NY 171: An Education in Telling Jokes (Game Over!)

[Untrod Tripod]

Well also his play yesterday was baaaaaaaaad

[DeathNote]

Maybe I am misunderstanding the word slip but in this situation, it appears as if you brought up day talk because that is what is on your mind. You slipped by revealing info about your team's powers (daytalk).

[Untrod Tripod]

That doesn't make him scum. At all.

[DeathNote]

I'm going to be sincerely pissed if I'm lynched for the one thing that I was right about this game.

There is also the possibility that you let your day talk slip because you wanted to get town credit.

[DeathNote]

That doesn't make him scum. At all.

Doesn't make Nik scum? Why? Do you not consider that a slip?

[Untrod Tripod]

A. That doesn't give him town cred
B. Day talk is not uncommon
c. He was listing it as a possibility for how zek reacted to the gamestate the way he did, not as a "this is how it happened I am nostradamus" type of thing

Look you might be right that nik is scum. I'm just pointing out that your reasoning is flawed

[Untrod Tripod]

Oh and

vote RC

[DeathNote]

I am surprised you don't see that post as anything but Nikanor defending his buddy while slipping up his team's daytalk ability.

Frankly, I don't care because once he gets lynched and flips scum, then I know for sure that my reasoning wasn't all that "flawed" lol

[Untrod Tripod]

No, it'd still be flawed.

[Green Crayons]

...can we please just do a utility lynch on RC

Disagree.

-----

Vote: Yates.

Can't really explain why I think this guy is scum, but I really think this guy is scum. I think it has something to do with him asking the wrong questions (such as his question to Marquise in 1986 (the post, not the year)). It looks like he's trying to gather information that really has nothing to do with finding scum.

I agree that Yates' questions seem "off." Not enough to make me vote him over Nik, Serra, Pere, or Ythan, though.

-----

Elyse

, please stop ignoring my Post 1956 and Post 1957.

[Yates]

I think it has something to do with him asking the wrong questions (such as his question to Marquise in 1986)

Once Marquis answers the question you won't be able to say this and expect anyone to believe it.

Nikanor scum buddy detected:

Look you might be right that nik is scum. I'm just pointing out that your reasoning is flawed

I agree that Yates' questions seem "off."

Don't drink the Kool-Aid.

[pirate mollie]

you know what?

I wanna see if I was right in my early scumread on nika was right. I can't remember why i let that go

does anybody have a recent vc

[Nikanor]

Maybe I am misunderstanding the word slip but in this situation, it appears as if you brought up day talk because that is what is on your mind. You slipped by revealing info about your team's powers (daytalk).

Honestly? I think that if anything, your attack on me makes you scum. I'm guessing that the only reason for why you remembered that quote of mine is because you knew that you could call me scum for it once Mala flipped.
And if you're town... saying "I don't care about counter-arguments because I know I'm right!!!" Is incredibly arrogant and a bad way to play mafia.

[Nikanor]

I think it has something to do with him asking the wrong questions (such as his question to Marquise in 1986)

Once Marquis answers the question you won't be able to say this and expect anyone to believe it.

a) I doubt that he will answer the question. If he wanted to be clear with his statement, he'd have been clear in the first place.
b) If he does answer, I REALLY doubt that the answer will make you look any flavour of good.

[PeregrineV]

Is there a Nik case?

He was a day1 townread, so not heavy onto the idea of this wagon. But, quite a few players have fallen short of day1 happiness.

@Nik- Need a little more info than that to get a Yates vote out of me. You got any concrete based?

[Nikanor]

@Nik- Need a little more info than that to get a Yates vote out of me. You got any concrete based?

Does his ISO count?

[pisskop]

1445 and 1446. Yup. I buy scum motivation here.
1514 is him not mentioning scum.
1608 is again him not mentioning scumz
1752 is mentioning a possible mala-scum, but nothing more.
1945 is terribad attempt to justify his terrribad post with terribad logic.

I still want and will happily take Niki, but Ill get on board

vote: serrapaladin

[DeathNote]

Honestly? I think that if anything, your attack on me makes you scum. I'm guessing that the only reason for why you remembered that quote of mine is because you knew that you could call me scum for it once Mala flipped.
And if you're town... saying "I don't care about counter-arguments because I know I'm right!!!" Is incredibly arrogant and a bad way to play mafia.

There is no arguing with UT and I don't want to start bitching with him again when it is obvious he won't change his mind. UT plants himself on his reads/opinions once people question it and it is impossible to get him to change his mind.

My "I don't care" is the best I can do against him but if you want to try and convince me how you are town then feel free. Claiming I am scum for making a case against you does not convince me you are town just fyi...

[DeathNote]

I also want Elyse to answer GC's questions. I just did a quick ISO and Elyse's activity has fallen off drastically.

@Elyse- Why are you entering active lurker stage? Your posts were much more thought out early game.

[DeathNote]

Wow.... yeah I don't know how I missed how bad Serrapaladin is. So much potential to be Malabuddy.

[PeregrineV]

I also want Elyse to answer GC's questions. I just did a quick ISO and Elyse's activity has fallen off drastically.

@Elyse- Why are you entering active lurker stage? Your posts were much more thought out early game.

Are you trying to sheep me?

[DeathNote]

I also want Elyse to answer GC's questions. I just did a quick ISO and Elyse's activity has fallen off drastically.

@Elyse- Why are you entering active lurker stage? Your posts were much more thought out early game.

Are you trying to sheep me?

No?

But if you want credit for saying that first, then all yours buddy. Hope it helps you seem a little more townie.

[PeregrineV]

I also want Elyse to answer GC's questions. I just did a quick ISO and Elyse's activity has fallen off drastically.

@Elyse- Why are you entering active lurker stage? Your posts were much more thought out early game.

Are you trying to sheep me?

No?

But if you want credit for saying that first, then all yours buddy. Hope it helps you seem a little more townie.

Does it?

Because 8 posts after I say that, I get this from you:

Tman the parrot.

Honestly

, I am down to lynch one of the following:

Tman
Peregrine
Mala
Nikanor
Marquis

Trying to connect the Deathnote thought processes here.

[DeathNote]

I'll wait for you to post something that makes sense.

If you are still trying to say I am mimicking your reads or buddying you then the answer is hell no. I wouldn't mind seeing you dead but there are lots of people in this game that fill that category.

If you remember, that is also the time when I started questioning your reads as you weren't giving any and then when you did, you wouldn't explain because "herp-derp you first".

[PeregrineV]

I'll wait for you to post something that makes sense.

If you are still trying to say I am mimicking your reads or buddying you then the answer is hell no. I wouldn't mind seeing you dead but there are lots of people in this game that fill that category.

If you remember, that is also the time when I started questioning your reads as you weren't giving any and then when you did, you wouldn't explain because "herp-derp you first".

And then I said:

You show me yours, I'll show you mine.

Mine are hidden through the thread.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

Pick a post or player, get all specific on me, address anything I posted before, and we'll talk.