurker was acting the scummiest out of everyone in the game. But that's me. So I cut that out, because it was a convincing case, and I dont want to mislead town. I'll put it back in with my other post tonight.

Lemme gather my thoughts. We have at least two days?

[Ripley]

We have at least two days?

No, it's

tomorrow morning

.

We need to act now.

[Nightfall]

Vote : Fircoal

So that someone else closer to the deadline can hammer if they need to.

That's lynch -1

[bird1111]

About to go to bed, if there is not 4 votes on someone by the time I wake up, there will be no lynch.

[Patrick]

Recommending someone hammers him, since no lynch is pretty bad in a 7 player setup.

[Patrick]

Also Fircoal, if you plan on claiming, now would be the time.

[Ripley]

I'll check the thread before I go to bed, in case of a claim, though there's not enough time left to check for counterclaims... how did this happen? It seemed the day was dragging on eternally, now all of a sudden we have a deadline almost immediately after our new player's first meaningful post. Oh well, I suppose all of us could have tried harder to post than we did, so we can't really complain ...

[Patrick]

Remember, if he claims mafia roleblocker, lynch him and we go for the win via the Patrick plan Where you from Ripley btw? And whats the timezone?

[Ripley]

Remember, if he claims mafia roleblocker, lynch him and we go for the win via the Patrick plan. Where you from Ripley btw? And whats the timezone?

Yep, I have that one covered.

I just looked at his post times in this thread, and he seems quite often to post around now. I'm in the same place as you, but I stay up really late. I can make a last check about 3.30-4. I daren't leave it till tomorrow because bird1111's rising time seems fairly random, and the US seems to be an hour ahead of where it usually is anyway. Are you likely to be around much longer? (in case I have some dilemma like Fircoal claiming something other than Mafia Roleblocker, which I think he's just about devious enough to do.)

[Patrick]

Another englishman. Excellent.

Being a lazy student, no lecture until 1 pm tomorrow, I'll be around a while longer

[Ripley]

Being a lazy student, no lecture until 1 pm tomorrow, I'll be around a while longer

Being a very, very industrious person who works from home, I will naturally be spending the whole day watching cricket.

However. Enough thread cluttering. Where's Fircoal? Fircoal, come out and play.

[Fircoal]

I'm here.

My role is a townie.

[Ripley]

OK, I guess I have no alternative. It's Fircoal or nobody.

Vote: Fircoal

[bird1111]

You string Fircoal up, and afterwards look through his house, which is faily plain, not containing any police officer badges, medical supplies, or guns so you conclude that he was a vanilla townie.

Fircoal, Vanilla Townie, lynched Day 1

It is Night One, choices due Monday at 6:40 PM local time

[bird1111]

All night choices are in, so therefore I will start day early.

You all wake up, and head to the town square, all of you expecting to see a dead body, but to your pleasant surprise all 6 of you are alive! Though for two of you, the surprise is not pleasant at all, but none of the other see that; though the others do not see.

It is now Day 2, with 6 alive it is 4 to lynch

[Patrick]

Well well. That's interesting. The mods post tells us that all choices were in, so scum certainly didn't miss he deadline. So we probably had a successful doc protect.

[Ripley]

Well, it's either a doc protect or else the mafia deliberately didn't kill. I'm still thinking about that second possibility.