New York 181 -- Game Over

[davesaz]

@Egg, what do you think of my other two points on Ika?

[Egg]

@Egg, what do you think of my other two points on Ika?

The town block stuff doesn't really bother me. The Elusive stuff I've already been over, so yes, I could see it.

[House]

Sort of. It's more that he's specifically using names and telling us what he thinks about who is a power role.

Do you think that is anti-town or scum?

[SilverWolf]

Leave me alone, I'm interacting with ABR.

Revisit this issue later if you can't figure it out.

Reminder to self, if House asks me any questions for the rest of D1, make sure not to answer them.

[Egg]

House , maybe both. Anti town for sure. Still debating on whether it's scum or not.

[SilverWolf]

I'm not sure what to think of her, but she is on my overly-long Potential Scum list.

Who are the rest of the people on your list?

[Klingoncelt]

[

I got one, whos do you suspect is sk? (yes there is a motive for my sk hunt)

Not a question I was expecting to see you ask.

What does everyone think of ika's question about the sk?

Ika knows lots about setups & mechanics, if he thinks there's an SK, there probably is.

20 players; T:S ratio is usually 3:1, that's 15 Town and 5 Scum.

So:
1 scumteam with 5 members or
1 scumteam with 3 members, 1 scumteam with 2 or
1 scumteam with 4 members, 1 SK or
2 scumteams with 2 members each, 1 SK

[ika]

kling you know this is an open setup right?

[SilverWolf]

[

I got one, whos do you suspect is sk? (yes there is a motive for my sk hunt)

Not a question I was expecting to see you ask.

What does everyone think of ika's question about the sk?

Ika knows lots about setups & mechanics, if he thinks there's an SK, there probably is.

20 players; T:S ratio is usually 3:1, that's 15 Town and 5 Scum.

So:
1 scumteam with 5 members or
1 scumteam with 3 members, 1 scumteam with 2 or
1 scumteam with 4 members, 1 SK or
2 scumteams with 2 members each, 1 SK

This is an open setup. It's in the opening post.

4 Mafia Goons
1 Serial Killer (Immune to Investigation)
1 Cop
1 Doctor
13 Townies

[House]

House , maybe both. Anti town for sure. Still debating on whether it's scum or not.

I'd find it difficult to buy as scumplay, as I'd imagine they'd be far more likely to keep such opinions to themselves lest they give themselves away later when their PR reads start turning up dead.

[Klingoncelt]

PSA

: If somebody directs a post to a specific player, please reserve your comments until that player responds.

kthx.

Belay that request.

I'll take answers from anyone con mucho gusto.

[House]

King - Hasn't done anything except jump on TSO. Answering he likes SK stands out, but I don't know what to make of it. Need to see more before I commit to a read here. Call him slightly scummier than my null pile I guess.

Kling is a

her

, please.

Anyway, I like being the SK because it's much easier to play as a Townie - I'm trying to kill off the Mafia too, you see. I don't have to deal with busing (I won't hesitate to bus as needed, I expect the same from my partners.) I don't have to protect any partners. When I'm Town I'm either a useless/weak Vanilla, or I'm a PR that's totally paranoid about getting NK'd. So, as an SK I get to play as Town and kill the hell out of everyone at Night. Good times!

I am Town this game, btw.

So KC, what do you think about the fact SW rolled scum this game?

I'm not sure what to think of her, but she is on my overly-long Potential Scum list.

Wanna wagon her?

I think I wanna wagon her.

[ika]

well im going to add klint to the town pile for that, i dont see her faking a townslip like that

pedit: house who are your top 2 town reads, top 3 scum reads and top sk read atm?

[House]

PSA

: If somebody directs a post to a specific player, please reserve your comments until that player responds.

kthx.

Belay that request.

I'll take answers from anyone con mucho gusto.

Belay that belay.

it's not hard to give somebody a chance to respond first, and it's far more helpful to not shit up the thread and ruin the inquisitor's efforts to give them some time before piping up with your own 2 cents.

[House]

pedit: house who are your top 2 town reads, top 3 scum reads and top sk read atm?

Not keen on egg's play so far, but I don't like him for a D1 lynch because he's simply too good an asset to risk mislynching.
Silverwolf is pinging scum to me, but I'm looking for input from others who are familiar with her scum game to confirm I'm not paranoid.

As far as top town reads go, I'd prefer not to give scum targets, thanks.

