Mini 455 - Mafia in Theoville - Game Over who won?

[YagamiLight]

I don't know if changing my vote was the correct decision. The anticipation is killing me.

With 8 votes cast at least two scum are voting. My theory is that CO didn't get bussed by his scum mates because he is not scum. Guardian may not be scum either, but I was worried about two realistic possibilities:

1. YL is scum, and would drop the hammer on CO once he found the good excuse he was looking for, like a looming deadline.
2. Anyone else (besides me of course) who switched from one bandwagon to another is likely scum.

Nanook will be my NK. Nanook's name was in the encrypted breadcrumb Guardian left a couple of pages ago. Guardian as townie had Nanook as a prime suspect, and Guardian as scum would target a scumbuddy next. Either way Nanook will die tonight.

I wasn't waiting for an excuse, I wanted to make sure that we were done with the conversation and confident in a CO lynch. I had already said I thought he was scummy.

[YogurtBandit]

I don't know if changing my vote was the correct decision. The anticipation is killing me.

With 8 votes cast at least two scum are voting. My theory is that CO didn't get bussed by his scum mates because he is not scum. Guardian may not be scum either, but I was worried about two realistic possibilities:

1. YL is scum, and would drop the hammer on CO once he found the good excuse he was looking for, like a looming deadline.
2. Anyone else (besides me of course) who switched from one bandwagon to another is likely scum.

Nanook will be my NK. Nanook's name was in the encrypted breadcrumb Guardian left a couple of pages ago. Guardian as townie had Nanook as a prime suspect, and Guardian as scum would target a scumbuddy next. Either way Nanook will die tonight.

I wasn't waiting for an excuse, I wanted to make sure that we were done with the conversation and confident in a CO lynch. I had already said I thought he was scummy.

And Adel wante dto save her buddy, and was waiting to think up an excuse. I honestly cant belive shes Vig.

[YagamiLight]

Adel, whats the number you used that mad Nanook appear in his encrypted text? and how did you discover it?

[ChaosOmega]

And Adel wante dto save her buddy, and was waiting to think up an excuse. I honestly cant belive shes Vig.

Since there's only 2 sides, there's no SK. There were 2 kills last night. No one counter-claimed Adel. What makes you think Adel isn't the vig?

[Adel]

Adel, whats the number you used that mad Nanook appear in his encrypted text? and how did you discover it?

Cryptography used to be a hobby of mine.


The type of encryption he used is very weak if someone knows that an encrypted message is included. It is also much much weaker for short messages than long messages.

"aecimagbnihititia aioivonv" was my message "iamvignightchoicebm"
Notice how most of the letters are reused. If it were longer it would be stronger.
"aivohia tigbnvmaaenioiciti" is my message but with 42344235 as the number.

Guardian's message contains the letters for "Nanook". The odds of the letters being there without him spelling the name in his message are really slim, especially since his post must contain a name and I didn;t see anyother partial anagrams of players names. That he used capitalization makes it easier.

[YogurtBandit]

And Adel wante dto save her buddy, and was waiting to think up an excuse. I honestly cant belive shes Vig.

Since there's only 2 sides, there's no SK. There were 2 kills last night. No one counter-claimed Adel. What makes you think Adel isn't the vig?

Iknow no Sk, but m,aybe Adel's a rouge vig.

[Adel]

crap.
"fwr. orgNmrglNn bSge ghNofgrkyboiegf Ntaf geNNgtnNk"
also contains "Streeflo"

I take back what I said earlier... let me work on this a little longer. I'll post what I get, and I'll work quickly to beat Theo.

[NanookTheWolf]

So you're going to come after me .. even if Guardian is scum?

You could see me as possibly being his mate in the game as I've outed his breadcrumbing early on in the game and tried to get him killed, and am now voting him based on prior evidence and thoughts placed in the game?

If guardian is scum, I'm just letting you know now that by killing me you are doing bad things for the town come tomorrow.

If he's town, you might as well go for it as this game is practically dead at that point anyway.

Oh, and I claim townie btw.

[NanookTheWolf]

crap.
"fwr. orgNmrglNn bSge ghNofgrkyboiegf Ntaf geNNgtnNk"
also contains "Streeflo"

I take back what I said earlier... let me work on this a little longer. I'll post what I get, and I'll work quickly to beat Theo.

Considering that the only letter capitalized in this message is N .. I'd put my money on it being geared at me.

