NY 176: Completely Ridiculous Mafia (Game Over)

[Bicephalous Bob]

DJ, what are your criteria for selecting your vig target?

Also, AP, if Ki-Gi talked himself in a corner when making those bold statements about dj and flaked as a result of that, which it seems to me he did, then that flaking is indicative of alignment.

[Depraved Justice]

DJ, what are your criteria for selecting your vig target?

shoot who we think is scummy and/or bad town like TSO.

[Depraved Justice]

Bob, what are your reads on Mir, Cephir, Toomai?

[Depraved Justice]

VOTE: Bob

First you say that you think we shouldn't vote. Then you ask us criteria. Well that is simple. Nero and I agree on a target.

[AngryPidgeon]

Also, AP, if Ki-Gi talked himself in a corner when making those bold statements about dj and flaked as a result of that, which it seems to me he did, then that flaking is indicative of alignment.

He gave up on a game because he was so logically decimated by Nero Cain? Ya, no.

The far more likely story is that he just siteflaked and we have no reason to think otherwise.

Can we get a replacement in here though?; its been a week.

[Cabd]

Last visited today.

[Bicephalous Bob]

I saw that too when dj linked it (which I thought was the reason why he linked it in the first place), but I just found out he did stop posting in all threads

UNVOTE:

Bob, what are your reads on Mir, Cephir, Toomai?

Mirhawk is probably (hopefully) town. I'm waffling on the rest. Toomai made one pretty cool post and a lot of slightly shitty ones. Cephrir stays at the surface all the time.

VOTE: Bob

First you say that you think we shouldn't vote. Then you ask us criteria. Well that is simple. Nero and I agree on a target.

:cool:

I didn't tell you to do anything. I think reinoe is a good vig target because him getting killed will have little influence on the game.

[AngryPidgeon]

I think reinoe is a good vig target because him getting killed will have little influence on the game.

To the contrary, hes a good vig BECAUSE that will have a big influence on the game.

[Bicephalous Bob]

as in he doesn't have much to offer im tired

[Depraved Justice]

AP, why do you think Ki-Gi visited the site but didn't post?

[reinoe]

as in he doesn't have much to offer im tired

Hey phone posting.

That's a pretty wild accusation coming from yourself.



VOTE: bicephalous bob

[Toomai]

I don't like how DJ claimed at...L-5? With two other players also leading the race at L-5? I'm dubious.

[AngryPidgeon]

AP, why do you think Ki-Gi visited the site but didn't post?

I don't know, maybe he thought of a funny booby joke to PM to goodmorning so he did that. OR maybe he wanted to read the League of Legends thread. Activity is a shitty tell and we should replace this slot 3 days ago.

[Cabd]

I don't like how DJ claimed at...L-5? With two other players also leading the race at L-5? I'm dubious.

It's very confirm-able role wise. It's not something we need worry about for now.

[AngryPidgeon]

I don't like how DJ claimed at...L-5? With two other players also leading the race at L-5? I'm dubious.

It's very confirm-able role wise. It's not something we need worry about for now.

Ya, this. Nero is pretty confirmed town afaic. I mean the only plausible role that could make that claim as scum is SK and that is way too preemptive to be an SK.

[Depraved Justice]

I don't like how DJ claimed at...L-5? With two other players also leading the race at L-5? I'm dubious.

You see that thing at the end of the vote counts. It is a deadline. Our wagon was the only one with momentum so we had to claim so we could get a scum lynch off. Wagons with momentum tend to be the only viable ones this late.

[reinoe]

I think reinoe is a good vig target because him getting killed will have little influence on the game.

To the contrary, hes a good vig BECAUSE that will have a big influence on the game.

Agreed. It'll suck getting shot but all those people who got on my wagon for shit reasons are going to look really fucking guilty as long as town doesn't dawdle with demanding explanations. Bob's getting lynched but TSO and Toomai both did fuckall today.

[Bicephalous Bob]

gm can we have a deadline extension since ki-gi should've been replaced by now

[Mirhawk]

oh I see how it is. When Iz suggested that I was scummy for townreading his scumreads it was a good argument. But when I mock him (and show him how ridiculous) said argument is its a bad argument? I really hate you and Ceph buddying up to IZ like that.

What are you talking about? What does this even have to do with Izy? Are we talking about the same thing?

You could prob push the "there's scum motivation in what you are doing" on anyone. Its also not "establishing" motive 'cause you wouldn't know anyone's motives till they flip.

This is terrible. By this reasoning there's really no point in scumhunting at all, without looking for motive behind what players are doing we may as well be randomly lynching people.

Lets see. I was clearly fussing at Ki-Gi for not really backing up his statement that I was being "weird" and then you cherry pick and try to show that I'm fussing at Ki-Gi for not suspecting AP. And taking my response to Iz and trying to make it look like I was talking about you while simultaneously calling it shit reasoning but whiteknighting Iz.

Do you even understand why I think you're scum?

You were lurking, when people started talking about you you immediately showed up. You were called on this by more then one player,

you then completely ignored this for pages

. Then when you did acknowledge it, you tried to pretend that it wasn't scummy because scum wouldn't do it.

Sure there's a bunch of stuff since then, but that's just icing on the cake. This is where I started scumreading you.

but my other head thinks we should claim so w/e

town vig.

~

Yeah fine whatever. This is extremely verifiable so I'm not going to push this further. I will however require a night in which you made a kill and a night in which you didn't make a kill to believe this claim in the long run. I suppose mafia vig is possible, but unlikely.

[Cabd]

I suppose mafia vig is possible, but unlikely.

GM is way too oldschool for this to be a possibility. There's three potentials here:

They're town vig.
They're serial killer.
They're liar scum that is gonna claim their kill got blocked or soaked tomorrow.

And in that order of likelihood.

[Mirhawk]

I'm going to stay on Toomai, it's the wagon I like best. It's also the wagon most likely to actually need my vote.

Bob's wagon isn't that bad. His attempt to run Ki-gi up for a lurker lynch with two days remaining was awful.

The people on reinoes wagon should get off it and decide between Toomai and Bob.

[Mirhawk]

You know DJ, it's a good thing I'm not Titus.

She totally would have kept pushing for you lynch.

She's crazy, I've seen her do it.

[Cephrir]

but my other head thinks we should claim so w/e

town vig.

~

This game needs a vig and your realness will be evident in a hurry.

UNVOTE:

[Cephrir]

I don't like how DJ claimed at...L-5? With two other players also leading the race at L-5? I'm dubious.

Momentum.

Also, what scum claims vig, that's awful.

[Cephrir]

gm can we have a deadline extension since ki-gi should've been replaced by now