Mini 455 - Mafia in Theoville - Game Over who won?

[ChaosOmega]

As for why I think Nanook is innocent. The whole thing in the beginning with him outing Guardian did look suspicious, but it seemed like that it was just him being a little rusty. I can understand, because, well, I did the same thing day 2. Now, on to Guardian's analysis on Nanook:

Nanook: Before Adel claimed he was very willing to lynch her

And you weren't? So you find Nanook scummy for something that you did pretty much all game long.

and also he tried to cast doubt on both claimed cops in his recent analysis

And you're suspicious of him for providing his analysis of the game...that doesn't make sense...oh wait, it's analysis you don't agree with, therefore, he must be scum.

Also, though I do not put much stock into this, NanoS was highly suspicious of him.

Well, you said yourself that you don't put much stock into it. I can't remember NanoS providing much of a good case against him.

That, in addition to his reasons for outing me, make him also seem like not a bad choice.

Not a bad choice...so you're also saying that Nanook is not the #1 choice to be lynched. I agree.

vote: Guardian

You were suspicious of his analysis about the two claimed cops, and you act like it's a mortal sin for questioning you and YogurtBandit, when neither of you are 100% cleared.

[NanookTheWolf]

Alright, I haven't been able to read the thread in its entirety here, but basically I'm getting that Adel is the vig which confirms YB as cop and Meme as town .. right?

I've had a feeling about Guardian from the beginning and I think I'm going to

Vote: Guardian

.. I could be on the wrong side of the town, but my thoughts from earlier and new thoughts from others combined makes this a better choice, IMO. Plus, between the two wagons, I've really got nothing against CO, so Guardian will be my choice.

I haven't been posting too much recently btw because of sickness and attention needed in games I've been modding.

[YagamiLight]

Alright, I haven't been able to read the thread in its entirety here, but basically I'm getting that Adel is the vig which confirms YB as cop and Meme as town .. right?

It does not necessaruly confirm meme, can't forget the possibility of a godfather.

I've had a feeling about Guardian from the beginning and I think I'm going to

Vote: Guardian

.. I could be on the wrong side of the town, but my thoughts from earlier and new thoughts from others combined makes this a better choice, IMO. Plus, between the two wagons, I've really got nothing against CO, so Guardian will be my choice.

I think CO seems scummyer for trying to out Adel. I get you doing it because you could have been rusty like he said, but we had talked long anfd hard about it after you and it seemed unanimous that it was a bad idea, but come Day 2 he does it anyhow. I think CO is the lynch today, but I want to make sure no one needs more discussion like YB asked.

[YogurtBandit]

Alright, I haven't been able to read the thread in its entirety here, but basically I'm getting that Adel is the vig which confirms YB as cop and Meme as town .. right?

I've had a feeling about Guardian from the beginning and I think I'm going to

Vote: Guardian

.. I could be on the wrong side of the town, but my thoughts from earlier and new thoughts from others combined makes this a better choice, IMO. Plus, between the two wagons, I've really got nothing against CO, so Guardian will be my choice.

I haven't been posting too much recently btw because of sickness and attention needed in games I've been modding.

So both Nanook and CO scum wanted a last ditch attempt. Nice try, scum.

[YagamiLight]

Any reason why I shouldn't hammer CO?

[YogurtBandit]

Any reason why I shouldn't hammer CO?

I dont think there is any, since we know tomorrows lynch.

[MeMe]

We

do

? Can you clue me in?

I'm a little in awe of Guardian's ability to stay alive, his main argument for which is that he'll have another investigation result tomorrow after having already delivered a bad one today. He's either paranoid or a liar...and my money's on the latter (because I know YB's investigation was accurate and Guardian's was not, I've ruled the "reverse" possibility to be unlikely).

Bravo, Guardian. You've fooled both the vigilante you said investigated as scum AND the real cop you outed. Just

wow

.

My money's on YagamiLight & Guardian as scum with the third up in the air -- but I'm really hoping I'll die tonight as I don't think I can handle much more of this inanity.

[ChaosOmega]

I suppose claiming won't help. I'm a vanilla townie. I don't know what I can do to convince you that I'm not scum.

Well, I've posted all of my thoughts on the game. Unless there's anything else you want me to answer, I don't know what else to say.

[MeMe]

Count right now is 4 to 4 with Yagami the hold-out.

[YogurtBandit]

I really dont want a fellow cop lynched, please, lynch Chaos, He's obv scum.

[MeMe]

Unbelievable.

[Adel]

unvote:ChaosOmega vote:Guardian

[YogurtBandit]

unvote:ChaosOmega vote:Guardian

... Vig. Yeah Right. You just wanted to take both cops out.

[theopor_COD]

End of Day Votecount

Guardian 5 - MeMe, Jalyn, ChaosOmega, NanooktheWolf, Adel

ChaosOmega 3 - Guardian, YogurtBandit, Streeflo

Not voting - YagamiLight

5 to lynch - deadline not required. Write up coming in five.

[YogurtBandit]

We know who to lynch tomorrow.

If Im dead, Its all part of Adel's plan to take out the cops. Any Doc alive, protect me, please.

If there relly is a vig, Dont shoot if Guardian is town. If Guardian is scum, hit Wolf. We'll take care of Adel Tomorrow.

[MeMe]

YB -- are you

serious

?

[MeMe]

Write up coming in five.

We've passed five minutes

and

five hours -- I'm really hoping he didn't mean five

days

here.

[YogurtBandit]

Write up coming in five.

We've passed five minutes

and

five hours -- I'm really hoping he didn't mean five

days

here.

Well, He hasnt been online...

[Streeflo]

Back! Finally got around checking this thread.

So the deadline passed and Guardian is lynched. I'm surprised at the fast bandwagon on him, and Adel's sudden vote change seeing how he questioned my sudden FoS when MeMe explained her reasoning. But not altogether unhappy, as Guardian would have been my second choice under ChaosOmega.

[YogurtBandit]

Back! Finally got around checking this thread.

So the deadline passed and Guardian is lynched. I'm surprised at the fast bandwagon on him, and Adel's sudden vote change seeing how he questioned my sudden FoS when MeMe explained her reasoning. But not altogether unhappy, as Guardian would have been my second choice under ChaosOmega.

Adel is obv scum.

[MeMe]

We know there's a vigilante.

EVERYONE checked in and said that they weren't the vigilante.

Therefore, Adel's the vigilante.

What the

hell

, YB?

[YogurtBandit]

We know there's a vigilante.

EVERYONE checked in and said that they weren't the vigilante.

Therefore, Adel's the vigilante.

What the

hell

, YB?

Then Wh ywould she kill a Near Confirmed Cop?

[MeMe]

He is not, by any stretch of the imagination, "near confirmed."

[Adel]

I don't know if changing my vote was the correct decision. The anticipation is killing me.

With 8 votes cast at least two scum are voting. My theory is that CO didn't get bussed by his scum mates because he is not scum. Guardian may not be scum either, but I was worried about two realistic possibilities:

1. YL is scum, and would drop the hammer on CO once he found the good excuse he was looking for, like a looming deadline.
2. Anyone else (besides me of course) who switched from one bandwagon to another is likely scum.

Nanook will be my NK. Nanook's name was in the encrypted breadcrumb Guardian left a couple of pages ago. Guardian as townie had Nanook as a prime suspect, and Guardian as scum would target a scumbuddy next. Either way Nanook will die tonight.

[YogurtBandit]

No. Do not Nk him, Cause if you do and hes town, we lose. Wait so we can lynch unless Guardian is scum.