As far as sk goes, I frankly wouldn't be surprised if it's you.

[Klingoncelt]

pedit: thats exactly why iw as askign who does everoyn think is sk. look how many commented on it. wanna bet that one of the people who said something are sk?

tbh im waiting for day 2 where i can really amp up the wifom quesitons

To me, scum is scum. I don't care if it's SK or Mafia. They all have to die and in what order doesn't really matter. So I have no need to SK hunt at this time. I get why you asked though now that you stated why. I would prefer no outing of PR's with this same tactic however.

I learned a lot playing an SK. Like I said, it's much easier to blend in with Town. It's also more relaxed because near the end the SK can try to get leashed in order to make it to endgame. The SK will start out killing as many Town PRs as possible, trying to even up the numbers between Mafia and Town. It never hurts to get rid of the SK.

[House]

House , maybe both. Anti town for sure. Still debating on whether it's scum or not.

I'd find it difficult to buy as scumplay, as I'd imagine they'd be far more likely to keep such opinions to themselves lest they give themselves away later when their PR reads start turning up dead.

EBWOP:

It does however fit sk play because there are two reasons why a player might be pinging a little scummy, and that's if they're either a PR or scum. An SK would need to have a good bead on which is which in order to maximize his/her chances to survive to the endgame while simultaneously avoiding the lynch and NK him/herself.

[SilverWolf]

pedit: thats exactly why iw as askign who does everoyn think is sk. look how many commented on it. wanna bet that one of the people who said something are sk?

tbh im waiting for day 2 where i can really amp up the wifom quesitons

To me, scum is scum. I don't care if it's SK or Mafia. They all have to die and in what order doesn't really matter. So I have no need to SK hunt at this time. I get why you asked though now that you stated why. I would prefer no outing of PR's with this same tactic however.

I learned a lot playing an SK. Like I said, it's much easier to blend in with Town. It's also more relaxed because near the end the SK can try to get leashed in order to make it to endgame. The SK will start out killing as many Town PRs as possible, trying to even up the numbers between Mafia and Town. It never hurts to get rid of the SK.

That's nice. Who is in your long list of potential scum besides me?

[SilverWolf]

Wanna wagon her?

I think I wanna wagon her.

I have no idea why you are trying to gang up with others to wagon me, continue to talk about me like I'm not here, and refuse to talk to me when I ask you a couple questions.

It's rude.

[House]

Serial Killers typically con as town (hence the existence of FBI Agents, which is notably absent in this game), so our SK has nothing to worry about from our PR's and stands to lose nothing by picking up crumbs and defending them should they be wagoned, thus earning them town cred when the PR claims.

[House]

Wanna wagon her?

I think I wanna wagon her.

I have no idea why you are trying to gang up with others to wagon me, continue to talk about me like I'm not here, and refuse to talk to me when I ask you a couple questions.

It's rude.

Buckle your seatbelt then, because here's more:

Silverwolf is pinging scum to me, but

I'm looking for input from others who are familiar with her scum game to confirm I'm not paranoid.

[SilverWolf]

idgaf about the Sk right now

I'm guessing one of the people obsessed with talking about it has that role.

[SilverWolf]

Wanna wagon her?

I think I wanna wagon her.

I have no idea why you are trying to gang up with others to wagon me, continue to talk about me like I'm not here, and refuse to talk to me when I ask you a couple questions.

It's rude.

Buckle your seatbelt then, because here's more:

Silverwolf is pinging scum to me, but

I'm looking for input from others who are familiar with her scum game to confirm I'm not paranoid.

You think I can't read? I already saw that. I'm not blind.

[House]

Wanna wagon her?

I think I wanna wagon her.

I have no idea why you are trying to gang up with others to wagon me, continue to talk about me like I'm not here, and refuse to talk to me when I ask you a couple questions.

It's rude.

Buckle your seatbelt then, because here's more:

Silverwolf is pinging scum to me, but

I'm looking for input from others who are familiar with her scum game to confirm I'm not paranoid.

You think I can't read? I already saw that. I'm not blind.

If that's true, your previous post is disingenuous, because I had already explained why I asked KlingonCelt her opinion on making a wagon on you, so you were misrepping my intentions.

VOTE: SilverWolf

[Klingoncelt]

I'm not sure what to think of her, but she is on my overly-long Potential Scum list.

Considering how many posts I have in this game, you should be able to figure something out about me by now.

I have. That's why you're on my potential scum list.