Mafia 62: Suspicion in Sicily - Game over!

[PJ.]

I am really waiting for Raffles to be ready to do his thing because I'm very intrigued

[Raffles]

Well if that's the case keep posting something useful so Flay don't set a deadline. I'm in exam week and I can't write anything big, my hands are tied down. Don't just sit and watch.

[PJ.]

Alright, well thats get some more analysis guys.

[Ancalagon]

Why is RA still alive?

[Mr. Flay]

Third Vote Count of Day Four:

Rand Althor - 2 (Yosarian2, Ancalagon)
Cubsfan4ever - 2 (Panzerjager, AlexPaoletti)

Not voting - 4 (Cubsfan4ever, scotmany12, Rand Althor, Raffles)

With eight left alive, five votes will lynch.

Movement and discussion are still happening (albeit slowly), so no deadline for now.

[Rand Althor]

Sorry just got online and saw the prod. I am going to

Vote:Cubs

for the reasons I brought up and his analyses on Anc and Alex. I'm thinking if he comes up scum one of those two (or both) is a scummate.

[PJ.]

Rand, for once we are thinking together.

[Ancalagon]

RA has yet to respond to my analysis. He needs to be lynched.

[Yosarian2]

I'd like people to come in and post their analysis, but anyoen who dosn't have time to do that needs to at least come in and say SOMETHING, preferably something game related, like "what do you think about lynching Rand" or comment on someone else's analysis or something like that. Participation is so bad right now it's painful.

[PJ.]

Ancalagon, why do you want to lynch Rand so badly. I don't find him that scummy, just stupidly lurking.

[AlexPaoletti]

Sorry just got online and saw the prod. I am going to Vote:Cubs for the reasons I brought up and his analyses on Anc and Alex. I'm thinking if he comes up scum one of those two (or both) is a scummate.

Wait, why would we be cubs' scummates???

[scotmany12]

Both RA and Cubs have been lurking throughout this game quite a lot. That does not totally make them scum. I view them as just some lurkers who aren't paticularly helpful. I'm not really ok with going out and lynching some one just because they are lurking. For a deadline lynch, lurkers are fine, but I don't want to see them get lynched just for lurking.

[Ancalagon]

Rand Althor:
Confirms, "random votes" himself, but I found this interesting:

he is so scum i'm sure of it.

Picture yourself saying this as a townie. I can't.

He then unvotes and promises to review the right then.

Four days pass.

Another interesting thing is this:

can we just lynch mole?

he will likely not show up.

we can get info from the lynch.
save us messy debates.

If he doesn't post he will get a replacement. If we do lynch him and he comes up town it's a wasted lynch. Personally I don't belive in LAL

Note: mole was Mafia.

He says that his "LAL" was Lynch All Lurkers.

He votes TS, and nine days later all he says is that he likes his vote on her.

Four days later, he votes kinkster because kinkster voted himself. (he did the same thing in the random voting stage)

After this, he makes sporadic posts about how inactive he was.

Vote: RA

I didn't see his scumminess till now.

Raffles to follow, maybe later tonight. I gotta work now.

Look at this analysis!

[AlexPaoletti]

Both RA and Cubs have been lurking throughout this game quite a lot. That does not totally make them scum. I view them as just some lurkers who aren't paticularly helpful. I'm not really ok with going out and lynching some one just because they are lurking. For a deadline lynch, lurkers are fine, but I don't want to see them get lynched just for lurking.

I would like do find Cubs to be an extreme lurker, my vote on him comes more from the things he did say, as explained in my analysis of him. My vote is not because he is a lurker, though that does contribute to my opinion of him.

[Ancalagon]

Let's just find one of the two to keep a vote on. I say RA because of the reasons above. If everyone else switches to cubsfan, I will. Both should be lynched either today or tomorrow.

[Cubsfan4ever]

That's a good point, it's a little late in the process to be lynching lurkers.

[Ancalagon]

Unvote, vote: cubsfan

[Yosarian2]

Interesting. Why?

[Ancalagon]

First of all, he posted, not responding to the arguments against him that were made since his last post, a possible Freudian slip. Second of all, since this makes no sense:

That's a good point, it's a little late in the process to be lynching lurkers.

It seems way out of place, and trying to save himself, since he himself is lurker. Also, there is no "late in the process" part of lynching lurkers.
Third, because cubsfan, because of his last post, seems more deserving of a vote than RA. He seems a wee bit more scummy.
Lastly, he seems more likely to be lynched than RA, at least for today. I'll still want RA lynched tomorrow if he isn't lynched today.

[Raffles]

Concerning cubsfan, I can't get much of a read on him. He surpassed the level of active and become a stubborn lurker, and that to me feels blatantly scummy.

My WIFOM is this is so blatantly scummy that I don't want to believe it. As much as I don't see this as a reason to keep him alive, I don't see it as a reason to hammer him yet.

FoS: Cubsfan

[Ancalagon]

Who do

you

think is scum?

[PJ.]

who is you?

[scotmany12]

Okay, I think I was wrong about cubs. After looking back at AP's analysis, he was extremely scummy day 1. Him and panzer got into some crap that they argued about, and he was wrong most of the time. Overall, very scummy day 1. Then he vanished day 2. This is when he started lurking. Now I have explained that I don't find lurking enough to warrant a lynch. Lurking in plain sight, though, is different. I find it very scummy. And cubs has been doing this during day 3 and now day 4. He was obviously keeping track of the game, but he did not help at all. Whenever he posted it was either irrelevant or extremely unhelpful to the town. This does warrant a lynch. Before I reread, I though he was only lurking, but this is not the case. It seems he went out of his way to not be helpful to the town. Maybe an SK possibly? If he turns up to be town, then he is a very unhelpful one at that, so the town will not be losing that much.

[scotmany12]

Heh, look at that, I forgot to vote.

Vote: cubsfan4ever

[Mr. Flay]

Final Vote Count of Day Four:

Cubsfan4ever - 5 (Panzerjager, AlexPaoletti, Rand Althor, Ancalagon, scotmany12)

Rand Althor - 1 (Yosarian2)

Not voting - 2 (Cubsfan4ever, Raffles)
----------------------------------------------
A quiet man, Cubsfan4ever was known for his tersely worded, sometimes upsetting comments at the diner over breakfast, and was not especially well liked among the people of the town. However, at the end of the day, it comes down to whether or not he supported the criminal element in Palermo, and the truth is that he did not. He just liked to watch American baseball and be left alone.

Cubsfan4ever, Townie, was lynched Day Four.

It is now Night Four; all night actions are due to me by the end of Thursday, May 24th.