Open 23 - Masons and Monks (GAME OVER) - before 458

[JDodge]

End-of-day Vote Count:

J-Man - 6 (LSU Tiger Josh, Stewie, dylan41985, Adel, Sir Tornado, ojpower)
now a ranger - 1 (J-Man)

Not voting (3): now a ranger, The Greg, Sweenytodd

Mourn the loss of J-Man,

Townie

.

It is now Night 1, deadline 1:18 PM EDT on Saturday, June 23rd. Earliest I will open the thread is 1:18 PM EDT on Friday, June 22nd.

Thank you Sweenytodd for pointing out that I had Adel listed twice in the vote count.

[JDodge]

Guardian replaces now a ranger.

[JDodge]

It was by far a good news, bad news night in the fair little town.

The good news being that 8 of you are still alive!

The bad news being that Adel is dead. Or, at least, what's LEFT of Adel, as you find his remains ripped to bits, with a bullet hole through his skull.

Adel,

townie

, shot and eaten N1.

It is now Day 2, with 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

[Guardian]

Damnit! And I replaced in in part to play in another game with Adel... On the bright side, only one townie dead.

Oh well, now that I wasn't NK'd I'll re-read the game and post some thoughts in a few minutes...

[dylan41985]

I could have guessed that Adel would be killed next by the evils of the town, but wow - he had no chance.

I'm going to be gone all of next week and I don't know how much I'll be able to post.

I'm highly suspicious of Sir Tornado and Stewie though...

[Guardian]

Dylan, I actually agree with being suspicious of those two; there are few players who I am not suspicious of at this point, though, you included. For now, though, there is another player I wish to focus on: ojpower.

Consider his contributions to this game, in their entirety:

Vote:dylan41985

He's the only one with numbers in his sn. =D

I guess I can go and unvote my random one.

Unvote

Prod received.

I am convinced that J-man is scum by other people's words. So

Vote:J-man.

I understand that you had surgery, but I find it hard to believe that you have nothing to contribute to the game other than this. Also, your hammer was scummy as hell. If you are going to hammer someone at the bottom of page 5 I would expect better reasons than being convinced by others.

Please explain what words of others convinced you that J-man was scum - and convinced you enough that you were willing to hammer. What exactly made J-man scummy?

Vote: ojpower

. Explain, and I will

consider

taking my vote off.

[Stewie]

I could have guessed that Adel would be killed next by the evils of the town, but wow - he had no chance.

I'm going to be gone all of next week and I don't know how much I'll be able to post.

I'm highly suspicious of Sir Tornado and Stewie though...

Why's that?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

It was by far a good news, bad news night in the fair little town.

The good news being that 8 of you are still alive!

The bad news being that Adel is dead. Or, at least, what's LEFT of Adel, as you find his remains ripped to bits, with a bullet hole through his skull.

Adel,

townie

, shot and eaten N1.

It is now Day 2, with 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

Damn Adel what did you do to make both the werewolves and mafia mad at you?

OJ is acting suspicious as if he isn't going to really post in here he should be replaced. If the mod doesn't want to replace him then I'll believe him to be either a scum or mafia and will vote to lynch him later. For now

FOS OJ

for submarining

[Sir Tornado]

I am convinced that J-man is scum by other people's words. So

Vote:J-man

.

Why drop the hammer so soon?

Vote Ojpower

[Sir Tornado]

I am convinced that J-man is scum by other people's words. So

Vote:J-man

.

Why drop the hammer so soon?

Vote: ojpower

[LSU Tiger Josh]

It was by far a good news, bad news night in the fair little town.

The good news being that 8 of you are still alive!

The bad news being that Adel is dead. Or, at least, what's LEFT of Adel, as you find his remains ripped to bits, with a bullet hole through his skull.

Adel,

townie

, shot and eaten N1.

It is now Day 2, with 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

Damn Adel what did you do to make both the werewolves and mafia mad at you?

OJ is acting suspicious as if he isn't going to really post in here he should be replaced. If the mod doesn't want to replace him then I'll believe him to be either a scum or mafia and will vote to lynch him later. For now

FOS OJ

for submarining

Edit by way of post The last sentece should say If the mod doesn't want to replace him then I'll believe him to be either a werewolf or mafia and will vote to lynch him later. Not used to having werewolves in a game.

[JDodge]

I will prod ojpower. In the future, please bold anything that needs my attention.

[The Greg]

I think ojpower is certainly worthy of suspicion, and I've got my eye on dylan and LSU as well. That was an awfully quick lynch, and none of them gave good reasons for being on the J-man bandwagon.

FOS: ojpower, LSU Tiger Josh, and dylan41985

[The Greg]

Also, I'll be leaving tonight and traveling without internet access until Saturday, June 30. I don't want to commit to a vote when I'm not here to monitor it.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Fos The Greg

as I was the first voter on J and had a good enough reason for the vote on a day 1 lynch. Everyone else bandwagoned AFTER me so get the facts straight as you aren't in the bandwagon if you're the first to vote someone.

[The Greg]

You voted him for metagaming. Metagaming =/= Scum. Its a bad strategy, sure, but not scummy. A pro-town player can metagame just as easily as scum. How is that a good enough reason for a lynch? It doesn't matter that it was D1, you still left your vote on someone in danger of being lynched for a relatively weak reason, the metagaming.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

He should've presented a better argument as to why I shouldn't have kept my vote on him. As such, he shares in the blame for his own lynch. Yes pro town players can metagame just as much as antitown players can. However, it's a bad policy to do and when in doubt, I will spend my random vote on someone that practices bad practices that are scummy in nature.

[JDodge]

Prodding Sweenytodd.

[Adel]

Bah! I'm dead. I'm

really

dead. gah.

[dylan41985]

Hey all,
I'm going to

vote: Stewie

more explanations to come next week[/b]

[Stewie]

To have "more" of something, don't you need some of it to begin with?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Very good point Stewie.

FOS Dylan

for his no explanation and not understanding that more requires something to begin with.

Vote OJPower

for still not posting and also droppign the hammer on day 1.

[Guardian]

MOD

has ojpower picked up his prod? If not, replacement?

He is the major focus of my suspicions at the moment, and having that role inactive... is annoying.

[JDodge]

MOD

has ojpower picked up his prod? If not, replacement?

He is the major focus of my suspicions at the moment, and having that role inactive... is annoying.

ojpower has picked up his prod.

[Guardian]

Ah. Lurker scum, I say!