Mini 452 NBA All-Stars Mafia-Game Over!

[xyzzy]

Xdaamno is scum for completely overreacting.

Note my sig.

[Xdaamno]

Eugh, wtf is this. 'Scum for completely overreacting'?

Four main points:

1. What constitues overreacting to be a scum tell? The basis behind it being a scum tell is that the player is paranoid and reacts to the slightest attack against them. In this case, my

person

was attacked and not my alignment. What reason would (hypothetically) a scum player have to strongely react against a point that dosen't imply they're scummy?

2. I do this in every game I play in, and I have to say this very statement in every game I play in. When I find something to pick at because it has so many holes, I pounce on it hardly. Because of this, it will appear that I overreact against the slightest and weakest points.

3. Why would you definitvly label such a weak point as 'Xdaamno is scum' rather than 'Xdaamno is probably scum'? It's a circumstantial scum tell at most, not a definitive point.

4. If any player looked back, they'll see as soon as the wagon started on me you thought me to be by far the scumiest players, hardly reviewed anyone else and haven't let off since. At the least, this makes you an untrustable source; and you're high on my scum list anyway.

No strawmanning.

[Thok]

Official Vote Count

Xdaamno (2): (inHimshallibe, IH)
inHimshallibe (0):
Fletcher (0):
The Central Scrutinizer (0):
Sonicpulsar (0):
xyzzy (0):
YogurtBandit (0):
IH (0):
mlaker (0):

Not Voting (7): (Fletcher, Sonicpulsar, xyzzy, YogurtBandit, mlaker, Xdaamno, The Central Scrutinizer)

With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

EBWOP: In my last post I referred to "both" mafia... should be "all" mafia, obv.

[Xdaamno]

I think it unlikely that both mafia were on the lynching wagon yesterday, as at least one tends to try not to pile on. Therefore, one of myself, xdaamno, and Fletcher are probably scum. That's my take at the moment.

Hmm. I doubrt Flether's scum, and I know I'm pro-town, yet I doubt scum would point this out intentionally. My take is, from hindsight, though something probably wouldn't happen, it dosen't change whether it can or not. If that makes sense, which it probably dosen't.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

You're saying I wouldn't mention my name as possible scum based on a site-wide generalization if I were scum. I would. But don't let that screw you up. The percentages say that you or Fletch have a greaterlikelihood of being scum.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

EBWOP: *or I.

[Xdaamno]

You're saying I wouldn't mention my name as possible scum based on a site-wide generalization if I were scum. I would. But don't let that screw you up. The percentages say that you or Fletch have a greaterlikelihood of being scum.

I know what you mean - as in it's entirely possible scum would point out something incriminating against themselves; after all, it's less damaging than if someone else uncovers it (Even if this isn't a strong tell), but it just dosen't happene consciously that often IMO.

[Sonicpulsar]

Xdaamno, I'm trying to basically tell you why everyone suspects you. You're over zealous (at least in my eyes). This leads to me thinking you're either scum, or won't do much good for the town.

The reason you won't do much good for the town is the fact that you're grabbing so much attention. It's easier for scum to float under the radar. I mean, if I really thought you were scum, I'd have voted for you a while ago. This makes me think you're crappy town. But that's just me. Perhaps others (yourself included) think your tactics are genius and game winning. I don't. But as long as you're having fun, who cares.

For the first time on this site, I'm angry at someone for being such an idiot. Really. You're saying you think I'm town, but also I'm not doing much good because I'm grabbing so much attention. Has it even fucking occured to you I thought not holding back views would work in the long term, and that this is how I always play? This is so patronizing and childish it's almost a scum tell for manipulation. If you don't have anything nice to say, shut up.

Wow. I covered my tracks as much as I could explaining why

I

think you're not a good town player. If you reread the last sentence of my previous post, you will understand what follows. I'm no longer having any fun discussing this game with you. I now think you're scum.

Vote: Xdaamno

[Xdaamno]

-_-'

I post an argument, and you respond by 'I'm not having fun. I think you're scum.';

what

? You should be annoyed at me out-of-character, not accusing me of being scum because I got annoyed at you; the two are completely uncorrelated.

[inHimshallibe]

Gah, we don't have any scum dead, and lurking is killing us. (Thank you Captain Obvious.)

unvote

I go back and forth on Xdaamno every time I read this thread. I think I've made up my mind that scum would just not be as active in his position.

vote: xyzzy

- don't like his behavior toward schismatized.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

I'm still convinced inHim is scum... more of intuition than anything else.

[YogurtBandit]

I'm still convinced inHim is scum... more of intuition than anything else.

You arent voting him?

[The Central Scrutinizer]

I'm still convinced inHim is scum... more of intuition than anything else.

You arent voting him?

I was, but I unvoted because I was lonely.

[mlaker]

I believe Xdaamno's claim, I don't know how good of an argument we have against him today. I'll look over it, but I don't really believe as strongly as I did that he's scum.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

What this game needs is a new wagon.

vote: mlaker

[inHimshallibe]

What this game needs is a new wagon.

vote: mlaker

Psst... wrong move... xyzzy...

o.o

[The Central Scrutinizer]

What this game needs is a new wagon.

vote: mlaker

Psst... wrong move... xyzzy...

o.o

You're still on my scumdar. Why would I listen to you?

[Xdaamno]

I'd say 'I don't like inhim's posts, but coincidentially I don't like xyzzy's either', or something like that, if I knew I wouldn't be lynched for backseat driving or something.

Oh wait...

[YogurtBandit]

I'm still convinced inHim is scum... more of intuition than anything else.

You arent voting him?

I was, but I unvoted because I was lonely.

Suit yourself.

[inHimshallibe]

YB, please add something original to the game conversation. All you've done is make side-comments to quotes.

Who do you suspect?

[inHimshallibe]

-dunk-

[YogurtBandit]

YB, please add something original to the game conversation. All you've done is make side-comments to quotes.

Who do you suspect?

Well, The pepole who are flipping about over Xdaanmo because I really dont see the case against him.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

[YogurtBandit]

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Tired?