Again, with Guardian being mafia, and him stating me as the person to kill tonight, don't you think that you wouldn't want to go with what scum has to say?

[YagamiLight]

There's a capital S.

[Adel]

Nanook, I take it back. I'm still working on it

w. rgNmrgN bg gfgrybf Nf geNNgNk

is what is left after Streeflo Night and Nanook are taken out. The problem is that doesn't leave enough vowels for much else... So Streeflo and Nanook aren't both in there.

[NanookTheWolf]

There's a capital S.

I missed that ..

[theopor_COD]

First off a great many apologies for the delay. We have been having some dreadful storms in Britain as you could guess from the rain everywhere. One such storm decided to kill my home modem - as such I can only post at work. Luckily for you guys I'm back at work tonight, if I wasn't it may have been five days.

Anyways is it ever a good idea to lynch a cop?

In this case yes, as Guardian was revealed to be a lying Mafia Goon

Lynched Day 2 -

Guardian, Mafia Goon, Mafia Aligned.

It is now night time, roles by this time Thursday, so 72 hours away and again my sincerest apologies but not much you can do.

[theopor_COD]

My that was quick . . . the town rejoice in death of Guardian, however bad news isn't far around the corner.
6 of you arise and notice the dead bodies of MeMe poisoned to death and then still in his uniform the gruesome sight of YagamiLight's body butchered to death.

The dead are revealed as

MeMe, Vanilla Townie, Town Aligned - Poisoned Night 2
YagamiLight, Doctor, Town Aligned - Butchered to Death Night 2

There's 6 of you left - 4 to secure a hanging.

[YogurtBandit]

Well ,Im insane. That's good news for Streeflo, Who I got an Innocent on. Streeflo is basically confirmed innocent, alnog with me and Adel.

Vote:NanookTheWolf

[Jalyn]

Do you mean sane, YB? I thought you got an innocent on MeMe and she just turned up town. I don't know that we should be voting anyone quite that quickly. I guess with the vig still standing we're not quite at lynch or lose yet, but still.

Adel, did you vig MeMe or YagamiLight? (and why?)

So, we're at:

YB - cop
Adel - vig
Streeflo - cop innocent result (could be godfather, but certainly not the play today)

Leaving:
Nanook
Jalyn
ChaosOmega

as the remaining possibilities.

[YogurtBandit]

Oh wait, I did get innocent on MeMe. So I am Sane.

Unvote, Vote Streeflo

Thats better. he's the play for today. I'll probly be n'ked tonight, with the doc gone, So you'll have to find the last one alone.

[Jalyn]

Huh? So you got a "guilty" result on Streeflo, not an "innocent" but you thought you were insane so you thought guilty meant innocent?

[YogurtBandit]

Huh? So you got a "guilty" result on Streeflo, not an "innocent" but you thought you were insane so you thought guilty meant innocent?

Yeah. Streeflo is Guilty.

Adel, Vig whoever you please tonight, tomorrow you all will take out who ever didnt get killed at night.

[Jalyn]

Well, that's easy.

vote: Streeflo

[Adel]

damnit... I butchered our doctor. My point totals were equal for YL and Nanook, so MeMe's earlier post that YL was who she expected to be scum with Guardian was the tiebreaker. I spent an unreal amount of time on the decision between Nanook and YL and I choose wrong. I suck at mafia. I've killed as many townies at the mafia has.

[Adel]

Vote:Streeflo

any objection to me knifing Nanook tonight?

[theopor_COD]

Votecount

Streeflo 3 - YogurtBandit, Jalyn, Adel

Not voting - Streeflo, NanooktheWolf, ChaosOmega

4 to lynch.

[Jalyn]

That's lynch -1, do we want to go into night without any discussion?

I don't think I'll have time tonight, but if we're still at day tomorrow, I'll try to do an analysis of ChaosOmega and Nanook. Someone else should probably do one on me. (I'm pretty sure I can't be impartial about myself )

I would think Adel and YB are both completely confirmed at this point, so no need to analyze.

[Adel]

ok lets talk. Jayln, I am really interested in your analysis on Nanook and ChaosOmega.

ChaosOmega: I am really interested in your analysis of Nanook and Jayln

Nanook: I am really interested in your analysis of Jayln and ChaosOmega.

Until then..

unvote: Streeflo

YB, I would like for you to join me in holding back your theories until all of our perspective scum have laid out a good case for who the other scum is.